Pittsburgh Public School directors are revisiting the idea of closing some school buildings as they face a potential budget deficit in coming years.
By 2024, the district is expected to have a $28 million operating deficit, chief financial officer Ronald Joseph said during Monday’s business and finance committee meeting. While there would be enough money in the district’s fund balance to account for the deficit next year, the district could be in the red by 2025 if they do not take action to reduce expenditures.
One option, Mr. Joseph said, is looking into the district’s school buildings, which currently have room for 40,000 students. But today the district enrolls around 19,000 students.
“We really need to look at our footprint, the number of buildings we have,” Mr. Joseph said. “Those are the things that all need to be considered because we are operating more buildings than we should, which means that our resources are spread out over all those buildings and we also have to maintain those buildings.”
This year, the district, which runs 54 schools, is operating on a $685 million budget that passed in December in a 5-4 vote. Of expenses included in the budget, $199.4 million is for salaries and $135.4 million is for benefits, social security and retirement. Of revenues, $383.8 million is coming from local sources such as the real estate and earned income tax and $280.3 million is from the state. The budget is almost 3% more than the $668.3 million 2022 budget, and includes a deficit that is $10.6 million lower than what was seen last year.
But given the potential deficit increase over the next few years, Superintendent Wayne Walters on Monday said his administration will present plans for consolidation to the school board after the start of the year. Conversations will fall after the next budget is voted on because of the required timeline for public hearings and necessary notifications.
“There’s no way that we can do it right now to impact the coming budget that we’re voting on in December,” Mr. Walters said.
At Pittsburgh Public, discussions around school consolidation come as the district grapples with fewer enrolled students and rising charter and cyber school tuition rates.
But across the country, districts are facing similar challenges that were exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic.
According to Thomas Dee, a professor in the Stanford Graduate School of Education, the pandemic led to a max exodus of students from public schools, who instead chose to enroll in charter and cyber schools. Those students have not returned. Additionally, districts will soon lose millions of dollars in pandemic relief funds, which end next year, forcing many to reexamine their budgets to avoid a financial cliff.
Those factors, Mr. Dee said, could force schools to close buildings in the coming years.
“This is a very broad phenomenon,” Mr. Dee said. “We’re hearing about under-enrolled schools and pressure to close those schools and possibly lay off teachers from around the country.”
In recent years conversations around closing schools have taken place in Denver, Indianapolis and at several rural north-central Pennsylvania schools where almost 40 elementary schools have closed, SpotlightPA reported.
But the phenomenon isn’t new.
According to Douglas Harris, an economics professor at Tulane University and director of the National Center for Research on Education Access and Choice, school closures have happened for years as school enrollments and finances remain intertwined.
“It’s almost always funded-related because nobody wants to close buildings,” Mr. Harris said. “It’s the most painful thing that any district ever has to do. It’s really a last resort when they really can’t serve students well given the existing number of school buildings.”
Pittsburgh Public in 2005 proposed closing 20 schools. In 2021 the district revisited the topic when they proposed closing six schools including Miller PreK-5 in the Hill District; Fulton PreK-5 in Highland Park; Woolslair PreK-5 in Lawrenceville; Manchester PreK-8 in Manchester; Allegheny 6-8 in the North Side; and Arsenal 6-8 in Lawrenceville.
That plan was ultimately tabled after school directors determined they did not receive enough public input.
But since that time enrollments have dropped by 25%. The district last year was also required to pay more than $19,300 per student in charter and cyber school tuition – an increase from almost $17,700 the year before – and around $46,500 for a student receiving special education services. School officials stressed that the district is not seeing an increase in students switching to charter and cyber schools; rather rates continue to rise. Still, 4,000 Pittsburgh students in grades K-12 attended local charter schools in 2021, according to district data. Another 1,000 attended cyber schools.
“We obviously can’t keep running like these,” school director Gene Walker said Monday. “We won’t have a district necessarily in five years if we run out of money and so we have to have those hard conversations that in the short-term are going to be very painful but the long-term hopefully has the impact on our kids and our district that we’re looking for.”
Mr. Walker said there has also been conversations about modernizing the district’s footprint among safety and operation committee members, which he chairs.
School director Devon Taliaferro said she is open to discussing school consolidation, but only if community members are included.
“I am more than happy to walk alongside you in how we have that conversation but if it does not include the voice of community I’m not interested in having the conversation because those are the people that it’s going to impact and affect,” Ms. Taliaferro said Monday.
While many school directors were open to discussions around school consolidation, several were frustrated that the district was facing a budget deficit at all. Many suggested administrators and school directors should have begun working on a plan months ago.
“I don’t know why we can’t pass a balanced budget now but I would like to say this budget deficit and budgeting with an operating deficit has become larger and more consistent over the last two administrations,” said school director Kevin Carter, who is chair of the business and finance committee.
School director Pam Harbin added that each year after the budget passes school directors agree they need to take a deeper dive into the district’s funding.
But that never happens.
“I can’t believe we’re here Oct. 9 and there’s going to be a new budget coming out Nov. 17 and then voted on in the beginning of December with three new board members and we’re like ‘This isn’t going to be a great budget because there’s a deficit,’” Ms. Harbin said. “I just don’t understand what we’re doing.”
Despite those concerns, Mr. Joseph said administrators are not “trying to arbitrarily hurt kids” by slashing staff. Instead, he said, the district wants to move to a model that ensures they are “operating schools in the best manner that we can based on the number that we are operating under.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.