Starting this fall, the days of wearing graphic tees and sweatpants are over in the Sto-Rox School District.

At a school board meeting late last month, the board voted to approve a dress code that will mandate solid color tops and bottoms, prohibit fingertip length skirts and regulate hats and other headwear, among other rules.

School board President Cameron Culliver said the initiative is not in response to any incidents or behaviors throughout the district. He said the conversation was about “standardizing” the district as a whole.

“It wasn't necessarily about concerns that we had … it was really about bringing back some structure to our districts,” he said.

Advertise with us

The district hopes the new dress code will save more time for teachers and parents and turn attention back to learning in the long run, although some education experts believe implementation of dress codes can be controversial.

The decision has been well-received by Sto-Rox parents, Mr. Culliver said, but many students have been against the move.

At public meetings held to discuss the upcoming school year, parents expressed interest in bringing their kids to Sto-Rox, but the absence of a uniform was unappealing to them, said Mr. Culliver. Sto-Rox has been in the midst of a struggle to bring students who had left to charter schools back to the district. Many charter schools require uniforms for students.

Sto-Rox follows other districts in the region, such as McKeesport and Woodland Hills, that have dress codes. District spokesperson Dan Rinkus said the move is not in response to other schools and Sto-Rox is trying to “forge its own path.” Sto-Rox has had other versions of a dress code in previous years.

The new dress code is a “pretty standard K-12 dress code,” said Richard Thompson Ford, a Stanford University law professor and author of “Dress Codes: How the Laws of Fashion Made History.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Thompson Ford said there are times when dress codes are needed, but they do often promote stereotypes — often along racial and gendered lines — especially for girls.

“A big potential problem is lopsided enforcement, where girls bear the brunt,” he said. “This becomes a broader issue about women’s bodies, that they are a source of distraction, which is a serious concern.”

Racial discrimination can be complicated — prohibiting durags, hats and sagging jeans, which the Sto-Rox guidelines do, can “all be potentially racially coded,” he said.

Mr. Culliver said school board members, four of whom are Black, were very conscientious of these concerns.

“It’s not about race or offending certain groups,” he said. “Us going this route was genuinely about asking ourselves, how can we bring back some pride?”

Advertise with us

Much of the reasoning is grounded in taking a “proactive, not reactive” approach to combating bullying. Mr. Culliver attended Sto-Rox as a student when the district had standardized uniforms, and “never felt different because the uniform was the uniform.”

Mr. Rinkus said the district decided against uniforms because “there's some flexibility built into the dress code,” which Mr. Culliver said allows for a degree of personal expression, too.

“We want parents and students to have options, but we also don’t want things to be where they were previously,” Mr. Rinkus said.

Mr. Thompson Ford said sometimes leaving it up to individual discretion can be far worse than a dress code.

“Even in the absence of a dress code there's usually some unwritten norm that people can be disciplined for clothing deemed inappropriate. Absence of a written dress code makes a moving target,” which disproportionately affects girls and students of color, he said.

Advertise with us

But it all comes down to how it’s enforced, said Mr. Thompson Ford.

“When you have these changes in dress code, what’s the on-the-ground effect in terms of enforcement rates? It’s hard to tell in advance,” he said.

Mr. Rinkus said the district intends to give students and families “as much grace as possible.”

“I do think it’s important that at the outset the district is responsive, proactive and equitably,” he said. “This is obviously new, so we’re just going to be responsive to these situations as they come.”

It was important to Mr. Culliver and the school board to announce the decision early to give families time to prepare and reach out if they need help. Students have been directed to talk to their counselors if they cannot comply with the dress code. In school, a student store and donation supply will be available, and the district intends to work with local businesses to help provide new clothing options.

Advertise with us

Guidelines were posted to Sto-Rox’s website on June 28, about two months before the school year starts on Aug. 26.

“The more clear and unambiguous the dress code is the better, so people know in advance,” Mr. Thompson Ford said. “So there’s no ambiguity for enforcing the dress code.”