First in an occasional series.
For decades, the Duquesne City School District was considered to be the heart of its Monongahela Valley community and was widely known for the many titles captured by its basketball and football teams.
But by the time Sue Mariani took over as superintendent in 2018, the district had experienced a series of losses.
Longstanding financial problems caused Duquesne’s high school to close in 2007, forcing students into other districts where they had few, if any, connections.
Students in seventh and eighth grades followed the high schoolers out of the district several years later.

The departure of the upper grades also meant athletics, cheerleaders and the marching band were no more.
Read More
One thing that was never lost, however, was the community’s pride in the school, a quality Ms. Mariani said convinced her to take the job in a district that at the time was in financial recovery and producing historically low test scores.
“The pride that they have in their own city and the pride that they have in the school district is just unmatched,” Ms. Mariani said in a recent interview. “It really is just a love and a desire for the school district to succeed, for the city to succeed.”
Over the past few years, Ms. Mariani and a team of administrators, educators and community members have been working to leverage that pride into something more substantial. The district that, before its high school closed, won 12 WPIAL basketball championships and four WPIAL football championships, is now on the verge of another kind of win.
This time, it’s a comeback.

Duquesne is the first Pennsylvania school district to reintroduce secondary grade levels after being forced to eliminate them. Last year, seventh graders came back to the district, with eighth graders poised to return this fall. And now, district officials are making plans to reopen a high school.
“There is no doubt that exciting things are happening at Duquesne City School District,” said Bob Scherrer, executive director of the Allegheny Intermediate Unit, a public education agency that has assisted Duquesne with resources and programming. “Superintendent Dr. Sue Mariani and her team are really focusing on a student-centered approach for their students and families. The district has a bright future.”
A ‘failing’ school district
On June 5, 2007, the state board of control then governing Duquesne voted to “curtail” the district’s high school program, a decision met with outrage and sorrow from the community that overwhelmingly opposed the plan.
State Education Secretary Gerald Zahorchak, who requested the board of control make the move, said the district was failing its students because it did not offer advanced placement and honors courses, had few athletic opportunities and no nonathletic extracurricular activities.
Duquesne’s high school students were sent to the West Mifflin Area and East Allegheny school districts.
Five years later, with the district still failing and near total collapse, seventh and eighth graders followed the high schoolers.
That plan, also resisted by the community, further fractured the relationship between the city’s residents and its school district.
But because of the community’s determination to have a strong neighborhood school, the grim questions of the past have been replaced by the promising prospects of today.
“I have a really great problem on my hand — and that’s probably my bigger obstacle — where am I going to put my nine through 12 graders?” Ms. Mariani said.
The lone remaining Duquesne City school building, a three-story red brick structure built in 1913 about halfway up a hill at 300 Kennedy Ave., once housed students in K-12. However, that would not be possible today, as much of the school has been repurposed.

Ms. Mariani said it may take a large endowment to renovate a building that could be used as a high school or build a new structure.
“It’s more of a longer-term goal,” Ms. Mariani said. “But it’s definitely what the community wants and quite frankly what our kids deserve.”
Despite the hurdles, the district aims to have a high school within the next five years. Ms. Mariani said the district likely will try to bring in one new grade level at a time until it is again K-12.
“It’s going to take a lot more time and a lot more work, and a lot more finances,” she said. “High school is just a different ballgame, [with] what you need academically to be able to prepare the kids, and a lot more staff.”
The community’s message
In her earliest meetings with school stakeholders, Ms. Mariani said the message to her was clear: Restore our school district.
After spending her first few months as superintendent listening and learning, Ms. Mariani was ready to begin that work.
She began putting her “aces in the right places,” a phrase now frequently uttered with a smile by staff at the school in reference to Ms. Mariani’s reshuffling of employees to get the most out of everyone.
For some, that meant teaching a grade they had never taught before. For others, that meant switching from teaching positions to administrative roles.
“Some, of course, weren’t happy with that,” Ms. Mariani admitted. “They taught first grade their entire lives. ‘How dare you move me to a third or fourth grade position?’”
But those moves were a catalyst to push the district forward, she said.
George Little, a Duquesne native and 2005 graduate, started as a paraprofessional in the district in 2015 and worked his way to a mid-level administrative role. Under Ms. Mariani, he became the school’s assistant principal.

He said Ms. Mariani’s ability to recognize the different skills of each individual staff member was transformative for the district.
“Instruction may be somebody’s highest quality that they bring, maybe leadership is somebody else’s quality, maybe technology,” Mr. Little said. “I feel like she was able to kind of dissect all of these different skill sets.”
In addition to rearranging staff, Ms. Mariani oversaw the formation of committees that included parents, clergy and other stakeholders.
The work done early in Ms. Mariani’s tenure paved the way for the turnaround, according to Sonya Gooden, who has served on the school board for about 12 years.
“The startup of committees where it’s not just the school board but key leaders within a community, understanding the history and seeing the potential within the district, establishing the appropriate administrators and team of people to make these goals happen moving forward — that was the moment we said, ‘OK, here we go,’” Ms. Gooden said.
Boosting education
Any attempt at adding more grade levels would depend on the district improving its academics and programming.
When Ms. Mariani got her “aces in the right places,” her new administrators implemented a more rigorous curriculum that was aligned to state standards and had the resources to support it.
Instruction was tailored to benefit each student. Cross-curricular work was paired with project-based learning to help keep students engaged.
“It wasn’t just about ‘We have to do it because it’s required,’” Ms. Mariani said. “It’s now ‘I understand how this affects the bigger picture, why it’s really important for me to learn algebra, what I’m really going to do with it.’ So it was those kinds of things that really sparked the true turnaround here.”
The district, which had been on a state academic watch list since 1999, was finally removed in 2019-20.
District officials also sought to improve the physical classrooms.
Grant money helped fund five makerspaces dedicated to different grade levels throughout the school where students can collaborate and create, aligning with the district’s focus on science, technology, engineering and math.
The PreK-2 makerspace, called the “Creation Station,” has sand and water kits, Legos, toys that teach the basics of coding and an X-ray machine. The Boiler Room, for students in grades 3-6, has a T-shirt designer, vinyl cutters, virtual reality goggles and a 3D printer.
Duquesne also started a Lego league and met every Saturday with students from a school in the North Allegheny School District.
Jamie Schmidt, who came to Duquesne the year after the high school closed and now serves as director of curriculum, said the Lego League was so much more than just an activity for kids.

