For the second time in eight years, Pine-Richland School District is facing a lawsuit over its policies toward transgender students, this time from a parent alleging its nondiscrimination policy is unconstitutional and violates parents' rights.
The lawsuit was filed on Friday in U.S. District Court for Western Pennsylvania by the conservative group America First Legal on behalf of a plaintiff referred to as "Jane Doe," seeking to end the enforcement of the district's policy on gender and gender identity.
Pine-Richland Spokeswoman Erin Hasginer said the district is reviewing the complaint but declined to comment on pending litigation.
The district updated its nondiscrimination policy in 2017 to include gender identity after three students, who have since graduated, sued the district in federal court when the school board adopted a policy that restricted students to using either unisex bathrooms or bathrooms that match their biological gender.
The lawsuit came forth after the board reversed a longstanding district policy that allowed students to use restrooms matching their gender identities, launching the district into the national spotlight.
The court determined the policy violated the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, in a first-of-its-kind opinion about the argument that transgender students are protected under these clauses.
Now, Pine-Richland is again under scrutiny, with the new lawsuit alleging the nuanced nondiscrimination policy is a "reckless disregard" of fundamental parental rights.
Wally Zimolong, the attorney representing the anonymous plaintiff in the current lawsuit with America First Legal, called the updated policy "offensive" and the "secretive nature of the policy" problematic.
The policy addresses the resources offered to transgender students, including the right to keep a student's transgender status private at school.
It affirms a student's right to be addressed by any name or pronoun they prefer and the right to request a school support team, including a guidance counselor, school psychologist, and other staff members, to provide a "supportive learning environment" before or during their transition.
The policy dictates that before a parent or legal guardian is notified of a student's transition or preferred pronouns, school staff work closely with the student to "assess the degree to which, if any, the parent/guardian will be involved in the process and must consider the health, wellbeing, and safety of the transitioning student."
“[In some cases] informing parents/guardians about a student disclosure carries risks for the student, such as physical and/or emotional abuse, abandonment, and/or removal from the home,” the policy said.
"Disclosing this information to other students, their parents/guardians or other third parties may violate privacy laws, such as the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA)."
The complaint said Jane Doe wrote to the School District and requested her daughter not be referred to any mental health counselor or social worker for evaluation. She also asked to be notified within three days if her daughter expressed "any matters related to gender identity or gender dysphoria."
Following her notice, the complaint said Jane Doe met with the principal of her daughter’s school and a guidance counselor, where school representatives told her that they would not fulfill her requests unless they were "legally required to do so" and that she had no parental rights under the policy.
Later, in an email correspondence, the district reiterated to Jane Doe that it would not comply with her demands and would work with the student, not the parent, on such matters.
The complaint alleged that Jane Doe has "legitimate concerns" about her daughter’s "risk of transitioning" after she discovered her watching videos online about transitioning and transgender advocacy. She also said her daughter recently started hanging out with other children who identify as transgender or who are "socially transitioning."
Jane Doe said she’s concerned if her daughter does show signs of "gender confusion or gender dysphoria," the school will begin affirming her before Jane Doe is aware and can take steps to help her child obtain "appropriate medical care."
The lawsuit said the policy violates constitutional rights under the 5th and 14th Amendment and the fundamental liberty in making child-rearing decisions.
"The [policy] requires that everything be conducted in secret from the parents," Mr. Zimolong said. "If it applies to all students, it would apply to even kindergarteners — to me that's a radical angle to this policy."
Mr. Zimolong was unable to cite evidence of Jane Doe's daughter or any other student engaging in the "psychological evaluation of the student, including students as young as 5, conducted by government psychologists, who assist the child with a plan in transitioning to a new gender," alleged in the complaint.
Cameron Lwin, whose sister is transgender and recently graduated from Pine-Richland High School, said the policy was beneficial to her mental health, and helped her come out to her friends and her teachers before coming out to their family.
As an educator himself, Mr. Lwin said discretion is well within the legal boundaries of schools.
“If you go to any guidance counselor, or therapist, they'll tell you straight up unless the child is of harm to themselves or harm to other people, they will not share any of the information that goes on within that session,” he said.
“Regardless of what America First thinks, claiming that you are transgender is not a harm to yourself or other people.”
Mr. Lwin also said it’s essential for students to have trust with school staff, especially members of the LGBTQ+ community.
A 2022 national survey from The Trevor Project, a nonprofit organization focused on suicide prevention efforts, found that 45% of LGBTQ youth “seriously considered” suicide within the past year. It also found that fewer than one in three transgender and nonbinary youth found their home to be gender-affirming.
Mr. Lwin said that in some of the schools he’s been employed in, students were often reluctant to share what was going on at home fearing it would get back to their parents.
Without privacy policies like Pine-Richland’s, he said it would be “extremely dangerous.”
“It would be very difficult to have genuine conversations with your students.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.