When Patrick Gallagher began his chancellorship at the University of Pittsburgh in 2014, he recalls someone told him Pitt was a “sleeping giant.” 

Ruminating over the metaphor during the last week of his tenure, Mr. Gallagher doesn’t believe it’s apt anymore.

“I think [Pitt] woke up,” he said. “That feels really good.” 

Mr. Gallagher will step down from the chancellorship Sunday after nearly a decade in the top spot at the largest university in Western Pennsylvania that boasts five campuses, 34,000 students and 14,000 employees.

Advertise with us

A physicist by trade, Mr. Gallagher, 60, became Pitt’s 18th chancellor after working in various roles within the U.S. Department of Commerce for two decades. Upon exiting the chancellorship, Mr. Gallagher plans to enter a teaching role at Pitt, where he himself earned his master’s and doctorate degrees. He will be succeeded by the University of Minnesota's Joan Gabel, who will be Pitt’s first female chancellor.

In an interview with the Post-Gazette, Mr. Gallagher reflected on a tenure brimming with successes, challenges and changes at the state-related school. Mr. Gallagher leaves Pitt during a contentious time in higher education: Public confidence in higher education is at a historic low, tuition costs are rising, schools are still coming to terms with pandemic struggles, and, in Pennsylvania, the legislature has become increasingly comfortable with questioning Pitt’s transparency and operations. 

But still, Mr. Gallagher is confident that Pitt, as one of the top research institutions in Pittsburgh and the country, flourished under his leadership.

“I think this outward focus — looking at Pitt through the regional lens and as an anchor of the region and as something that's part of the region and participates and partners – I think that will have some long-lasting benefits,” Mr. Gallagher said.

Growing campus

The Oakland campus looks a bit different from when Mr. Gallagher took over nine years ago.

Advertise with us

Logistically, more students make their way around the urban campus than they did in 2014. Oakland’s undergraduate enrollment grew by over 6% during the Gallagher era – from 18,757 undergrads in fall 2014 to 19,928 in fall 2022. 

Mr. Gallagher said the “modest” enrollment boost happened despite the fact that Pitt was not in a “growth posture.” He attributed the increase to new educational options that popped up during his tenure.

Pitt certainly expanded educational and campus opportunities under Mr. Gallagher. In 2017, the university began enrolling students at its first new school in 20 years, the School of Computing and Information. A year later, Pitt established an Office of Sustainability. Construction is currently underway for a Campus Wellness and Recreation Center, a 270,000-square-foot facility that will include a pool, jogging track and basketball courts.

The university has also extended its reach in the Pittsburgh region. In 2018, Pitt opened its first Community Engagement Center in Homewood; three years later, it would open a second in the Hill District. These initiatives come as Pitt touts an economic impact of $5.2 billion annually. 

Simultaneously, Pitt is attracting record numbers of applicants. Over 58,000 people vied for a spot in Oakland’s 2023-24 first-year class. That’s a staggering boost compared to application numbers from just a few years ago — applicants rose by over 68% between 2021 and 2023.

Advertise with us

“A lot of that [growth] reflects a lot of hard work from admissions and Pitt becoming recognized more as a national public university rather than just regional,” Mr. Gallagher said. “We’re seeing that growing reputation, that growing brand across the whole country.”

But Pitt’s regional campuses in Greensburg, Johnstown, Bradford and Titusville have followed downward enrollment and application trends similar to those seen by Pennsylvania’s state schools, community colleges and Penn State’s commonwealth campuses.

The chancellor believes higher education is at a crossroads, in which more expensive, prestigious schools remain in high demand, while more affordable, accessible schools see drops in their student populations. 

“The question is, ‘What does this mean in the long term?’ And the honest answer is, we don't know,” Mr. Gallagher said. “My biggest fear is that those declines are happening predominantly in first-generation students and lower income students, and I don't think they're going somewhere else. I think they're forgoing a college education.” 

Snowballing interest in Pitt’s Oakland campus is a sigh of relief for university administrators, who three years ago were in uncharted territory when the pandemic hit. Mr. Gallagher said the whole world was “winging it,” including Pitt. Like many universities across the country, Pitt temporarily shifted to remote learning options and mandated the vaccine for students and faculty.

Advertise with us

In hindsight, the chancellor considers the pandemic to be a distraction from the university’s mission. Higher education is largely a social experience, and the pandemic robbed many students and educators of in-person interactions.

