A school aimed at educating students who have dropped out of high school might not have its charter renewed by Pittsburgh Public School officials after the district said it found several violations against the state’s charter school law.
District officials on Tuesday recommended board members not renew the charter for Passport Academy Charter School, located in Downtown Pittsburgh. The recommendation, made by Lisa Augustin, the district’s director of charter accountability, followed findings that Passport allegedly violated its written charter agreement by enrolling students who have not dropped out of high school, underperformed academically and did not communicate with PPS staff.
School directors are expected to vote on the recommendation during this month’s legislative meeting. If directors do not renew the charter, it could set the 10-year-old school up for closure.
“This school served a purpose that was going to help students who may not have been helped otherwise. … But these violations can no longer go unnoticed,” Ms. Augustin said. “So just in doing my duty I have to recommend that this school not be renewed.”
Passport Academy’s principal and CEO did not respond to an email seeking comment.
Passport Academy first opened in the 2014-15 school year to help students who had dropped out of school earn a high school diploma, not just a GED. Today the school enrolls around 130 students in ninth through 12th grade from Pittsburgh Public and surrounding districts who each participate in a “blended learning” program, meaning students spend the first three hours of the day taking in-person classes followed by two and a half hours of online learning.
Read More
Under state law, approved charters can last between three and five years. Afterwards, the charter school must reapply with its local school district, which then decides whether to renew or deny the charter. This is the second time Pittsburgh Public is considering Passport’s charter.
But on Tuesday, Ms. Augustin laid out several alleged violations to the state’s charter school law, which were found after Ms. Augustin and her team conducted annual site visits over the past five years and had regular correspondence and oversight.
Under state law a charter may be revoked or not renewed based on: one or more material violations of the charter agreement, failure to meet requirements for student performance, failure to meet generally accepted standards of fiscal management, violation of any provision of law from which the charter school has not been exempted and conviction of fraud.
According to Ms. Augustin, Passport Academy violated its charter agreement by enrolling students who had not dropped out of high school, something that was initially written into the agreement. The problem, she said, has been ongoing since the school opened. Pittsburgh Public officials worked to rectify the situation by coming to an agreement that if a student was under the compulsory age the student and parent would sign an affidavit — which was to be provided in the charter’s enrollment packet — stating they had dropped out of school.
But, according to Ms. Augustin, the school for years submitted late affidavits and those that were not signed.
“They continue to not do this, which has led to a lot of problems and also leads to us not really having any assurance that they’re enrolling students who are only dropouts,” Ms. Augustin said.
She also found violations in student performance.
According to state data, 5.7% of Passport students were proficient or advanced in Pennsylvania State Assessments for literature. No students were proficient or advanced on the exams for algebra and biology. Ms. Augustin noted that district officials are considering pandemic-related impacts when looking at student performance over the past five years.
The school has made improvements in its graduation rate. During the 2021-22 school year, Passport reported an almost 45% graduation rate, an increase from nearly 13% in the 2018-19 school year. According to Passport’s website, students must have at least a 2.0 grade point average to graduate, completed a minimum of 10 service learning hours, finished required coursework, presented a graduation project and received credit in eight core subjects.
But, Ms. Augustin said, the school’s “curriculum is gravely below standards and has many other issues including not being completely aligned to PA core standards.”
Violations were also reported after the school did not respond to requests for information, something that has persisted for years, officials said.
No violations were found in terms of fiscal management, children with disabilities or fraud.
But since the violations that were found have persisted for several years, Ms. Augustin recommended the district not renew the school’s charter. It is only the second time in 14 years Ms. Augustin has made the recommendation. The first was in 2012 when district officials said Career Connections Charter High School failed to meet the conditions, standards and procedures laid out in the original charter agreement. The case went through an appeals process. The school closed three years after the initial vote, Ms. Augustin said.
“I do not take this lightly,” Ms. Augustin said. “I know how difficult it is with the charter school law to not renew a charter school, as it should be because an authorizer shouldn’t just be able to not renew on a whim. I work with the charter schools as much as I can to avoid this, to avoid actual violations.”
School Director Sylvia Wilson added that this is not the first time the district has discussed violations by Passport Academy regarding enrolled students.
“I think you’ve given ample time in the past even though we know that this has been ongoing,” Ms. Wilson said. “You’ve given [them] time and time again to correct it and that has not occurred.”
During the meeting, Ms. Augustin also recommended that the school board renew the charter for Propel Hazelwood, a K-8 school that educates 270 students.
A final vote on both schools will take place during the June 26 legislative meeting.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.