How best to remake Pennsylvania’s state university system already was a dizzying political fight, with twists and turns in some unlikely places. This may be among the most unusual yet.
On Wednesday, State System of Higher Education leadership was asked at a legislative hearing how it is engaging students about the changes, including controversial university mergers. Leaders, of course, can email blast those students to death, interview them until they nod off or give website updates — even elevator pitches. They apparently are doing a lot of that now.
But students evidently prefer another way of communicating, and they made that clear when surveyed by system leaders.
“What was the emerging trend? Video on TikTok,” said State System Chancellor Daniel Greenstein, flashing a momentary grin at lawmakers as if he was trying to imagine what that outreach would look like. “You can’t make this stuff up.
“So, we’re looking at how to do video on TikTok,” he added.
The exchange over these short videos on social media that are all the rage was a whimsical aside in a hearing that also touched on weighty matters: Republicans on the House Appropriations and Education committees, meeting jointly, had pointed questions about system requests for $50 million a year in temporary funding, as well as a proposal this month to boost the system’s permanent yearly appropriation by $73 million to $550 million.
Read More
It’s a move that could potentially lift Pennsylvania from its near-bottom rank in state support to higher education — 47 out of 50 states.
State Rep. Tim O’Neal, representing parts of Washington County, said he worried that the $50 million was being baked into the permanent cost of doing business, on top of the $73 million increase in yearly funding. Mr. Greenstein said that is not so.
He said the $50 million is for specific changes needed to help retool the 14 universities. The chancellor said lawmakers have a choice to make that goes beyond whether they devote more money to just the State System, but instead how they intend to help ease a shortage of trained workers in Pennsylvania that is sending jobs out of state.
“These are policy choices that the General Assembly has to make,” Mr. Greenstein said. “At the end of the day the question really for the assembly is not about [the State System]. The question really is about what is the future shape of the economy.”
“The question is what kind of state does Pennsylvania want to see. That’s a question for you ... and if you are satisfied with having a huge gap in terms of the skills base that employers require ... then we can continue with the austerity path that we have been on.”
The State System is in the process of combining six of its 14 state universities into two. California, Clarion and Edinboro in the west will be known under the umbrella title of Pennsylvania Western University, with their local names incorporated. Bloomsburg, Lock Haven and Mansfield universities are being merged, too, but a new name has not been announced.
The financial and enrollment pressures that the 14 universities face was amplified by a report released Tuesday by the National Student Clearinghouse Research Center. It said national data indicates that enrollment declines are not reversing — and, in fact, have deepened, with two-year and four-year public campuses facing particular stress.
Other factors including a decline in high school graduates and affordability already had created havoc in Pennsylvania. The system’s enrollment, nearly 120,000 in 2010, has now dipped to fewer than 89,000 students — its smallest total since the 1980s.
Also Wednesday, Mr. Greenstein said an application for the mergers is now before the Middles States Commission for Higher Education, and with the panel meeting in March, he sees a decision soon thereafter. He said the NCAA is expected to decide after that on whether the six universities being merged can keep their current complement of athletics.
Both are seen as critical decisions for the viability of the unified institutions.
State Rep. Emily Kinkead, D-Allegheny, asked what course correction provisions are in place if the anticipated approvals — be it from Middle States or the NCAA — do not come to fruition.
“It’s always important to have contingencies,” Mr. Greenstein said.
But he said it’s not a good use of staff who already are overburdened to begin scoping out hypothetical situations.
Besides, he said, his understanding of both reviews is that they are less about “yes or no” and more about “Let’s have a conversation about ‘X.’”
Ms. Kinkead asked what the chancellor sees as the biggest hurdle.
“Staff burnout,” he replied. “This is hard work. And this is hard work being done by people who are working 100% in their day jobs dealing with the pandemic.”
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.