“What made COVID so difficult, and so challenging was that it was everywhere,” Mr. Gallagher said. “The entire planet was subject to this. That means it impacted everybody all the time. It wasn't just a work issue. It was a home issue, it was our lives, it was travel, it was international, and you didn't know what it was going to end. I think that’s a particular type of stress.”

Surging costs and concerns

While Pitt’s Oakland campus reaps the benefits of enrollment and application boosts, local and national attitudes toward four-year institutions like Pitt have soured during Mr. Gallagher’s tenure.

In 2015, the year after Mr. Gallagher became chancellor, 57% of Americans said they had a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in American higher education. That number has since dropped to 36%, according to a Gallup poll released Tuesday. 

Waning trust is attributable to a number of factors, with rising costs and politics often at the forefront. 

Advertise with us

During Mr. Gallagher’s tenure, in-state undergraduate tuition for a general studies student at the Oakland campus rose more than 17%, from $16,872 in fall 2014 to $19,760 in fall 2022. 

Mr. Gallagher attributed increasing costs in part to lacking state support, while pointing to several programs that Pitt has established to assuage the financial burden for some students, such as the Pitt Success program. He said Pitt student indebtedness has actually declined during his tenure.

“I would love to see the state of Pennsylvania really support its citizens with robust financial aid support and institutional support for their state schools,” he said, “but if they won’t do that, we have to find other ways to support our students and the way to do that is to target those that have the greatest need. I think we've made some meaningful steps in that direction.”

As tuition costs swelled, Mr. Gallagher’s salary went up. Pitt’s board of trustees hired Mr. Gallagher with a $525,000 salary. He ends his chancellorship making $698,202, a 33% raise. Ms. Gabel, Mr. Gallagher’s successor, will earn a base salary of $950,000. 

Mr. Gallagher attributed pricey administrator salaries to the competitive nature of the job. The chancellor, who pledged to give 20% of his salary back to students when the pandemic hit, called it a personal priority to financially support Pitt and its community during his tenure.

Advertise with us

“I've benefited from what's a very competitive market for university presidents and chancellors,” he said. “To be honest, I sort of have a mixed view about that. I'm personally not that motivated by that. I mean, I came from government service.”

Pitt has also found itself in hot political water during his time. Some Republican legislators and conservative groups have repeatedly criticized the university for its fetal tissue research, high price tag and lack of transparency. 

Seeking guaranteed tuition freezes and more openness from Pitt, a majority of House Republicans voted against the university’s 2023-24 state funding on July 6. Legislators have yet to approve funding for the state-related schools, including Pitt, in this year’s state budget. Pitt uses state money to provide tuition discounts for its in-state students. Mr. Gallagher declined to comment on the state budget.

From the left, some Democrats and liberal groups sharply criticized the university this spring when it refused to cancel a debate – “Should transgenderism be regulated by law?” – hosted by a conservative student group. Opposition to the debate culminated in a tumultuous protest, in which protesters threw an explosive device at police officers and numerous campus buildings were closed. A Regent Square couple were indicted this month for their role in the protest.

The protest made national headlines. Mr. Gallagher believes universities are “soft targets” for those wishing to create disruption at controversial events.

Advertise with us

He believes public universities “enshrine and protect” student and faculty viewpoints, while also reflecting the political and cultural debates of the day. He thinks universities are becoming increasingly subject to “ideological scorekeeping” and, in some cases, outside agitators who seek to escalate situations. The chancellor believes universities must learn to “cope” with this while protecting free expression.

“Universities are not monasteries and they're not places that are isolated from the whole world,” he said. “They're not ivory towers, and I say this at a university that happens to have one. They are supposed to be immersed in the turbulence of the day. That's where all the discovery and action is.”

As he prepares to move from the chancellor’s residence to the classroom, Mr. Gallagher said he looks forward to teaching at the department that trained him. 

He attended Pitt for graduate school to pursue a teaching career, and joked that he took a “40-year detour” from this career ambition.

“I've taken the strangest path to becoming a professor, maybe ever,” Mr. Gallagher said. “Going back to your own alma mater and these different roles is hard to explain… [As chancellor,] you kind of have to pinch yourself sometimes as you walk up to the Cathedral thinking, ‘I can't believe I'm back here in Pittsburgh and taking this on.’ It’ll be the same way … being one of the faculty members.

“It’s special.”