There aren’t many positives to a pandemic.
But in Pennsylvania, it at least created a new window into how state-owned universities conduct their business, specifically the 14 member campuses of the State System of Higher Education and their councils of trustees.
As universities shuttered in spring 2020, those trustee councils shifted their in-person meetings to Zoom. All of a sudden, students, parents and the general public could watch in real-time — and from great distances — and see how decisions affecting them were made, from room, board and fee increases to COVID-19 decisions and capital spending projects. Viewers didn't have to drive one, two, or three hours to the campuses to do so.
But that window on some campuses might be closing.
Spot checks of all 14 universities by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette found most planned, at least this fall, to continue a practice seen by good government groups as aiding transparency, though a few schools were undecided. At least one institution — Indiana University of Pennsylvania — said it is ending the live streams. Collectively, IUP and other system campuses receive $477 million in state taxpayer funds each year.
"Live streams for these meetings were done during the time in which capacity limitations were in place from the Governor’s office, and when social distancing was part of our COVID-19 protocols," IUP spokeswoman Michelle Fryling said Wednesday. "At this time, we are not requiring social distancing."
Read More
Asked if cost or another reason was behind the decision, Ms. Fryling did not respond.
Trustees at IUP will meet at 5 p.m. Sept. 9 on the university’s campus, about 60 miles northeast of Pittsburgh — and apparently, those who want to watch will have to be there.
The issue arises during an extraordinary time for the State System universities, with six of them being merged into two and others facing sizable changes in how they do business — all of which have impacts on the system’s nearly 94,000 students and thousands of faculty and staff.
Long before the pandemic, the State System’s board of governors in Harrisburg streamed its public meetings live. The University of Pittsburgh and Penn State University, which are state-adjacent schools, also stream their regular trustees’ meetings.
Groups that promote open government and follow education say State System campuses would be ill-advised to end the streams, even if the campuses are reopening for in-person classes.
“Cutting off virtual access to their meetings would be a mistake and have the potential to diminish public trust in the universities that these boards are supposed to be supporting, said Susan Spicka, executive director of Education Voters of Pennsylvania. “Going back to only in-person meetings would give the impression that the boards want to deliberate and make decisions without students, families, and communities knowing what they are doing.
“Nothing good would come from that.”
Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel to the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association, said the state’s Sunshine Act does not specifically address virtual technology. But she said nothing prohibits institutions from offering a stream, and her group supports it so long as it is in addition to in-person access.
“The goal of the Sunshine Act is to encourage and guarantee the public’s right to participate in government decision making, and all agencies should take steps to make it easier for the public to attend public meetings,” she said. “ When virtual technology is used in addition to in-person public meetings, it can result in increased public participation.’’
Khalif Ali, executive director of Pennsylvania Common Cause, offered a similar view. The head of the statewide faculty union admonished the IUP decision and urged the administration to reconsider.
“I fail to understand how eliminating live streaming of Council of Trustees meetings does anything but foster distrust, said Jamie Martin, president of the Association of Pennsylvania State College and University Faculties, who is a professor at IUP. “I sincerely hope that the IUP administration will reconsider this move to limit access and that others will continue to provide virtual access to COT meetings.”
At Slippery Rock University, live streaming of trustee meetings will continue. Those who will watch are asked to register for viewing, said Slippery Rock spokesman Robert King. The next meeting there is set for Sept. 23-24, with information available at sru.edu/about/administration/council-of-trustees.
Edinboro University says its trustees' meeting on Sept. 17, though a hybrid of in-person and remote, will offer a live stream on the school’s YouTube page.
"This link provides the Zoom information, a schedule of meetings, agendas, minutes and other information related to the Council of Trustees,'’ said Edinboro spokesman Angela Burrows.
The same is true at Clarion. Information is available about that school’s Sept. 15 meeting on the school’s website.
Cal U officials also plan to continue streaming meetings. Information about the Sept. 15 meeting is available on the school’s website.
Representatives of the rest of the 14 system campuses suggested that they will continue the live stream or are still unsure.
At Bloomsburg University, the next COT meeting is Oct. 6. Spokesman Thomas McGuire said, “I believe they are still planning to stream it. We don’t typically get the link until closer to the day of the event.’’
East Stroudsburg’s council will continue to be accessible online, too. That school’s next council meeting is Sept. 22 and will be live-streamed, spokeswoman Brenda Friday said. "The meeting will be a hybrid with some of our COT members together in person while other COT members and University staff and administrators will attend via ZOOM,” she added.
At Kutztown University, where the next trustee meeting is also set for Sept. 23, spokesman Matthew Santos said, "The plan now is to meet in person as in the past, which did not have a remote option for the public. However, we are still reviewing remote viewing possibilities for this year."
At Lock Haven, spokeswoman Elizabeth Arnold said livestreamed meetings will continue. The next meeting is Sept. 17 at 2 p.m.
At Mansfield University, representative Ryan McNamara said that the school will provide a live stream of the council of trustees meetings until further notice, including at the upcoming meeting on Sept. 29.
Millersville University spokeswoman Jante Kacskos said, “The meetings will be hybrid (most likely from here on unless the Delta variant pushes us back to Zoom only). There will be the option to meet in person with masks, or via Zoom. The next meeting is Sept. 21.”
Shippensburg University spokesman Megan Silverstrim said, “We continue to offer the option to dial into the meetings via phone. The next meeting is September 17.”
West Chester University’s first trustees' meeting will be on Oct. 7, and it is planned to be an in-person meeting with a Zoom option, spokeswoman Nancy Gainer said. The format will be determined closer to the date for the COT meeting on November 18.
A representative at Cheyney University could not immediately say whether a public Zoom option will be available.
Bill Schackner; bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner.
This story was updated on Sept. 14, 2021, to add a link to Bloomsburg University’s trustees meeting and reflect that East Stroudsburg trustees will next meet on Sept. 22.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.