Students at the Sto-Rox School District were suspended at a rate four times higher than the Allegheny County average of almost 13.7 students per 100, according to a 2018 University of Pittsburgh report, and Superintendent Megan Van Fossan said the suspension rates from the 2021-22 school year weren’t much better.
But the district is making an effort to decrease that number through a partnership with the Just Discipline Project, a program through University of Pittsburgh Center on Race and Social Problems designed to decrease the “school-to-prison” pipeline, a practice that disproportionately puts children of color in the criminal system.
JDP will train faculty members and students on other methods of discipline besides suspension and expulsions. The program will focus on building healthy relations between peers and faculty members.
“We really want to be restorative in our approach with school discipline,” said Ms. Van Fossan. “Our hope is that we can really restore some of these relationships.”
The cost of the program is covered for two years through grants and partnership funding. Districts with large populations of Black and brown students and in low-income areas with higher suspension rates are the target of the program. According to state data, more than half of Sto-Rox students are Black, and 93% are economically disadvantaged.
The project is a restorative program that focuses on decreasing exclusionary discipline by improving relationships between students and faculty members. Exclusionary discipline includes any disciplinary action that removes students from their usual education environments, such as in-school or out-of-school suspension.
Read More
The project was presented to Sto-Rox by the University of Pittsburgh Center on Race and Social Problems.
“[The Just Discipline Project is] not only telling them we're trying not to dictate their practice,” said Jay Huguley, JDP’s principal investigator. “We work alongside them to create change, and we have groups of teachers and student leaders that make the programs work.”
Each building participating in the project is assigned a restorative practice coordinator. These members are paid through the project’s funding partnerships. The Pittsburgh study at Children's Hospital supports three sites, and Heinz Endowments has been a supporting partner since the pilot study.
Just Discipline’s approaches are based on program models from areas with similarly underresourced urban schools as Pittsburgh, such as Oakland, Calif., and Houston. The programs in those that successfully decreased their discipline exclusionary practices had personnel to lead restorative work.
Sto-Rox students will receive training on what restorative justice means and how they can change their school climates by student-led activities. Students also will help staff members facilitate the meditations to easily resolve conflicts.
Shawn Thomas, the program director, said the “bottom-up” approach is what makes JDP’s methods unique and successful.
“The idea is to get them trained and give them the knowledge that we have, the skills that we have, and allow them to transform their community through building relationships through fun, competitive style or what they come up with,” he said. ”It's not just telling them what they should do.”
Mr. Thomas added that involving the students and giving them leadership opportunities shows improvements in academics as well.
Based on the two-year review from the pilot study at the Woodland Hills School District, academic improvement increased while suspensions decreased 22%.
“When [students] feel like they belong in school, when they feel like they have caring adult relationships, they perform better in school,” Mr. Thomas said. “The restorative work starts on the front end, right? It starts with building a relational community where people feel connected.”
Ms. Van Fossan said that attitude is something she plans to push for at Sto-Rox.
“You've got to teach kids replacement behaviors,“ she said. “Expulsion and suspension doesn't give you that. It sends them out.”
Ms. Van Fossan said this past school year, four students were shot, one fatally, which she found especially alarming considering the district has just 1,200 students.
Removing students from learning environments, she added, should not be the default for disciplining a student. Instead, other alternatives should be considered such as having discussions with parents, students and faculty members.
Mr. Huguley said suspension rates lead to more dropouts, which increase a student’s likelihood to enter the juvenile justice system. While racial bias contributes to the school-to-prison pipeline, he said, it is also the historic resource inequity faced by Black and brown schools and communities. The project is designed to provide resources early on to both students and adults when conflict arises.
“We're helping students before they get down the pathway on the school-to-prison pipeline, trying to cut that off in the beginning.”
Sto-Rox is hoping the partnership will encourage students to mentor one another and turn to school for alternative outlets for their emotions.
The district is not expecting the partnership to change things overnight. But district leaders hope this project can provide resources to families and students.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.