Pittsburgh Public School directors are moving forward with a public hearing for Passport Academy Charter School, one of the first steps the district must take as it considers not renewing the school’s charter.
School directors on Wednesday unanimously voted to begin the state’s charter nonrenewal process for Passport Academy, a Downtown Pittsburgh school that educates students who have dropped out of high school. Director Yael Silk was absent.
The decision came after district administration this month listed several alleged violations to the state’s charter school law including that Passport violated its written charter agreement by enrolling students who have not dropped out of high school, underperformed academically and did not communicate with PPS staff.
A public hearing date will now be set. During the hearing, overseen by an officer with no connection to the case, testimony will be heard from Pittsburgh Public and Passport. The hearing officer at the end will issue a recommendation on whether the charter should be renewed. Pittsburgh Public will vote on the recommendation; Passport can appeal.
“For every parent, every student and every staff that signed up to educate these young people in Passport Academy, it’s not personal,” school Director Dwayne Barker said. “It is not your fault. We want you all to continue to stand, we want you all to continue to fight. There were some things that was brought up that just wasn’t right and when the hearing comes out the answers will come out as well.”
The district first discussed Passport’s charter nonrenewal during an education committee meeting in early June. Since then, community members and Passport students and officials have spoken in favor of the school’s charter being renewed. On Wednesday, several people wearing shirts supporting Passport attended the board meeting.
Read More
“No matter the decision we’re dealt Wednesday, know that we’re optimistic that we will ultimately receive a renewed charter,” Joseph Oliphant, Passport’s principal and CEO said in a statement on the school’s website. “Even if a public hearing is granted and the PPS board votes not to renew the charter, we can and will appeal the decision.”
He added that the process for nonrenewal can take more than a year “and I can assure you that our school will remain open and committed to providing the quality educational experience our students deserve during this process.”
Passport Academy first opened in the 2014-15 school year to help students who had dropped out of school earn a high school diploma, not just a GED. Today the school enrolls around 130 students in ninth through 12th grade from Pittsburgh Public and surrounding districts who each participate in a “blended learning” program, meaning students spend the first three hours of the day taking in-person classes followed by two and a half hours of online learning.
Under state law, approved charters can last between three and five years. Afterwards, the charter school must reapply with its local school district, which then decides whether to renew or deny the charter. A charter may be revoked or not renewed based on: one or more material violations of the charter agreement, failure to meet requirements for student performance, failure to meet generally accepted standards of fiscal management, violation of any provision of law from which the charter school has not been exempted and conviction of fraud.
This is the second time Pittsburgh Public is considering Passport’s charter.
Earlier this month, Lisa Augustin, the district’s director of charter accountability, laid out several alleged violations to the state’s charter school law including that Passport violated its charter agreement by enrolling students who had not dropped out of high school, something that was initially written into the agreement. The problem, she said, has been ongoing since the school opened. Pittsburgh Public officials worked to rectify the situation by coming to an agreement that if a student was under the compulsory age the student and parent would sign an affidavit — which was to be provided in the charter’s enrollment packet — stating they had dropped out of school. But the school for years submitted late affidavits and those that were not signed.
Violations were also found in student performance. State data shows that 5.7% of Passport students were proficient or advanced in Pennsylvania State Assessments for literature. No students were proficient or advanced on the exams for algebra and biology. The school has made improvements in its graduation rate. During the 2021-22 school year, Passport reported an almost 45% graduation rate, an increase from nearly 13% in the 2018-19 school year.
And issues also reported after the school did not respond to requests for information, something that has persisted for years, officials said.
Because of those ongoing violations, Ms. Augustin recommended the board not renew the charter. It is only the second time in 14 years she has made that decision.
School Director Sala Udin said he is now looking forward to the hearing where Passport officials will have the opportunity to have a dialogue with the school board.
“I know that there’s a lot of problems with the fact that they did not complete many of the required activities and I’d like to get a better understanding of what is missing and the reasons why it's missing,” Mr. Udin said. “I’d like to hear that directly from the Passport staff.”
He noted that it’s now up to Pittsburgh Public to keep Passport students in the school system.
“I don’t want us to turn our backs on them because we know what will happen to many of them,” Mr. Udin said. “It will not be a pretty picture.”
Director Emma Yourd added that as the district works through its facilities utilizations plan — a controversial proposal that could lead to the closure or consolidation of some schools — officials should “think about ways we can serve these students who are some of our most vulnerable and most harmed students.”
“If there are young people that are listening, this is not about you, whatever this decision is,” board President Gene Walker said. “It’s about the rules that are set to make this system work effectively and properly. Process matters and at some point we have to figure out how to do this work effectively so that the people that benefit from this aren’t harmed by the stuff that we do as adults.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.