As Pennsylvania lawmakers continue to battle over a state budget, Western Pennsylvania school districts may begin to feel the pinch if the impasse continues beyond September.
An 11-day deadlock among legislators has left education funding in limbo, forcing school districts to operate with budgets that are not fully funded. Many districts in the Pittsburgh region are not yet feeling repercussions from the partisan battle as they rely on local and federal funding to pull them through the summer months.
But if the impasse drags on, districts might have to make hard decisions.
“Since the state budget usually passes in the summer, school districts are not typically providing services to students at this time,” said Mackenzie Christiana, spokeswoman for the Pennsylvania School Board Association. “But districts with low reserves or an extended budget impasse would force school districts to either borrow money or make cuts to the programs and services being provided, which would impact either their taxpayers or students.”
The House and Senate both approved a budget spending plan, but a signature on the floor of the Senate is needed before going to Gov. Josh Shapiro’s desk. And top Republicans already have discharged the chamber until September.
Republicans are upset with Mr. Shapiro because he said he would veto a voucher-style program in the budget that would give taxpayer-funded scholarships to students in low-performing public schools so they could attend private ones. Mr. Shapiro, who has long supported such a concept, initially supported the program.
It is now unclear when a budget could pass, leaving districts in the dark.
“It’d be nice to know what amount you’re going to get [from the state] because … trying to balance our budget with having two big unknown numbers creates an extra challenge,” John Zahorchak, chief financial officer for the Penn Hills School District, said. “It seems it should be unnecessary.”
It’s not the first time a state budget wasn’t passed on time. In 2015, it took nearly nine months for an impasse to end, and schools endured some of the most visible difficulties caused by the impasse.
Districts are required to pass a budget by June 30, the same day the state budget is due. But districts often do not know how much basic and special education funding they will receive from the state aside from estimates, making it difficult to finalize their finances.
At Penn Hills, 39% of their budget – which during the 2023-24 school year totals $97 million – comes from the state. For the 2023-24 school year, that could amount to $38.4 million. That money is used to educate 3,070 students, 63% of whom are considered economically disadvantaged.
Mr. Zahorchak said the district is not currently feeling any impact because they typically don’t see payments from the state until September or October. In the summer, they receive revenue from local taxes.
But if the impasse would extend past that point “we’re going to have to relook at things,” he said.
“We’d have to monitor our cash flow,” Mr. Zahorchak said. “I don’t think we’d really have to do too much in terms of taking out loans or anything like that unless it got into March, April. If it extended that long then we’re going to have to look at some sort of loan or some sort of program where we could get a small advance on some of the money.”
At Hempfield Area School District in Westmoreland County, 37% of the budget, or about $40 million, comes from state subsidies and reimbursements, business manager Paul Schott said.
Like Penn Hills, the district of 5,300 students is not seeing any immediate impacts from budget negotiations. That stability could be sustained for several months, Mr. Shott said, because about 58%, or $62.3 million, of the general fund comes from local revenue such as real estate taxes.
In a normal year, the Cornell School District takes out tax and revenue anticipation notes to cover expenses through July and August. By that point, local real estate taxes are paid. Because the district has funding secured through the summer and fall months, any impacts would not reach the district until the winter, Patrick Berdine, the district’s business manager, said.
Cornell, which encompasses Neville Island and Coraopolis, educates 520 students, 71% of whom are considered economically disadvantaged. Mr. Berdine said 29% of the district’s budget comes from state funding, or about $5 million.
“It’s not going to affect us financially unless this thing goes into 2024,” Mr. Berdine said. “We’ll have the money to operate.”
The stalemate
For Ms. Christiana, with PSBA, the impasse highlights why public schools maintain budget reserves, which can provide districts with money they can use to maintain educational services while the budget remains in limbo.
She noted that during the 2021-22 school year districts maintained $2.6 billion in unassigned fund balance. The problem, she said, is that balance would only cover one month of operating expenses, forcing districts to find money to pay for salaries, utilities and other mandated costs.
Education spending is at the top of the priority list for nearly all parties in the stalled state budget negotiations, including Mr. Shapiro, Republicans who control the Senate and Democrats who control the House. But a letter sent Wednesday by Republican Senate leader Joe Pittman of Indiana County illustrated how nearly all aspects of that spending could be jeopardized if a deal cannot be reached.
In the letter, Mr. Pittman told Rep. Matt Bradford, D-Montgomery and the House majority leader, that “payments to schools districts for basic education would be $550 million less" in 2023-24 than the $7.87 billion figure shown in a disputed spending bill unless more actions are taken. Those actions will require cooperation between the House and Senate.
Specifically, some line items in the $46.55 billion spending bill require extra instructions – typically contained in other bills -- to be carried out. Mr. Shapiro cited that need last week when he said he would veto the voucher program. Mr. Shapiro said a lawyer for his administration had found that the spending could not be enacted without separate “enabling” legislation, and House Democrats had already rejected a bill that contained the enabling language.
On Wednesday, Mr. Pittman said the same scenario applied to $550 million of the proposed basic education appropriation for 2023-24. He cited a conflict between existing “implementation language” state law and the way the proposed 2023-24 spending bill is written.
Another initiative affected by the need for enabling language, Mr. Pittman said, is the proposed $100 million in so-called “Level Up” funding that goes to the state’s 100 most financially strapped school districts. Even though the funding stream has been in place for two years, the “implementation language” has only been authorized on a year-to-year basis.
It was unclear Wednesday when leaders of the two factions – House Democrats and Senate Republicans – might start to hash out exactly how to produce bills containing the necessary language, get them through the House and Senate and to the desk of Mr. Shapiro.
A summary by House Democrats of education spending in the proposed spending bill showed a 9.1% increase over the current year for the combination of basic education and Level Up funding. It also highlighted the addition of $46 million for universal free breakfast and letting students who get reduced prices on lunch to instead get it free; a 3.7% increase in special education funding; and $10 million for a new student teacher stipend program.
Mr. Shapiro at a news conference last week made clear that aside from his decision to jettison the scholarship program he previously supported, the proposed spending bill is a good one and should be sent to his desk.
For many Republicans, though, Mr. Shapiro’s decision to abandon the scholarship program signified a betrayal of an agreement made behind closed doors at the bargaining table. The only step required to send the proposed spending bill to Mr. Shapiro is for Lt. Gov. Austin Davis – who also is president of the Senate – to sign the bill in front of senators while they are in the chamber. Top Republicans have shown no willingness to bring the Senate back to Harrisburg before September unless progress is made toward a deal.
While Mr. Zahorchak of Penn Hills and Mr. Berdine of Cornell are frustrated by the ongoing situation, they highlighted other problems with public school funding such as the requirement that public schools cover tuition for charter and cyber schools. They also suggested that the state needs to provide districts with their basic and special education subsidy amounts before school budgets are passed.
“It’s always a guessing game,” Mr. Berdine said of state funding.
The two are now keeping an eye on their district budgets to ensure their cash flow extends through the impasse.
At Penn Hills, Mr. Zahorchak remains positive.
“I don’t suspect the budget impasse will go beyond September, October,” Mr. Zahorchak said. “At least I’m hoping not.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.