Pittsburgh Public Schools officials are sounding the alarm on countywide property assessment appeals that could lead to a nearly $20 million reduction in the district’s budget.
In all, PPS could experience an almost $6.7 million reduction in real estate tax revenue and need to pay $13.4 million in tax refunds for the 2022 and 2023 tax years as decisions on assessment appeals continue to be made, according to a worst case scenario presented by Chief Financial Officer Ron Joseph during a budget workshop on Monday.
“I don’t like to be alarmist but based on the numbers that are coming in we will need to take action sooner than later and start looking at places we can make some reductions in the short-term to be able to weather this,” Mr. Joseph said.
Assessment reductions across Allegheny County have hit a high not seen since the 1990s, county officials previously said, putting both the city of Pittsburgh and its school district on the hook for potential massive tax refunds and revenue losses as a result of the assessment cuts. And it has led to several Downtown properties being granted millions of dollars in reductions.
The commercial reductions are based on two major factors: high office vacancy rates created by the COVID-19 pandemic and hybrid work, and a steep drop — from 87.5% to 63.5% — in the common level ratio, the number used in appeals hearings to calculate the taxable value of a property. That number has again fallen to 54.5% this year and could go even lower in 2025.
And decisions on appeals are still being made, meaning further impacts could soon hit the city and PPS. The deadline to file assessment appeals for the 2024 tax year is March 31.
Read More
For Pittsburgh Public, the slew of appeals comes as the district is facing a projected deficit of $7.7 million in 2023. That number is expected to grow to almost $29.9 million in 2024 and $28.9 in 2025.
Those projections show the district using its unassigned fund balance to cover the 2024 deficit, dropping the account to $14.2 million. That would bring the fund balance out of compliance, “which means going into 2025 if we took no action we wouldn’t be able to pass a budget in 2026 that would be able to be balanced by our fund balance,” Mr. Joseph said.
That scenario worsens, however, with the assessment appeals. Under those projections, the district’s deficit would grow to $46.5 million in 2024 and $45.4 million in 2025.
Mr. Joseph cautioned that the district is still waiting on appeal decisions, but “if we were to just take the worst case scenario, layer it on, we’re out of money at the end of this year because that would be taking a $20 million additional hit and layering that on to our projected $38 million deficit. So this is the worst case scenario.”
He noted that the last time the district saw a similar scenario was during the 2012 countywide reassessment. While the reassessment led to lower assessed values in the district, the institution was able to counter monetary losses through the countywide collection of earned income tax, which at the time was going into effect for its first full year.
But this time, Mr. Joseph said, “I don’t think we can count on seeing a dramatic increase in our earned income revenue to be able to cover all of the projected loss that we’re going to have in our real estate tax revenue.”
Now, the district could look into short-term options such as raising taxes to help offset impacts from the appeals. Officials are also considering closing or consolidating schools in response to the growing budget deficit and declining enrollments.
“We wanted to give the rest of the board the information of where we currently stand as a school district so that we have this information going into pulling the budget together for 2025,” school director Emma Yourd said. “So it’s tough information for us to have and I appreciate you sharing it with us in the spirit of transparency and making sure that we as a board can make the best decisions.”
School director Gene Walker said the district and community now have to deal with the “stark reality” that PPS cannot continue in the direction it’s been going.
“The discussions that we’re having now are the ones that are going to hopefully help us make the impact that we need to make long term as painful as that’s going to be because this is about as gloomy as it gets,” Mr. Walker said.
“I just hope everybody’s ready. We’ve got to strap in and get ready to kind of do everything possible, cause I talked about wanting to have a school district in 10 years. If things keep going the way they’re going we won’t be here in three years and that’s even more scary. We’ve got a lot of work to do.”
Megan Tomasic: mtomasic@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.