Redshirting — a term used to refer to coaches keeping a college athlete out of competition for a year to develop their skills — has found its way into kindergarten classrooms.
With “academic redshirting,” parents choose to delay the start of their children’s education for a number of reasons, such as developmental readiness. Twelve percent of parents with school-age children reported having redshirted a child, according to a 2021 study conducted by Morning Consult and Ed Choice.
This relatively common phenomenon has gained more traction since the pandemic when many parents did not want their children to start kindergarten virtually.
Cutoff dates typically are Aug. 1 or Sept. 1, meaning students must turn 5 before the cutoff to start kindergarten that year.
In Pennsylvania, kindergarten programs are established for children between the ages of 4 and 6, depending on local school board decisions, according to the Department of Education. Some states require students to attend kindergarten, but Pennsylvania does not mandate it.
James Cromie, director of communications and public relations for Bethel Park School District, redshirted his two sons, who both have May birthdays. That meant his sons started kindergarten when they were 6 years old.
When the time to enroll his oldest son in kindergarten came around, he feared he was not prepared, so he posted a poll on Facebook, asking for advice. The responses, many of which were from elementary teachers, spoke very highly of redshirting, he said.
“By doing it as 6-year-olds, what you see is kids who are much more developed, much more focused, much more alert and much more ready to learn, and we have never regretted it,” he said.
Brandi Zamboni, a kindergarten teacher in Baldwin-Whitehall School District, said she is glad her two kids, who have summer birthdays, took an extra year before starting kindergarten.
“I've never talked to a parent or a teacher that has decided to hold back a kid and regretted it,” she said.
Still, some have critiqued the practice for equity concerns and whether it truly benefits a child in the long term. And for students to stay back another year, it means that parents will typically have another year of child care cost — something that not all families can afford.
“Being old for your cohort is generally pretty beneficial in the younger years, but that kind of washes out as kids go on through schooling, so I generally do not think there are huge advantages to doing it,” Chloe Gibbs, a University of Notre Dame professor who studies early education, said.
She said parents ultimately make decisions based on their child’s particular situation, but she views redshirting as a sort of “Band-aid.” Instead of parents resorting to redshirting as an approach, schools should focus on policies that help level the playing field in early schooling, including offering preschool, lowering student-teacher ratios and reducing class sizes, she said.
“I would prefer that we think more comprehensively about the best ways to make sure all kids excel in these early years and get the skills that they need and are ready to move on to first grade,” she said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.