A report from Pittsburgh City Controller Rachael Heisler recommends ways the Pittsburgh Public School Board can improve communication with residents and elected officials.
The report, released Tuesday, notes that the district has faced a “growing number of challenges” over the past few years, including declining enrollment, “alarming low levels of math and reading proficiency,” a growing budget deficit and chronic student absences.
“Managing these problems in a transparent way that centers students and families will require strong cooperation between the board, administration, and community,” the report said. “Yet the board’s members have continually voiced frustrations regarding their capacity to properly assess the impacts of their own policies and ability to work cohesively as a body. Similarly, PPS staff survey responses indicate a ‘toxic culture’ where educators feel unsupported and unheard.”
The main recommendation was for the district to retain a third-party “consulting partner” specializing in improving board governance and “building a culture of shared trust.”
But taking into consideration the budget difficulties the district faces, the controller recommended that the district only pursue this route if it finds neutral ways to pay for it, such as grants or donations from charitable partners.
The consultant should be able to help streamline board policies, review and adjust the superintendent evaluation to match the district’s goals, and implement a “student-centric policy governance model,” the report said.
The policy governance model has been used by education advocacy organizations such as the National School Boards Association. Among other things, it encourages continual evaluations by board members and superintendent of the district and of themselves.
In a self-assessment survey the school board conducted in 2023, members indicated there were “disagreements regarding how the board should interact with the administration,” according to Ms. Heisler’s report. Having a governance model in place would lay out clear policies for such matters, the report said.
In a statement Wednesday, school board President Gene Walker said the board had made “significant progress” in the area of governance.
The board already is working with a consultant, the Council of Great City Schools, to provide “expert board coaching services to improve collaboration and leadership capacity,” Mr. Walker said.
“Our board is actively engaged in processes that strengthen our ability to work cohesively and effectively, and the assumptions made in the report do not fully reflect the progress or current state of affairs. While we welcome constructive feedback, it is crucial that assessments of our work are grounded in accurate and up-to-date information,” Mr. Walker’s statement said.
The report also recommended that the school board bolster communications with city officials, something Pittsburgh City Council members have bemoaned in the past.
In 2022, council created a “City-School District Partnership,” though since then, the “two bodies have not convened and there are no plans to do [so] as of the publishing of this report,” the controller said.
The legislation outlined five areas in which the two bodies might be able to combine resources, including school safety, emergency child care and transportation.
Population stagnation is an issue that both city government and the school district face, along with financial difficulties.
“While Pittsburgh’s municipal government and school district have distinct areas of policy focus and state mandates, they share a common mission of making the city a hospitable, equitable, and safe place for families to live and grow,” the report said
The report also noted that many council and school board members already have working relationships, and the partnership would allow any issues to be formally addressed as a group.
Mr. Walker said the school board remains “open and committed to collaboration.”
“We continue to be actively engaged in discussions with the City of Pittsburgh around shared concerns such as school safety, transportation, and expanded learning opportunities, and will continue to explore productive ways to work with the city to benefit our students and families,” Mr. Walker said. “We remain focused on moving forward with effective governance, transparency, and collaboration to ensure the best outcomes for the students of Pittsburgh.”
Staff writer Megan Tomasic contributed to this report.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.