This story was updated at 7:25 p.m.
The Faculty Senate at West Virginia University introduced a resolution of no confidence in President E. Gordon Gee and provost Maryanne Reed on Monday, quickly removed any reference to COVID-19, then decided other grievances didn’t warrant the sanction.
The few senators who spoke in-person or remotely registered concerns about its passage. Another senator asked if the tally would be anonymous or if names would be attached.
Monday’s session was suspended about 4:15 p.m. so senators could prepare to vote up or down on the resolution. An hour later, the vote was announced — 20 supporting the resolution and 103 against.
WVU issued a statement Monday evening on behalf of its Board of Governors Chair Tom Jones. In it, he expressed respect for faculty with concerns but also said the board “unequivocally supports” Mr. Gee and Ms. Reed and as having maintained academic standards and campus transformation amid a deadly pandemic.
“We also have the utmost confidence in the leadership qualities and vision of President Gee. The Board of Governors must position our University for success beyond this pandemic,’’ it read in part. “It is critical that we begin to take action now. The charges we have requested for academic transformation, as well as other transformations within the University, are not easy – but they are necessary.”
Read More
The initial resolution as it was posted to the Senate's agenda (see it here) for Monday's 3:15 p.m. meeting involved six paragraphs, the top one being the Gee administration's refusal to set a COVID -19 vaccine mandate across campus, despite widespread support among faculty, students and others in the community.
But a senator immediately introduced a proposed amendment to strike the first paragraph entirely, saying its prominence distorted the overall intent of the resolution on campus, which involved grievances over shared governance, transparency and leadership style.
The senator said 95% of the discussion beyond campus in recent days and in the media focused on COVID-19.
The amendment to strike the paragraph passed 57 to 17. After follow-up motions to refer the matter back to the Faculty Assembly or to table the resolution until the Faculty Senate's next meeting failed, the discussion proceeded.
Before suspending the session for the vote, Faculty Senate Chair Ashley Martucci, invited a response to the resolution from Mr. Gee, 77, who arrived as interim president in late 2013 and was then appointed in 2014.
He and Ms. Reed acknowledged the stresses on faculty in tumultuous times, including the pandemic, but said academic transformations are vital to the public research university’s future.
“It is not an easy time to be faculty members, and it's not an easy time to be president with all the issues we face," said Mr. Gee, who was present at the session, which was held mostly via Zoom.
"I have immense respect for the faculty. ... I value what you do."
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.