Lauren Hlavenka has already seen the disappointment on her children’s faces when she broke the news that their school, Hyde Elementary, is closing.

But rather than letting her three children be sad, Ms. Hlavenka is painting the transition, which will take place in Moon Area School District during the 2025-26 school year, as an adventure.

“I just told them that next year … it'll be an adventure, and trying to spin it positively for them,” Ms. Hlavenka said Thursday. “But no, they were definitely bummed because Hyde, it's just a small, close-knit family vibe there. The principal knows every single child, sibling, parent. It's just a really great school. It's just really, really sad. It feels like a death.”

School directors on Tuesday in a 5-4 vote decided to close Hyde, a kindergarten through fourth grade school of 220 students surrounded by sprawling neighborhoods. Directors Adam Gill, David White, Robert Zieger and Sarah Simmons voted against the motion.

Advertise with us

The vote finalized nearly a year of uncertainty among parents and families, many of whom came together in an attempt to save Hyde, where 43% of students are economically disadvantaged while almost 14% are in special education classes. The school, one of seven in the district of 4,035 students, also has a large Hispanic population, making up 23% of students, and 24% of children at the school are English language learners.

Residents packed meetings, presenting data and emotional testimony for why Hyde should remain open. Red and white signs reading “Keep 5 Neighborhood Schools” are still scattered throughout Moon neighborhoods. And an online petition in favor of saving the school has garnered more than 900 signatures since it was posted in July.

“We have outstanding teachers,” Moon resident Nancy Augustine said Thursday. “We want them to have appropriate class sizes and a diverse student population, and Hyde had all of that. So it leaves us just shaking our heads about how a board can make such a determination.”

The idea of closing Hyde was first presented in September during one of several town hall meetings that took place over the past year.

During the sessions, administrators said they were considering two options — closing Hyde at the end of the 2024-25 school year and moving those students to Brooks Elementary, about a 10 minute drive away, or remodeling Hyde and having all five elementary schools stay open. But officials highlighted that Hyde is the third most expensive elementary school in the district to run, with an annual operating budget of $107,650.

Advertise with us

And the building, listed in fair/poor condition, also needs $9.7 million in renovations.

Closing Hyde, administrators said at the time, would allow the number of additional staff needed for equitable supports to drop from 21 to eight across all elementary schools. Combining students from Hyde and Brooks, they added, would also allow the district to implement a multi-tiered system of supports to address diverse students needs and to allow for tailored instruction.

And the closure would permit the district to fund construction projects at the middle and high school — including additional classroom and cafeteria space — that are needed now as those populations grow, Superintendent Barry Balaski said during a September meeting.

Now, the board is moving forward with the plan to consolidate into four elementary schools.

“My primary concern is the education of your children and how we can continue to improve it,” school board president Amy Stuart said Tuesday. “If the administration had requested $10 million to improve Hyde and presented the evidence that was the best academic model I would have supported it without hesitation. … However, that’s not the case.”

Advertise with us
Red and white yard signs are scattered throughout Moon neighborhoods, reminders of a nearly yearlong fight to save Hyde Elementary. (Megan Tomasic / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

But many families impacted by the closure are now questioning data used to make the decision.

Melissa Eiker, the former Hyde PTO president whose son completed fourth grade last year at the elementary, pointed to several new housing and apartment developments being built across the township, potentially bringing in new families that could lead to schools being overcrowded, she said.

“The numbers don't add up,” Ms. Eiker said.

She noted that Hyde is one of the more diverse schools in the district, and has the highest number of low-income students receiving free or reduced lunches.

Many residents also highlighted those numbers, pointing to the Mooncrest neighborhood that is home to a large Hispanic population. There, students and families are offered services from Mooncrest Neighborhood Programs, which teaches English as a second language and offers after-school programs. Those students also receive English language lessons at Hyde.

Advertise with us

Because of that, many Mooncrest parents are worried a larger elementary school would not offer sufficient ESL classes. Many are also concerned about easily accessing a school that is farther away.

“I say no because this school is closer,” Karina Rodriguéz said Thursday. “We know already the school and they’re good teachers and the principal is a very good person.”

Standing outside his Crestridge Drive home, Sean O’Brien, whose 10-year-old daughter will start fourth grade at Hyde next week, said the vote to close the school “was expected,” adding that “it seemed pretty clear from the jump.”

He’s now questioning what will happen to the Hyde building once it closes. The district did not specify plans for the building.

He pointed to his sister-in-law, Alyssa Tutino, whose youngest daughter is going into third grade at Hyde. Rather than finishing out her elementary career at the neighborhood school, she will now be sent to a different school for fourth grade during the 2025-26 school year before entering middle school the year after.

Advertise with us

“It’s hard to help them adjust because this is all they know,” Ms. Tutino said while standing outside her Old Thorn Road house. “It happens, there’s things in life, it’s not always easy, but it doesn’t have to be this way.”

For Ms. Tutino, this is the second time her family has been impacted by the district closing Hyde. The elementary school was shuttered during the 2015-16 school year in a redistricting attempt that put kindergarten through second grade in Brooks Elementary and third and fourth graders in McCormick.

At the time, Ms. Tutino said her oldest daughter, now a high school junior, was forced to move from Hyde to Brooks.

“She just had a really hard time feeling like it was her school,” Ms. Tutino said. “She very much felt like an outsider, that she was just like plopped into this situation. We went through a period of her being anxious about going to school, going to school functions.”

But the school was later reopened after the community elected new school directors.

Advertise with us

“When she came back to Hyde, it felt like home to her,” Ms. Tutino said. “She felt way more familiar. It was like she didn’t miss a beat.”

Several board members on Tuesday also raised concerns about the decision, including Mr. Zieger, who suggested that data presented regarding Hyde “was inconclusive.”

“I’m disappointed in the outcome,” Mr. Zieger said. “I feel your frustration but at the same time I think we need to recognize that this board went about it the right way and when everybody says they didn’t take this decision lightly, I believe that.”

Several community members, including a group of 40 parents who largely led to fight to save Hyde, are now planning to continue their efforts in hopes the board reverses its decision.

“From our side, I think there's still options to try and get them to see the light,” Ms. Eiker said, “to understand there are ramifications.”