Since Hamas launched a surprise attack on Israel over a week ago, Carnegie Mellon graduate student Ben Koby said he and his Jewish peers have been alarmed by antisemitic attitudes and actions across the nation. 

At CMU, some Jewish students have refrained from wearing religious items to avoid being publicly identified as Jewish, he said. Other Jewish students have been threatened or called slurs, said Mr. Koby, who serves as co-president of the university’s Jewish Graduate Student Association. 

There’s a “very large degree of fear” that Mr. Koby finds “unacceptable.” 

“All Jewish students know that when Israel goes to a war, the antisemites come out of the woodworks,” Mr. Koby said. “Seeing as this looks like it's going to be a long conflict, we felt it was critical that we start organizing to protect ourselves and protect our interests.”

Advertise with us

On Oct. 7, the Islamist, militant movement Hamas launched a surprise attack on Israel, killing hundreds of men, women and children and capturing others. Israel has since declared war on Hamas. As of Monday, over 1,400 Israelis and 2,700 Palestinians have died in the conflict, officials say.

Universities have become a hotbed for intense rhetoric surrounding the Israel-Hamas War. Over 30 student groups at Harvard University faced sharp backlash after penning a letter that placed all blame for the conflict on Israel. At the University of Pennsylvania, school leaders are in hot water after the Philadelphia school hosted a Palestine Writes festival last month that featured speakers who have made antisemitic remarks. 

And at campuses across the country, students have organized vigils and protests in support of Israel or Palestine. Last week in Oakland, around 100 people attended a vigil for Israel at Schenley Plaza. A group of people in support of Palestine also attended the rally, chanting phrases like, “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free,” and “Hey hey, ho ho, the occupation’s got to go,” The Pitt News reported.

Later that week, around 300 people rallied in support of Palestine in Oakland.

Mr. Koby said he believes there’s a “fine line” between pro-Palestinian sentiment and Hamas support. He’s seen both at CMU. 

Advertise with us

In response to threats and safety concerns, Jewish students at CMU and Pitt are planning to take self-defense classes together. Mr. Koby stressed the importance of Jewish safety and unity during the war.

“There's an old saying: two Jews, five opinions,” he said. “We can be a very heterodox bunch, but when people start threatening us, everyone comes together.”

Pitt student Eitan Weinkle said he’s heard “very little” about antisemitic acts and attitudes on campus, but still feels less safe at school now than he did two weeks ago. Mr. Weinkle, who serves as president of Student Coalition for Israel at Pitt, has family and friends who live in Israel, and knows someone who died at the attack on a music festival near the Israel-Gaza border. 

The Pitt senior expressed disappointment with Pitt Chancellor Joan Gabel’s initial statement about the attacks. Ms. Gabel’s first statement did not explicitly mention Hamas. 

She later released a longer statement that explicitly condemned Hamas’ “unconscionable, barbaric acts.”

Advertise with us

“Like many of you over the past several days, I have continued to watch the horrific and heartbreaking scenes resulting from Hamas’ unprecedented terrorist attacks against Israel and innocent civilians. In no uncertain terms, we condemn these unconscionable, barbaric acts,” part of her second statement reads.

Similarly, CMU President Farnam Jahanian released an initial statement that did not mention Hamas. He also released a second statement that directly condemned Hamas.

Mr. Weinkle called Ms. Gabel’s first statement “inadequate.” The second response was “better,” but he still believes Pitt needs a better system in place to respond to events like this.

“There are ways to support all students while not sacrificing moral ambiguity,” he said. “They really dropped the ball on making all of their students feel safe: Israeli, Palestinian, Jewish, Muslim. Islamophobia and antisemitism are skyrocketing right now… [Pitt’s] primary concern is keeping all of their students safe, and at first they did not do a good job of doing that.”

A Squirrel Hill native, Mr. Weinkle grew up blocks away from the Tree of Life synagogue, where the the worst antisemitic attack on U.S. soil occurred nearly five years ago. 

Advertise with us

When instances like the synagogue shooting and Hamas attack occur, Mr. Weinkle believes it’s important for the Pittsburgh community to rally together and support each other.

“We don't want to forget who we really do care about, and that's everyone else around us,” he said. “We want to uplift, listen to and support everyone.”