When Bobby West is asked whether prospective home buyers should consider the quality of an elementary school while house hunting, he always has the same answer: do your own research and choose the community that is the best fit for your family.
As a realtor focusing on Southwestern Pennsylvania, Mr. West often faces the complex and intertwined question about school choice and home location.
But knowing the answer is different for every family, Mr. West often points people to services such as Niche.com while encouraging them to visit individual districts to see if it is a fit for their children.
“I do try to stay out of the specifics of it, because I don’t want to make promises about art class and recess. … But I definitely direct people to the district itself,” Mr. West said. “I know most of the districts are pretty accommodating as far as having people show up and do interviews and on some level engaging with the district about what they have to offer.”
School choice has been a growing movement in recent years, with some families considering which public school they want their child to attend while others look into charter and cyber options. The trend has caused families to heavily consider both the community and school district while house hunting. But it also has raised concerns among advocates who believe the choice of affluent families leads to higher rates of school segregation.
For potential homebuyers, experts recommend several tips while house hunting such as touring schools and meeting with administrators to learn about the district rather than just looking at test scores. They also recommend conducting your own research beyond what other parents say about a school and keeping an open mind about giving children a different school experience.
“Schools factor in hugely in family decision making about where to move. … And information about the schools isn’t driven necessarily by visiting the schools and kind of going to see what they’re like but more often by word of mouth,” Genevieve Siegel-Hawley, a professor at Virginia Commonwealth University, said.
She noted that the informal information exchange that occurs at the coffee shop, the playground and through family and friends is “very simplified information like that’s a good school or that's a bad school.” But that oversimplification, she said, can amplify biases about particular school districts while ignoring other factors about the school such as student growth over time.
School choice has been a central focus since the pandemic when parents became concerned about COVID cases and how districts were responding in terms of masking and vaccines.
During the 2020-21 school year charter and cyber schools saw their highest enrollments with 169,253 students, data from the Pennsylvania Department of Education shows. That number has been slowly declining with almost 160,700 students attending charter and cyber schools during the 2022-23 school year, but it is still significantly higher than the 141,845 students reported in 2018-19, the last normal year before the pandemic.
And places such as Pittsburgh-based Niche.com, which helps people choose K-12 schools, colleges and places to live, saw increased usage in 2020 and 2021 when home interest rates were low and people were working remotely.
“There was a lot going on that prompted a lot of thinking around changing where they live and re-examining their school choices,” Niche founder and CEO Luke Skurman said. “But definitely we saw it come through in the data very strongly.”
Through Niche, users are able to see overall school district ratings for public schools and charter and cyber schools. Those ratings are then broken down by academics, teachers, diversity, clubs and activities, college prep and administration. From there, people can search for available houses within that district.
“A lot of home movers think about the neighboring schools, the quality of the schools,” Mr. Skurman said. “It’s a long-term decision and it’s often a factor whether they have children or not. It still can greatly impact the overall home prices as well.”
The site largely relies on community input and reviews and overall test scores such as state assessment proficiency and SAT and ACT scores.
While the tool is largely used across the country, Ms. Siegel-Hawley suggested that parents take a deeper look into the districts they are considering and not base their decision simply on things such as test scores, which she said “become a stand-in for school quality, and they are often closely linked to race and class, because those opportunities are distributed so unevenly along racial and economic lines.”
Instead, she said families should look into how students are growing year over year, especially in disadvantaged districts or at schools with historically marginalized populations.
“That suggests that the school’s doing a lot of work to counter some of the structural inequalities outside of the school,” Ms. Siegel-Hawley said.
Integrated Schools, a grassroots organization that works to redress the imbalance of racial and economic power in schools, also suggests meeting twice with administrators at the school families are considering and taking time to visit schools that aren’t at the top of their community’s sought-after list.
For Ms. Siegel-Hawley, another factor is recognizing your own biases and discomfort related to each person’s own experiences.
The goal, she said, is to realize “that it is possible to provide different experiences for their kids.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.