Hello, Town and Gown harmony.

Meet COVID-19, and the increasingly uneasy debate about whether public universities in this state — specifically Penn State University, its largest — ought to require that students arrive this fall vaccinated against the coronavirus and its fast-spreading delta variant, with or without an act of the state Legislature.

For weeks, university leaders have detailed incentives for students and employees to get the shot, from drawings with cash prizes to Tuesday's virtual town hall where officials warned that students not vaccinated will face a regime of testing, indoor masking and cannot count on taking classes remotely if they fall ill.

But to date, Penn State has not specified whether it might require student vaccinations, saying it instead strongly urges them.

Advertise with us

That's apparently not enough for the borough council in State College, a Centre County community whose population swells each year when some 45,000 students arrive from various parts of Pennsylvania, the nation and overseas. The economic and cultural benefits of having a national research university in town are not lost on local officials, even if they also must deal with issues from crowding downtown to large parties.

A directive issued by Penn State on Wednesday evening drove home the rapidly changing environment.

“Due to the rapidly evolving COVID-19 conditions around the country and in Pennsylvania, effective immediately (Aug. 4), Penn State will require all students, faculty, staff and visitors — including those who are vaccinated and unvaccinated — to wear masks indoors at all campuses,” said the statement released by university spokesman Wyatt Dubois. “Within the last 24 hours, many counties that are home to Penn State campuses have shifted to “orange” status, warranting an immediate adjustment to the University’s on-campus masking requirement.”

In an open letter to the university dated Tuesday, before the latest campus statement, Council President Jesse Barlow reiterated the council's previous actions supporting a mandate, and he cited student and faculty bodies urging the same.

He shared a copy of his letter with the Post-Gazette on Wednesday.

Advertise with us

"The time to act is now. There must be ample time for those who remain unvaccinated to become at least partially vaccinated by the start of the fall semester," the letter said, quoting a campus group.

"We have a duty to protect our communities and those who belong to the Penn State Community and requiring vaccinations will ensure just that," it added.

Classes at Penn State are due to start Aug. 23.

On Tuesday, Penn State President Eric Barron and others, speaking at a virtual campus town hall, made it plain that while there is no mandate, the university is not neutral on vaccinations.

“Please, please get vaccinated. Think about all the other members of the community who may have children at home or other persons who are at risk,” he said. “We know that individuals that get vaccinated have mild or non-existent symptoms. It is the very best defense we have against COVID-19.”

Advertise with us

But the rift over this issue between the borough and Old Main appears pronounced. Earlier this week, borough Council Member Theresa Lafer summed up her feelings this way to the local newspaper, the Centre Daily Times:

“I am tired of hearing magical thinking about medicine, from a major university with a major hospital and med school attached to it,” she said. “So our students somehow will not get sick, and they will not bring this back to the people living in the community — That’s nonsense.

"Clearly, the people who make this decision don’t live in this community and do not care about this community. Penn State, at its most un-neighborly," she added.

A year ago, other small college towns became hotbeds for the infection as students moved into on- and off-campus dwellings, in some cases attending large parties and other gatherings where masks and social distancing guidelines were not followed.

Mandating vaccines for a specific illness in Pennsylvania requires an act of the Republican-controlled state Legislature. The 14 state-owned universities in this state have made clear they view themselves as unable to implement a requirement for their 94,000 students without such an act.

Advertise with us

Penn State and other state-related campuses including the University of Pittsburgh, Temple and Lincoln universities — while part of the commonwealth's public campus system — are not state-owned.

Wednesday evening’s announcement from the university applies to both the the main University Park campus and two dozen other locations that collectively enroll about 90,000 students.

“Community members will be required to wear masks indoors, including in all classrooms — regardless of size — as well as in meeting rooms, common areas in residence halls, and at any indoor events,” the statement read. “All individuals on campus will be permitted to eat in designated food service areas, and students living in residence halls will not be required to wear a mask in their living space.

“In addition, vaccinated employees with individual offices are not required to wear a mask in their personal office. In accordance with CDC guidance, all individuals must wear a face mask while using public transportation, it added.

Mr. Barlow, a resident of the borough for 40 years, is a computer science and engineering professor at the university, and he readily acknowledges he would not be living in the borough were it not for Penn State.

Advertise with us

But, he said, he’s not aware of a single faculty member who opposed the idea of a mandate and would like to see the university press the matter further, even in a state whose Republican-controlled state Legislature is not likely to abide. As a public official in the borough, he said, he senses a similar sentiment.

“People are peeved at the university,” he said. “I think they should press it harder. The thing I keep hearing is the trustees, they don’t live in here, most of them, and the Legislature, they don’t live here either. They’re imposing this on us.”

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter @Bschackner