Three Western Pennsylvania school districts sued the state this week for new teacher certification requirements they say violate educators’ First Amendment rights and encroach upon school districts’ authority to establish curriculum.
The suit was filed Monday in Commonwealth Court by Mars Area, Laurel and Penncrest school districts, as well as by two teachers, several board members and parents.
It aims to stop the Pennsylvania Department of Education from implementing the Culturally Relevant and Sustaining Education Program, which are professional development principles and competencies for teacher preparation programs that aim to create an inclusive learning environment for all students.
State officials say the program, which does not apply to students or the curriculum, will enable teachers to serve students from varying socioeconomic backgrounds and those with different abilities.
But those involved in the suit say the competencies did not go through the proper regulatory process and that they interfere with daily school processes.
Attorney Thomas King, who is representing the plaintiffs, said the program forces teachers and administrators to “police both the thoughts and the speech” of students, board members and parents in the school setting.
Read More
“It’s just inventing stuff that is popular and woke in California and New York but should never be in schools in Pennsylvania,” said Mr. King, who in 2021 was among those involved in a successful challenge to a statewide mask mandate in schools.
The Pennsylvania Department of Education declined to comment on pending litigation.
The suit – which is funded by the Thomas More Legal Society of Chicago, a conservative public-interest law center that focuses heavily on pro-life litigation – claims the program violates teachers’ First Amendment rights and breaches petitioners’ constitutional rights.
Additionally, the suit states that the program usurps local authority of districts to implement curriculum and calls for “improper civil disobedience” because it requires “educators to ‘disrupt’ lawfully enacted policies and practices of school districts.”
It also alleges the program is unconstitutionally vague and violates the Regulatory Review Act, the Code of Professional Practice and Conduct for Educators and the Nondelegation Doctrine.
“You’ll see that these regulations are terribly vague or confusing or have no basis in the law,” Mr. King said. “We’ve asked the court to strike down the regulations, we’ve asked the governor to rescind the regulations.”
Amendments to Chapter 49: Certification of Professional Personnel began in 2018. At the time, officials said the changes work to advance Pennsylvania’s goal of boosting the number of new teachers of color from 13% to 25% by 2025 to help tackle the state’s teacher shortage.
After several years of collecting feedback and public comment, the Senate and House education committees approved final amendments to Chapter 49 last March.
Overall, the changes ask potential teachers to acknowledge that bias exists in the education system and to integrate multiple perspectives into their teachings to “capitalize on learners’ real-world experiences, identities, and heritage,” according to the guidelines.
The CR-SE competencies must be integrated into professional development programs by the 2023-24 school year.
The state has 30 days to respond to the suit.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.