The U.S. Supreme Court on Friday ruled that the Biden administration overstepped its authority with a student loan forgiveness program that would wipe out billions of dollars in debt, a move that will be an enormous setback for millions of Americans who could have had up to $20,000 of debt canceled.

The 6-3 ruling nixes the one-time federal student loan debt relief program, which would have eliminated $400 billion in debt. The program attracted 26 million applicants – including nearly 80,000 in the Pittsburgh-region – before it was blocked as it made its way through the courts.

Student debt holders who have sat in limbo for months have largely been expecting the court to overrule the program. Local experts were not surprised by the ruling, but repercussions will affect nearly 1.8 million Pennsylvanians who have a total of $66.9 billion in federal student loan debt, according to federal data.

“This is certainly devastating for students,” Jamie Kosh, president of the Pennsylvania Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators, said. “On the other side it did cause a lot of confusion for new borrowers. … We seriously need reform in the higher education industry.”

Advertise with us

It was the second significant education ruling in two days. On Thursday, the court ruled that colleges must stop considering the race of applicants for admission.

Student loan forgiveness has seen a big push in recent years that was spurred by the COVID-19 pandemic and its lingering effects. For President Joe Biden, the plan would have largely fulfilled a campaign promise after he vowed to help borrowers “crawl out from under that mountain of debt.”

Under the program, announced in August, individuals who are single and earn under $125,000 would have qualified for $10,000 in debt cancellation. Married couples who file taxes jointly could have qualified if their income was under $250,000. Pell Grant recipients could have qualified for $20,000 in cancellation.

But the program saw swift pushback from Republican-led states. By the start of the year there were at least six lawsuits from Nebraska, Missouri, Arkansas, Iowa, Kansas and South Carolina that were filed against the plan and an injunction was issued to temporarily halt debt relief.

As the case made its way through the courts, the states’ lawyers argued the Biden administration should not be permitted to use the pandemic to justify its plan.

Advertise with us

The program was based on the Higher Education Relief Opportunities for Students Act of 2003, which allows the education secretary to waive regulations related to student loans during times of war or national emergency.

The act has been used by both the Trump and Biden administrations to pause federal student loan payments and interest during the pandemic, and it was used to issue multiple extensions on the pause beyond its original six-month period.

In the majority opinion representing conservative justices, Chief Justice John Roberts Jr.  wrote that the HEROES Act does not give the education secretary the authority to cancel student debt. 

“We hold today that the Act allows the Secretary to ‘waive or modify’ existing statutory or regulatory provisions applicable to financial assistance programs under the Education Act, not to rewrite the statute from the ground up,” Chief Justice Roberts wrote.

Justice Elena Kagan wrote the dissent. 

Advertise with us

“Congress authorized the forgiveness plan (among many other actions); the Secretary put it in place; and the President would have been accountable for its success or failure,” Justice Kagan wrote. "But this Court today decides that some 40 million Americans will not receive the benefits the plan provides, because (so says the Court) that assistance is too ‘significant.’ ”

Real-life impacts

As borrowers grapple with the reality of the ruling, Michele Shepard, senior director of college affordability at The Institute for College Access and Success, worries about possible financial ramifications. 

The ruling comes as millions of Americans will once again be expected to restart federal student loan payments this fall. The payments were first suspended in March 2020 when the pandemic shut down the U.S. economy. The suspension was extended five times since then.

“I think it is throwing all of the folks into more uncertainty as the pause is set to end this fall,” Ms. Shepard said. “So we’re really concerned about not only the confusion that borrowers are facing but also the tangible financial implications for folks and how they’re going to kind of manage not really knowing what’s coming.”

As the ruling plays out across the country, Linda DeAngelo, associate professor of higher education and a faculty fellow at the Center for Urban Education at the University of Pittsburgh, said people may not be able to make major purchases or buy basic items as they struggle to pay bills.

Advertise with us

“It will have ripple effects not only for the individuals but also for all of society in being able to engage economically within our society,” Ms. DeAngelo said.

Matt McKenzie, who is currently studying for his masters at the University of Pittsburgh, is now feeling the brunt of the ruling. Mr. McKenzie has $20,000 in federal student loans from his undergraduate degree. He now plans to look into other repayment options such as alternative programs or state offers.

