The Chartiers Valley School District will continue its search for a new superintendent after directors announced during a contentious meeting Tuesday night they were no longer considering the top candidate.

In an emailed statement, district Solicitor Rebecca Hall said school directors are not moving forward with hiring Philip Martell as superintendent. A reason was not provided. The board had originally been slated to hire Mr. Martell for a five-year contract that would have begun July 1, according to a board agenda. He would have made a salary of $204,000.

But Mr. Martell, who currently serves as River Valley’s superintendent, said in an email to the Post-Gazette that “after considering the volatile political climate, I chose to stay at River Valley, where I love my job. I applied because it was closer to my home but not at the sacrifice of unnecessary political attacks by parents and the teachers' union. It would do a leader no good to take a position where your leadership credibility is under question from the beginning.”

Chartiers Valley has been searching for a new superintendent since February, when former Superintendent Johanna Vanatta announced she was taking the top spot at Blackhawk School District in Beaver County.

Advertise with us

But on Tuesday, many who packed the school board meeting opposed the hiring of Mr. Martell, who previously worked as assistant business manager in the West Mifflin Area School District, director of finance and operations at Wilkinsburg School District, and director of finance and operations and superintendent of the Connellsville Area School District, according to his LinkedIn. He also served as president of the Elizabeth Forward School Board and held a seat on the Allegheny Intermediate Unit board.

In 2015, Mr. Martell was at the center of an investigation by the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office. The investigation started when West Mifflin Area School District officials said they had documents that made it appear he submitted duplicate expense reports for conferences he attended while working at the district and serving as an AIU board member.

The West Mifflin school board at the time permitted the district solicitor to take legal action against Mr. Martell for reimbursement or restitution of any “improper payments” related to the travel fees. The matter was then referred to the district attorney’s office.

The investigation ended that same year when Mr. Martell agreed to pay $1,013 in restitution to West Mifflin.

In his statement, Mr. Martell said he hopes the Chartiers Valley “community understands the significant issues facing the school district, which will be bankrupt in two years with a $5-8 million deficit. The selfishness of the teachers union will only hurt the district in the long run and be crippling to the students of the district educationally with larger class sizes and a lack of resources."

Ms. Hall added that the board will now discuss a plan to obtain a list of qualified and interested individuals for the position and will update the public on the process as soon as possible.