Millions of students across the country, including those in the Pittsburgh region, could benefit from a new federal proposal that would make it easier for districts to serve free school meals, but some experts worry costs associated with the program could hinder its benefits. 

The proposal, made by the U.S. Department of Agriculture last month, would amend qualifications to the community eligibility provision program, which allows high-poverty schools to serve breakfast and lunch at no cost to all enrolled students. 

The changes would make it easier for districts to qualify for the program. 

“I really look at that as the education system having that opportunity to take care of those basic needs – breakfast and lunch – and therefore students will have their mind set and ready to go for the day and prepared to learn,” Chris Derico, president-elect of the School Nutrition Association, said.

Advertise with us

Currently, schools that have 40% or more of their students enrolled in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program can choose to offer free meals to all students without having to submit individual applications. 

The proposal would lower the threshold from 40% to 25%.

That change, officials said, would eliminate unpaid meal debt, minimize stigma and streamline meal service operations. 

“When all students have access to healthy school meals, meal participation tends to increase, and more children can experience nutritional benefits that fuel their learning, growth, and development,” the proposal reads.

In the Pittsburgh region, several districts such as Penn Hills, Pittsburgh Public and Sto-Rox already offer all students free meals under the community eligibility provision. 

Advertise with us

But others have begun seeing increased school meal debt after a pandemic-era program that provided all public school students with free breakfast and lunch ended, meaning districts are back to charging students for meals.

Earlier this year, districts such as Baldwin-Whitehall were already reporting high debt levels. In January, the district was facing $45,000 in school lunch debt. Before the pandemic, that number typically was $50,000 for the entire year. At North Hills, debt hovered around $7,000, officials said at the time, similar to numbers reported before the pandemic.

But even as districts grapple with how to move forward without pandemic-related programs, it was not clear how many would participate in the community eligibility provision if the changes are enacted.

Evora Nichole Taylor a School Nutrition Association of Pennsylvania board member and director of food services at Chichester School District in Delaware County, said some districts may face a large bill if costs of offering free meals to all students exceed the federal assistance.

“It can have a really great impact because that would mean that more schools would qualify, but it’s a double edged sword,” Ms. Taylor said. “So while more students would qualify at no cost it could ultimately end up really impacting the district.”

Advertise with us

While Ms. Taylor applauded the potential percentage change, she suggested that the government should also revise a multiplier used to determine the percentage of meals reimbursed at the federal free rate. 

As things currently stand, many districts and nutrition programs are required to make up the difference between what is reimbursed and the actual costs of providing free meals to all students. 

For example, the Chichester School District food program pays $1,200 per month in fees not covered by federal assistance. If the multiplier were slightly increased, Ms. Taylor said, the program – which relies on funding from reimbursements or a la cart sales – would not be required to pay any additional costs.

“When I read the regulations it was great initially until you really dive into them and you realize that they’re not giving us that multiplier,” Ms. Taylor said. “That’s going to hurt a lot of students.”

Rather than helping all districts, the proposed changes, she noted, could largely benefit schools that are close to receiving a full reimbursement.

Advertise with us

“If you’re at a district that has a very low direct certified number it is definitely a deterrent for you because you’re not going to reap the benefits of it,” she said. “If you’re at a district that’s like mine that will maybe help me get 100%, then it would be more of a draw for me.”

Following the pandemic, several state legislatures have been helping districts provide free meals to students. 

California, Maine, Minnesota and New York permanently extended universal free school meals. Others, such as Massachusetts, Nevada and Vermont, committed to free meals for this school year. 

While Pennsylvania districts are once again required to charge students for lunches, the state is providing every child with free breakfast this academic year. Gov. Josh Shapiro in his budget proposal last month presented the continuation of universal free breakfasts “because students can’t learn on empty stomachs.”

“I almost look at it as the school system providing free transportation, free textbooks,” Mr. Derico said. “We’re now getting into the business of providing that free breakfast and free lunch so there’s no barriers to the learning process.”

Advertise with us

He noted that the proposed changes are “just another tool that districts will have at their disposal to use to expand universal free meals, so that’s a positive.”

Comments on the proposed changes will be accepted by the USDA through May 8.

For Ms. Taylor, there’s only one goal in mind as conversations move forward. 

“At the end of the day,” she said, “it’s about feeding our kids.”