“It’s just another burden that’s put on my shoulders, and I’m sure the $40 million other people that were looking for this kind of student loan relief,” Mr. McKenzie said. “This affects people’s ability to be able to pay rent, to feed their families, to invest in their future.”

Maher Oueida could face up to $60,000 in federal student debt by the time he finishes his masters degree at Pitt. When he heard about the ruling he said he was “disappointed.” But what really struck him was the frustration that came after realizing that the Biden administration’s promise to millions of Americans was not coming to fruition.

“I think one big reason a lot of younger people were voting for Biden was this idea that we can just take of the student debt crisis. … A lot of people are feeling let down by the government that’s supposed to help us out,” Mr. Oueida said. 

Advertise with us

While the loan cancellation plan could have helped millions of people, it didn’t come without criticism.

Antony Davies, a Duquesne University economics professor, said the plan could have had costly impacts on both the economy and higher education. The University of Pennsylvania estimated the plan would have cost between $469 billion and $519 billion over a ten-year budget window. 

"Every dollar in loans the government forgives will be paid by someone else: either in reduced government services, or in increased taxes, or in inflation," Mr. Davies wrote in an email. "In the end, what really happens is that people who don't go to college end up being forced to subsidize those who do."

Mr. Davies also expressed concerns with a hypothetical pattern of federal loan cancellation. If the government began canceling more students' loans, universities would likely raise tuition costs as students became less "price conscious," he predicted.

"Universities will compete to grab as many of those students (and their tuition dollars) as possible by offering more low-quality, low-effort courses of study," Mr. Davies wrote.

Advertise with us

Colleges across the region have already been feeling impacts to their financial aid programs. 

Carnegie Mellon officials said undergraduate need-based financial aid is up by 61% since 2016. 

Political reaction

In remarks Friday afternoon, Mr. Biden suggested that he was looking for another way to deliver student debt relief.

“Today’s decision has closed on path,” he said during a briefing Friday. “Now we’re going to pursue another.”

Shortly after the ruling, numerous Western Pennsylvania politicians took to social media to either criticize or praise the decision. 

Advertise with us

U.S. Sen. John Fetterman called the court's decision "ridiculous" and referred to the court as "extremist." 

"Our government has spent trillions to bail out big banks and the CEOs who crashed our economy," Mr. Fetterman, a Democrat, wrote in a statement. "Our government canceled millions in pandemic loans for members of Congress. Yet SCOTUS is saying we cannot cancel some of the student loan debt for working people."

U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, a fellow Democrat, took to Twitter to call for court reform and criticize gifts the justices have received.

On the Republican side, U.S. Rep. Guy Reschenthaler tweeted he was glad to see the court reject Mr. Biden's "vote-buying scheme."

"Biden's ridiculous student loan forgiveness proposal was always unconstitutional," Mr. Reschenthaler wrote.

Advertise with us

In a similar vein, U.S. Rep Mike Kelly tweeted the court's decision "upholds Congress's power of the purse," while U.S. Rep. Glenn Thompson referred to the loan relief plan as "nothing more than a transfer of wealth." 

"The president does not have the authority to force millions of Americans to foot the $400 billion bill," Mr. Thompson wrote.

Now that the ruling has been handed down, Ms. Shepard said, the U.S. Department of Education needs to communicate as soon as possible to ensure borrowers know the next steps. 

And, she said, borrowers need to take steps to protect themselves by knowing the status of their loan accounts and to use all available options in terms of repayment plans.

“I do think we’ve gotten to the point where so many people are struggling, so many people are confused,” Ms. Shepard said. “The administration felt they needed to take pretty significant action to mitigate that and now we’re right back where we started.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Kosh said there are several repayment options available to borrowers. Officials with the Pennsylvania Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators are also creating a program that will help guide borrowers as they get back into the repayment mindset.

“The loan forgiveness was not the be all, end all, solve the problem of student loan debt,” Mr. Kosh said. “This is a bigger issue that we need to deal with with student borrowing and there needs to be loan reform and the expansion of opportunities … for our students to not come out with the kind of debt that students are saddled with.”