College debt is stressful. Some students and families consider taking fewer classes or extra time to finish their degrees — or not going to school at all— rather than take out student loans.

But there’s a lot of research that shows borrowing can pay off in the end, said Michele Zampini, senior director for college affordability at The Institute for College Access & Success.

“I would never want to see someone otherwise invested in going to college not go at all just because of borrowing,” she said.

As college becomes increasingly expensive, the world of student loans can be confusing, particularly for students. Experts say taking the time to figure it out can make all the difference.

Advertise with us

Which loans should I take out?

“You always want to maximize the federal loans available before you look at the private market,” Ms. Zampini said.

Typically federal loans are cheaper, more accessible and don’t require a co-signer. A lot of students have the opportunity to get subsidized federal loans, and they have more built-in protections, she said.

Federal loan types include the Direct Subsidized Loan for undergraduates — which is based on financial need— and the Direct Unsubsidized Loan for undergraduate and professional degree students, which awards up to $20,500 depending on grade level. There is also the Direct PLUS loan, which allows parents to take out money for their undergraduates.

But when there’s a funding gap, that’s when families should look at the private market. This is where the research comes in — it’s not a one-size-fits-all deal.

“I encourage families to have those conversations early on, to look into all of the options,” said Amy Sawdey, a higher education access partner at the Pennsylvania Higher Education Assistance Agency. “Look into all of the different options that are out there. Explore what's best for your family and your situation, because it is different for everyone.”

Advertise with us

If applying for private loans, students should carefully compare the rates and terms for all of their options, being wary of the fine print. Flexibility is preferable should you have surprise circumstances and your income isn’t as high as anticipated after school, Ms. Zampini said.

Some states have their own loan programs that are also worth looking into. In Pennsylvania, the only state loan is called PA Forward, a PHEAA loan students in-state and out of state can apply to that “gives our Pennsylvania families a more affordable option with more affordable interest rates,” Ms. Sawdey said.

Two students going to the same school or living in the same neighborhood may have different eligibility for loans. Big banks can advertise the most, but they might not check all of your boxes.

“Do your research, compare across the board … dig a little deeper rather than the first big name that pops up on Google,” Ms. Zampini said.

How do I apply?

“It all goes through the FAFSA — your school will then package what aid they can give to you,” said Ms. Zampini.

Advertise with us

All students must apply for federal student aid by filling out the FAFSA, the Free Application for Federal Student Aid, which led to $114.1 billion in federal grants, loans and work study funds in 2023, according to the Federal Student Aid annual report. To apply for these, as well as determine eligibility for state and school aid, students must fill out the FAFSA form.

Filling out the form might only take up to 10 minutes after it was streamlined for the last application year. For the 2025-2026 school year, applications will open on Dec. 1, 2024, and close by June 30, 2025.

“Once the FAFSA is available to file for the coming year, do it as quickly as you're able to,” said Ms. Zampini.

Students should apply to multiple schools and list them all on the form, said Diona Brown, director of PA School Services at PHEAA. Schools often have stark differences in the amount of institutional aid they can provide, so casting a wider net means students will receive more offers and can identify if there’s a gap.

Once accepted into a school, students will be given an aid offer which includes all of the loans they’re eligible for in a full financial breakdown, including work study options — a way for students to earn money to help pay for school through on campus work. Students can either take out what they offer, or take out less should they figure out an alternative way to cover the costs.

Advertise with us

To apply to the PA forward loan, students can visit PHEAA’s website or reach out to a PHEAA access partner, who are based in each Pennsylvania county. Private loans will vary, but families should always be aware of deadlines.

Scholarships & grants as an alternative

Students are often missing all the scholarship money universities have to offer, Ms. Brown said.

“There’s so much money out there,” she said. “More scholarship money, less loans.”

The PELL Grant, which assists students in low-income households, is the largest federal grant program offered to undergraduates which students can qualify for through filling out the FAFSA. Though federal grants are not first come, first serve, some college and state scholarships are, so it’s important to be mindful of deadlines and apply annually.

PHEAA runs the PA State Grant Program, which Pennsylvanians can apply to after filling out the FAFSA. The amount awarded depends on your financial situation and the school you choose to attend in Pennsylvania — smaller grants are available for schools out of state.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania colleges have their own scholarships to offer, which can be awarded through applying to the school or through separate application processes. At the University of Pittsburgh, the Nordenberg Leadership program awards five graduating high school seniors in Pennsylvania a full-tuition scholarship for eight terms

High grades and performance can earn students merit scholarships at schools across the country, helping lower tuition regardless of household income.

“There's so much scholarship money out there that goes wasted because a lot of students don't take the time to apply for scholarships,” said Ms. Brown. “Especially students coming out of high school, there’s a lot of local scholarships available that have a lot less competition.”

Tips & tricks

As lawsuits push back the promise of student debt repayment relief, it’s more important than ever for students to know what they owe. Ms. Sawdey’s biggest recommendation is for students to be at the table alongside their parents.

“We want your students to be sitting down with you,” she said. “Ultimately, a majority of these loans are going to be in the student's name. We really want our students to understand that this is something they’re signing up for.”

Advertise with us

Though the money feels like a number, she encourages students to start thinking about what it would look like to repay those loans, using tools like a net price calculator and then having conversations. Families should also be applying for aid and scholarships every year, she said, as many families stop searching for additional funding after the first year their child leaves for college.

Ms. Brown reminded families that there are a variety of pathways to get a degree, from online school to community college, to employers with tuition reimbursement programs.

“There's a variety of different things like that that I think families should look into to help make the right decision for them,” she said.

Students should always be aware of repayment terms and interest, Ms. Zampini said. Federal loans have fixed interest rates, while private loans depend on the lender and rise over time.

Income might not be as high as expected or job availability might be limited after school, so families should look for options that will work with varying economic situations.

“We really encourage families and students to borrow what you actually need,” said Ms. Sawdey, who noted that interest rates mean students have to pay back more than they borrowed. “Try not to borrow the excess if you can.”