An ongoing disagreement between Pittsburgh Public Schools and Passport Academy was recently settled, a step that could save the charter school from closing.

Ira Weiss, Pittsburgh Public’s solicitor, confirmed that an agreement was reached between the two schools, seemingly settling a yearslong dispute that came to a head in June when school directors began a process that could have led to the district not renewing Passport’s charter.

Now, the settlement withdraws claims made by Pittsburgh Public and Passport over the years regarding charter school tuition payments, and lays out a more detailed enrollment process for Passport, a school aimed at educating students who have dropped out of high school.

“This is a unique program and the district's pleased to work out a way to change and make this option available to these families,” Mr. Weiss said.

Advertise with us

Passport Academy first opened in the 2014-15 school year to help students who had dropped out of school earn a high school diploma, not just a GED. Today the school enrolls around 130 students in ninth through 12th grade from Pittsburgh Public and surrounding districts.

But issues quickly arose between Pittsburgh Public and Passport.

Read More

From the time Passport opened, Pittsburgh Public has dealt with ongoing problems with the school enrolling students who had not dropped out of high school, Lisa Augustin, Pittsburgh Public’s director of charter accountability, said in June.

Given the ongoing issue, district officials previously created an affidavit for students under the compulsory age that required a signature from the student and parent stating they had dropped out of school. But Passport for years submitted late affidavits and those that were not signed.

Three years later, in 2017 and 2018, Passport filed its own claims with the Pennsylvania Department of Education alleging PPS improperly calculated tuition fees owed to Passport. School districts pay per pupil tuition to charter schools as per state law.

Advertise with us

Issues continued over the years, but were once again brought to the Pittsburgh Public School Board in June when Ms. Augustin gave a presentation that detailed issues with student enrollment at Passport, along with violations to student performance, with low proficiency rates on standardized tests and curriculum not aligning with state standards.

Based on those allegations, Ms. Augustin recommended the district not renew Passport’s charter. Under state law, approved charters can last between three and five years. Afterwards, the charter school must reapply with its local school district, which then decides whether to renew or deny the charter.

School directors later that month voted to begin the state’s charter nonrenewal process for the Downtown school.

Around that time, Pittsburgh Public also filed a lawsuit in the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County, suggesting that a review of materials from the 2021-22 school year found there were discrepancies associated with enrollment dates of 26 students. Those students, the suit states, did not attend Passport for the entire school year.

Because of that, Pittsburgh Public overpaid in tuition by more than $568,000.

Advertise with us

Correspondence regarding the discrepancies was sent to Passport in September and November of 2022 but a response had not been received by the time the suit was filed.

But under the agreement, Mr. Weiss said, Pittsburgh Public’s case will be discontinued. Claims made by Passport against the district will be withdrawn.

“Clearly the board expressed at the meeting the desire to try to keep this program going because dropouts don't have a lot of options for their education,” Mr. Weiss said. “Out of all that came the agreement that, basically, each side is going to withdraw its claims.”

The agreement also created the new enrollment process, which includes a verification process to ensure the applying student has dropped out of high school that will include a parent's signature. There is also now a clear definition of dropout and the agreement creates a mediation process the schools will go through if either entity believes there’s financial issues. The process will take place before any claims are created with the state or a lawsuit is filed.

Now that an agreement was reached, Pittsburgh Public School directors are expected to approve a charter renewal agreement with Passport, Mr. Weiss said, “assuming a proper one could be reached, and I have no doubt it will be.”