Pittsburgh Public Schools officials floated a tax increase, workforce reductions and other options as possible ways to address the district’s lingering budget deficit that could soon exceed $40 million.

Ronald Joseph, the district’s chief financial officer, outlined the courses of action Monday in a presentation before the school board and warned that the district needed to address its finances immediately or risk running out of money in the near future.

“We have to have these conversations now, we have to plan,” he said. “If we don’t, we accept that we’re waiting for someone else to correct this issue for us, and it may not be the best remedy that we imagine.”

Mr. Joseph told the board that the district is projected to have an approximately $39 million deficit by the end of 2021, which is expected to grow to nearly $44 million in 2022 without any intervention. He said the district would be on pace to exhaust its fund balance — meaning it would run our of money in its general fund — in 2023 if steps are not taken toward fixing the financial issues.

Advertise with us

The school board has the power to increase the millage rate by 3%, which would add an additional $5 million in annual real estate revenue, according to Mr. Joseph. Board members declined to raise property taxes last year after approving a small hike in 2019 — the first time that the district had increased taxes in five years.

The district has not proposed a specific tax increase for this year, though it likely will happen as it is one of the only ways for the district to raise revenue. Any increase would have to be approved by the board, but it is unknown if board members would be amenable to such a move.

Board member Bill Gallagher voted against the proposed 2.6% tax increase last year because he said he felt the district had to seek other means of revenue and look for places to save money before putting a greater burden on taxpayers.

He said Monday that the district should revisit its footprint reorganization proposal that included closing underutilized schools and adjusting feeder patterns, a plan that could save the school system several million dollars but was tabled by the board earlier this year.

“I’m not against taxes. I was a public school employee, so taxes don’t bother me,” Mr. Gallagher said. “But I feel that we have to do our part to show the citizens of Pittsburgh that if we’re going to raise taxes, we’re serious about making the right decision to utilize our money to the full extent.”

Advertise with us

The district also could save money by reducing the size of its workforce, which has grown in recent years despite an ongoing decrease in student enrollment. Since 2015, Mr. Joseph said, the district’s enrollment has decreased by about 15% while its staff has increased by about 14%.

Mr. Joseph said that if the district were to align its workforce to its decline in students, it could cut nearly 650 positions. He noted that number was simply straight math, and it has not been determined where reductions could be made.

“We know there’s not a perfect one-to-one adjustment to enrollment,” he said. “We know that if you lose 30 students in a school, it doesn’t mean you can pull a teacher out. It depends on the grades and the distribution of those students.”

Federal stimulus funds coming to the district could help stave off the need for staff reductions for at least a year, Mr. Joseph said, which could be beneficial to city students who have recently returned to school full time for the first time since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic and may need help catching up on their studies.

“It’s imperative to maintain school-based staff in order to create the sense of normalcy that we need to address this learning loss,” he said. “So it would be counter-productive to engage in reductions at this time we’re expected to try to address the learning loss as a result of the pandemic.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Joseph said the district could consider several other places it could save funds, including program reductions or consolidations and decreasing the total amount of money it borrows each year to pay for its capital plan.

He also suggested the district work on long-term goals, such as advocating for charter school funding reform, recapturing income tax revenue that was diverted to the city while it was under Act 47 and implementing strategies to increase student enrollment.

No matter what, Mr. Joseph said, the district will need to make some tough decisions if it wants to escape its current financial situation.

“We have limited ability to increase revenue, so we have to reduce expenditures,” he said. “I think that calculus has been the same regardless of discussions of any possibilities, and, if there were any possibilities that we can think of to get that amount without touching staff or having workforce reductions, we would have done that already because I frankly don’t like having this conversation every year about possibly running out of money and being the doom-and-gloom guy. That’s not what I would like to do, but this is where we are.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.