“The kids that signed up never missed a Saturday. It wasn’t anything that was required. It was seventh grade kids talking about how ‘Now I want to be an engineer,’” Ms. Schmidt said, trying to hold back tears. “I get so emotional talking about it because of the opportunities that we’ve been able to open up. ...
“I cry every time I talk about it because to see the turnaround of the district and have kids be able to believe in themselves, and that they have a future and people there to support them is really why we do this.”
Putting the band back together
The district was eager to revive its extracurricular programs, too.
Even standard activities, such as a pep band, can prove costly, though. With that in mind, Duquesne put out a call for help.
On May 25, six Thomas Jefferson High School students and band director Jim Mirabella marched through the doors of the Duquesne school building carrying instruments.
But instead of playing them, they were donating the decommissioned but gently used drums, flutes, clarinets, baritones and other instruments to Duquesne.

“I’d rather them be used than collecting dust,” Mr. Mirabella said.
Mr. Mirabella attached quad drums to a harness and placed them over the shoulders of one Duquesne student.
“Heavy, huh?” he asked the girl, a grin on his face.
Then Mr. Mirabella got the big drum — a marching bass drum — attached it to its harness, and, as the Duquesne students looked on wide-eyed, got ready to place it over the shoulders of another girl.
“Hang on. Ready?” he said. “Here you go!”
Before leaving, Mr. Mirabella encouraged the students to keep pursuing music. One of his students, he explained, is heading to the University of Pittsburgh to be a part of the school’s drumline.
“Music can take you a long way,” he said.
Ms. Mariani said Duquesne was grateful for Thomas Jefferson’s generous donation.
“This donation will help get instruments into our students’ hands,” Ms. Mariani said, “which will hopefully begin not only a love of music, but an avenue of learning that hasn’t been offered in Duquesne for more than a decade.”
Money matters
Reintroducing more activities — not to mention grade levels — at a time when the costs of nearly all aspects of education are higher than ever and rising, could not happen without some creativity.
That’s especially true in a community that still suffers economically from the decline of the steel industry, where the poverty rate is more than three times the state average, and in a school that has 100% free and reduced-price lunch.
At 17.5 mills, Duquesne’s millage rate is among the lowest in Allegheny County, and the district has not raised the tax rate for nearly a quarter-century. Taxes alone were never going to right the district’s finances.
Since Ms. Mariani started, Duquesne has built its list of community partners and brought in $14 million in grant money. In comparison, the district has an annual budget of about $20 million.
“That’s the way we get things done,” Ms. Mariani said.
As the district struggled over the past two decades, many Duquesne families sent their children to charter schools, where they believed they would have better opportunities. With each child lost to a charter, thousands of dollars followed them out of the district.
In the summer of 2018, Duquesne teachers and staff members donned bright red T-shirts emblazoned on front and back with a white Olde English “D,” and went door-to-door with information about the district’s programs and amenities in an attempt to entice charter families to send their kids to their neighborhood school.
The “Bring Your Kids Home” campaign helped the district lower the number of students it was sending to charters. In 2017-18, before the campaign, Duquesne paid charter tuition for 212 students. In 2018-19, that number was 203, and in 2019-20, it was 204.
The campaign was slowed by the COVID-19 pandemic, but will relaunch this summer as “Rediscover Duquesne.”
Jocelyn Brown started as a paraprofessional in the district in 2021-22 after working with many of the school system’s students as a youth development professional at the Boys and Girls Club of Duquesne. She also decided to enroll three of her children in Duquesne for the first time last year after previously sending them to area charters.
Ms. Brown said she was hesitant to place her kids in Duquesne because of some of the behavior district students displayed at the Boys and Girls Club. But she said she also saw great potential.

While the transition hasn’t been perfect, Ms. Brown said she believes it has benefitted her children.
“I do feel like them being more comfortable here allowed them to learn more,” Ms. Brown said.
Ms. Brown’s daughter, Essence, who will enter sixth grade in the fall, said she is happier at Duquesne than at the school she used to attend.
One reason, Essence cited in an interview in which she was wearing an all-pink outfit that included her dress, jacket, shoes and hair-tie, was that she gets to pick out her clothes instead of wearing a school uniform.
Importantly, Essence said, she gets to go to school with the kids from her own neighborhood.
“I like it here,” Essence said. “I get to see my friends in school and outside of school.”
Post-Gazette librarian Stephen Karlinchak contributed. Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.