Policies that have appeared this year in Sewickley Academy student and employee handbooks that assert broad powers by school officials to search private communications and possessions have sparked fears in a parents group that was critical of the academy this summer that speaking out could result in significant discipline.

The mandates allow the academy to enact disciplinary measures if a student or student’s family member displays a loss of confidence or disagreement with school policies or if a student makes disparaging or negative comments about the school, administration or faculty on social media. The policies also authorize school officials to check the personal possessions of employees, including their private phones and email accounts.

Sewickley Academy said it retained the law firm Fisher Phillips under its previous leadership in early 2021 to review the handbooks and “to ensure they were current, aligned with widely utilized safety best practices, and following all local, state and federal laws. The handbook policies follow industry standards broadly used by hundreds of private schools across the country."

But the changes follow recent controversy at the academy over the removal of several top administrators this summer, including the institution’s longtime head of school, its equity director and other top administrators. The firings occurred in the weeks after an anonymous group sent a letter to homes of members of the Sewickley Academy community that said the school’s diversity, equity, inclusion and social justice initiatives amounted to political and ideological persuasion — an act many felt was threatening with a message that they believe had racist overtones.

Advertise with us

Though academy officials said the personnel changes had to do with enrollment problems and job performance and were not influenced by the letter, criticism came swiftly from students, parents, alumni and others. The developments led to the formation of a concerned parents group, formal complaints to a private school accrediting body, condemnation on social media and a small protest outside of the school.

Some in the school community say the new policies appear to be an effort to quash dissent against the academy and the leadership team that was installed following the firings.

The Sewickley Academy 2021-22 student handbook includes a parent/family cooperation policy that says the school believes “a positive and constructive working relationship” between the academy and families is necessary.

The policy goes on to say that “if the parent’s or other family member’s behavior, communications, or interactions on or off campus (including during school-sponsored events) is disruptive, intimidating, overly aggressive, or reflects a loss of confidence or disagreement with the School’s policies, methods of instruction, or discipline, or otherwise interferes with the School’s safety procedures, responsibilities, or accomplishment of its educational purpose or program, the School reserves the right to dismiss the family or family member from the community.”

The student handbook also has a new social media and networking policy that says “teachers and administrators periodically check [social media] sites and may determine that off campus behavior violates the School conduct code by making disparaging or negative comments about the School, administration, or faculty members in a manner that is disruptive to the School’s educational mission or activities.”

Advertise with us

It continues by saying “students are not permitted to create websites or social networking profiles to rate teachers, discuss aspects of the School, or otherwise disclose information online that the School would find offensive or inappropriate if posted in the School’s newspaper.”

Dominic Odom formed a group of academy parents in response to the events over the summer that protests the changes to the school’s leadership and monitors adjustments to the DEISJ initiatives. She said she believes the new policies are meant to stoke fear among people like herself who have been outspoken about the recent issues at the school.

“I think it states that they do not have the control of the school that they were hoping to have in their takeover,” Ms. Odom said. “I think it also states that their public relations campaign is not working, so I think this is a last ditch effort to serve as a distraction [for parents].”

A new inspection policy in this year’s employee handbook gives the school the power to search personal property, including the content of phones and private email accounts.

The policy says the school can “inspect all areas on campus, school buses, and employees’ personal property, including lockers, tool boxes, desks, purses, briefcases, packages, computers, electronic devices, cabinets and vehicles brought onto school property, school buses, or to school-sponsored events. Inspection of electronic devices includes inspection of all types of devices (computers, laptops, iPhones, iPads, Blackberries, cameras, etc.) and the contents, such as emails, texts, photos, images, documents, and any other information contained therein, including all communications on the School's systems from/to an employee's private email account such as Yahoo, AOL, etc."

Advertise with us

The academy said Friday that it  had not checked the private email accounts of any employees.

The employee policy was new to Gary Niels, the executive director of the Pennsylvania Association of Independent Schools, who himself was a head of school up until three years ago.

Mr. Niels, however, said he confirmed that the law firm has recommended these policies to hundreds of schools across the country, including dozens in Pennsylvania.

“They understand that it’s a fairly aggressive policy,” Mr. Niels said. “But they feel that for the safety of schools, schools should have this in writing to be able to draw on in circumstances in which they feel like they have to do a safety check.”

Mr. Niels said that given the current atmosphere at the school, people may be coming to the wrong conclusion about these policies.

Advertise with us

“I do know sometimes in schools when trust is broken, then the way people interpret everything that is happening is through the lens of distrust,” Mr. Niels said. “And sometimes that’s not the intention.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.