Recalculate the monthly budget. Set up automatic payments. Check the bank account.
Millions of Americans have taken those steps in the past few weeks as student loan payments returned after a three-year, COVID-induced pause.
Payments resumption follows five pause extensions and a failed attempt from President Joe Biden to cancel some loans for 43 million Americans.
In Pennsylvania, nearly 1.8 million borrowers have a total of $66.9 billion in federal student loan debt, per federal data. The average Pennsylvania college graduate is saddled with nearly $40,000 in debt.
The Post-Gazette spoke with four regional borrowers about how the loan payment pause impacted them and how they plan to pay their loans moving forward.
The majority of those interviewed expressed a desire to see some sort of higher education cost reform as millions of graduates juggle loan payments with other expenses.
Loan payments will ‘eat away’ at a family’s savings
Alex Rosenblatt will be paying off his loans for the next 20 years.

The 36-year-old, who lives in Robinson with his wife and two young children, has about $50,000 in remaining debt from his two degrees. His wife has an additional $27,000.
Under their current payment plan, the Rosenblatt household will pay roughly $600 a month for two decades. Mr. Rosenblatt anticipates loan payments will “eat away” at his family’s savings.
“[That money] could easily go to something else,” Mr. Rosenblatt said. “We could put it in savings, we could spend it … there's a plethora of things we could use it on.”
During the pauses, Mr. Rosenblatt paid off his car and some other debts with the money that would have gone toward his student loans.
He was happy when the Biden administration announced its plan to cancel some loans — and disappointed when the Supreme Court ruled in June that plan was unconstitutional. But, he added, he wasn’t sure how much the loan cancellation plan would have solved a system that he believes is fundamentally flawed. Mr. Rosenblatt thinks federal loans should have minimal, if any, interest rates.
“[Loan cancellation] would have helped a lot of people. It would have helped me a lot. It would have helped my wife,” Mr. Rosenblatt said. “But I think it was still a Band-Aid and things would have probably gotten back to where they were in a couple of years.”
He would also like to see universities — especially publicly funded schools — lower their costs. The bulk of Mr. Rosenblatt’s loans came from Penn State, where he received his undergraduate degree in electrical engineering. He later earned his master’s in business administration from Waynesburg University in Greene County, which had more “bare bones” costs.
Mr. Rosenblatt had $100,000 in federal and private student loan debt after completing both degrees. About three-quarters of that debt came from Penn State.
“Going to a publicly funded university should not land you in a fortune of debt,” he said.
‘We are overselling higher education’
After earning her master’s degree in 2009, Julie Saeler was overwhelmed.

The health and physical education graduate had amassed $42,000 in student loan debt during her undergraduate and graduate studies at Kent State University in Ohio. Mrs. Saeler, who had federal loans with 4.5% and 6.5% interest rates, said she lived paycheck-to-paycheck and relied on her tax return to buy anything “fun” for herself, like a bicycle.
When she married her husband, she had over $20,000 in student loan debt. And then the pandemic happened.
“When COVID hit, I was just thanking the Lord that my husband and I both kept our jobs through COVID,” said Mrs. Saeler, who lives in Butler. “Life was on hold, we lived very simply. It's a gift to not have interest, so I [decided] to pay $1,000, $1,500 a month — whatever I could — and just throw all that money at my loans.”
Thanks to the payments that Mrs. Saeler made during the pause, her debt level is now at $4,000 — and she expects that to be canceled this June.
As a physical education teacher in the Butler Area School District since 2019, Mrs. Saeler will soon qualify for $5,000 in loan forgiveness for teaching in a low-income school district for five years.
While she waits to qualify for loan cancellation, Mrs. Saeler is paying the minimum monthly payment on her remaining loans. She expressed gratitude for her situation.
As a college graduate and public school educator, Mrs. Saeler believes there needs to be “reform” in America’s education system. She thinks college education is overpriced. She’d also like to see more young people understand the weight of college debt and consider pursuing other options like trade school, as her husband did.
“We are overselling higher education,” Mrs. Saeler said. “There’s not enough value in it.”
An Ohio State alumnus ‘won’t notice’ loan payments resuming
Jon Ruffley equated the loan payment pause as kicking a can further down the road.

Mr. Ruffley had about $10,000 of remaining debt headed into the pandemic. Now that payments have resumed, he’ll pay around $100 every month.
“I won’t notice it,” Mr. Ruffley said, describing his monthly payment as “very small.”
Mr. Ruffley, who grew up in Cincinnati and now lives in O’Hara, graduated from Ohio State in 2015 with a bachelor’s degree in chemical engineering and $27,000 in federal loan debt. He said the Columbus school’s tuition costs are “bang for your buck.”
He later attended Pitt, where he earned his Ph.D. in chemical engineering at no cost because his education was funded by the federal government through his employment.
While he was in graduate school, Mr. Ruffley paid off a large bulk of his undergraduate loans, starting with the ones with the highest interest rates.
In his conversations with college graduates, Mr. Ruffley has realized many of them still don’t fully understand how their student loans work. He recalled convincing his peers to first pay off their loans with the highest interest rates rather than the loans with the biggest balances.
“It’s been surprising to me how a lot of younger people just don't have the financial literacy to deal with basic [finances],” said Mr. Ruffley, who serves as the president of Ohio State’s alumni club of Pittsburgh. “...I figured out there are a lot of people who never got that information.”
‘If I had known … I would have done things differently’
Rachel Brumbaugh graduated the University of Pittsburgh in 2020 saddled with $150,000 in federal student loan debt.

Knowing she’d have high monthly payments once the pandemic-induced payment pause ended, Ms. Brumbaugh invested “pretty much everything she could” while there was no interest on her loans.
Now, her monthly payments are roughly $1,000 per month — a “pretty big” portion of her monthly budget that Ms. Brumbaugh feels “well-positioned” to pay. She’ll be paying off her loans for the next decade.
Ms. Brumbaugh — who earned her Pitt bachelor’s degree in philosophy and communication science disorders, and her Pitt master’s degree in speech language and pathology — doesn’t regret going to Pitt. But she does wish she was more cost conscious when she made her decision. She recalls being more concerned about which schools she got into and where her friends were going.
“I absolutely loved my time at Pitt. I wouldn't say I regret going to Pitt, but they were definitely more cost effective options for me to get my degree,” she said. “[I wish I] explored some of those [options] a little bit more and [applied for] scholarships … I just didn't work hard enough for scholarships.”
The Pitt graduate, who grew up in Blair County and currently lives in Huntingdon, W. Va., works for Troutwood, a financial services company. She credits her Troutwood connections and experience for making her feel “confident and comfortable” to pay such a high monthly payment.
She believes there need to be more policies in place to educate prospective students about college debt. She referred to her former lack of understanding as her “biggest hurdle.”
“If I had known the implications of my high debt, I think I would have done things differently,” Ms. Brumbaugh said. “I’m less worried about [loan] forgiveness, and more so about educating people on how to not put themselves in a situation where they’re going to be really, really worried about debt payment.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.