Black girls across Pennsylvania face “daunting educational barriers” in the state’s K-12 public schools, according to a new report that details sweeping recommendations in an effort to make the system more inclusive.

The 36-page report titled We Need Supportive Spaces That Celebrate Us: Black Girls Speak Out About Public Schools delves into how Black girls are treated in the state’s education system while highlighting barriers they face daily such as racism, sexism and poverty.

“Our core belief is that public schools should be supportive and affirming places where Black girls have every opportunity to learn and to thrive,” Pennsylvania-based Education Law Center staff attorney Paige Joki said. “Our report makes clear that this is not the current reality in Pennsylvania.”

The report, released Thursday by the nonprofit Education Law Center, outlines eight recommendations to help school leaders create supportive spaces for Black girls. 

Advertise with us

They are based on experiences and perspectives of more than 20 Black girls who attend or have attended public middle and high schools in Pennsylvania.

“I think it’s important to hear from Black girls, what we want, directly from us and how systems have directly impacted us instead of hearing it from the mouths of other people,” Amaiyah, a senior at a Pennsylvania school district who participated in the report, said. “No one knows what a Black girl goes through like a Black girl.”

Across the nation, Black girls are four times more likely than their white peers to receive out-of-school suspensions, a Georgetown University analysis of the U.S. Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights 2017-18 school year data found.

Black girls are also almost four times more likely to be expelled and risk arrest at school, are two times more likely to be restrained and face five times the risk of transferring for disciplinary reasons. 

Those numbers mirror what’s happening across Pennsylvania. 

Advertise with us

Allegheny County in 2018 saw 60% of juvenile justice referrals for Black girls come from school-related offenses, according to a report from the Black Girls Equity Alliance, a Gwen’s Girls initiative that focuses on improving the outcomes for Black girls in child welfare, juvenile justice, education, and health and wellness.

The report also found that Black girls in Pittsburgh Public Schools were more than three times as likely as white girls to be suspended, with 20% of Black girls receiving one or more out-of-school suspensions each year. Pittsburgh Public teaches more than 20,000 students, almost 52% of whom are Black. Almost 65% of students are considered economically disadvantaged.

And Black girls get dress coded at higher rates than their white peers. 

That data comes as Black children obey school rules at the same rates as their peers, Ms. Joki said.

“Their schools often engage in discriminatory and subjective discipline and policing practices,” Ms. Joki said. “These conditions result in students being deprived of the very basic and needed supports that actually most students across the nation receive.”

Advertise with us

She said that Pennsylvania schools are among the most racially and economically segregated schools in the nation, referencing not only higher rates of discipline Black students face, but also in terms of funding. 

Almost 50% of Black girls in Pennsylvania, Ms. Joki said, attend schools that are grossly underfunded with few teachers of color. 

School funding has been the focus of state leaders after a February ruling highlighted the inequities between low-income and wealthy districts based on the funding formula’s reliance on property taxes. The suit found that wide achievement gaps on state assessments exist between students in wealthier and poorer districts, with gaps widening for Black, Hispanic, English-language learners and economically-disadvantaged students.

“We’re hopeful that as remedies in this matter move forward the types of egregious and pervasive educational deprivations Black students are experiencing will be remedied,” Ms. Joki said. 

Proposed solutions

Advertise with us

Amaiyah was a ninth grader when she was first dress coded for wearing ripped jeans. But as her body changed as she got older, Amaiyah saw an increase in the number of times she was flagged for a clothing infraction. The Education Law Center declined to give Amaiyah’s last name.

Comments from teachers such as “put something around your waist” and “cover yourself” became common for her and her friends. Last year, Amaiyah said, a teacher told her she looked “cute” in a dress, which Amaiyah found inappropriate. 

The incident, which Amaiyah said made her feel uncomfortable, drew unwanted attention from other students. The dress coding system, Amaiyah said, “is built upon objectifying Black girls,” and supports a common stereotype of adults viewing Black girls as women. 

“We’re still not grown adults no matter how much our bodies may symbolize it,” Amaiyah said. “We still deserve to grow up as children the same way that white girls do. Black girls deserve a childhood, too.”

The Education Law Center report detailed eight recommendations, including one about creating inclusive dress and grooming codes, for school districts to implement with the goal of creating a safe learning environment for Black girls.  

Advertise with us

“We talk about specifically how that plays out in school so treating Black girls like they’re women, treating them like they’re dangerous, the preoccupation and hypersexualization of Black girls’ bodies,” Ms. Joki said.

Other suggestions include hiring more Black teachers and staff. A February report found that only 6% of teachers identify as persons of color, compared to 37% of students in Pennsylvania. 

That means 48% of Pennsylvania schools do not employ any teachers of color, Ms. Joki said.

Steps are being taken to increase the pipeline for Black students to enter a teaching career. The Pittsburgh Promise, which works with Pittsburgh Public Schools, recently started the Advancing Educators of Color scholarship program, said Amy Yearwood, The Pittsburgh Promise’s director of college and career success.

It is designed to attract more Black Pittsburgh youth to the field of education. After graduating, the students teach at Pittsburgh schools.

Advertise with us

Ms. Yearwood noted that increasing the number of Black teachers will help fulfill other recommendations made in the report such as giving Black girls access to supportive adults; implementing culturally responsive curriculum and providing mental health services and professionals who have shared lived experiences with Black girls. 

Other recommendations include supporting Black girls’ academic success, adequately responding to the COVID-19 pandemic and removing police from schools.

The report, Ms. Joki said, is a “call to action” based upon Black girls’ experiences with racism. Each girl interviewed for the report detailed instances where they were the subject of racial slurs and faced discriminatory discipline or been the target of discipline because of their race and gender.

“These forces impact and harm every single aspect of their education and also deprives them of the education that they deserve and are entitled to under law,” Ms. Joki said.

Education Law Center officials will host an event Monday that will dive into the recommendations while highlighting students involved in the report. They are also working on a second report, which will become a blueprint for solutions. 

“We think really everybody has a role to play in needed change, and while this report is an important moment it’s not our destination,” Ms. Joki said. “I look forward to moving this work forward and getting the word out about what conditions look like in our schools because I think that part is really missing from the discussion a lot of times.”