With a final vote three weeks away on the controversial merger of six of Pennsylvania’s 14 state-owned universities, the NCAA says it still is waiting for information it needs from the schools to review what has become a key consideration in the system’s biggest change in its 38-year history.
The State System of Higher Education is seeking NCAA approval to continue offering a full array of athletics on all six campuses. They include California, Clarion and Edinboro universities in the west and Bloomsburg, Lock Haven and Mansfield in the northeast.
Sports have emerged as a key prerequisite for the mergers given schools’ reliance on those teams for a pipeline of students who fare well academically, as well as the role sports play in sustaining alumni and donor affinity.
An NCAA official told the Post-Gazette Friday that at this point, it has no specific timeline for making a decision and can not handicap the odds of an approval.
“Basically, we are waiting for the impacted schools to submit information for review by the Division II Membership Committee. At this time, there is no definitive date when a decision will be rendered,” said Gail Dent, a spokeswoman for the National Collegiate Athletic Association, headquartered in Indianapolis. “Also, each scenario regarding mergers and integrations is different; therefore, they are reviewed and evaluated on a case-by-case basis.”
’ ...We cannot comment on the likelihood of an approval of a proposal,” she added.
Read More
In response, David Pidgeon, a State System spokesman, indicated that the system’s board of governors is prepared to vote July 14-15 with or without NCAA signoff on sports. It was not immediately clear what information is still outstanding, but Mr. Pidgeon said system officials are in regular contact with the NCAA.
“Those conversations are ongoing, and a decision by the Board regarding integrations is not dependent on the NCAA’s meeting schedule,” Mr. Pidgeon said. “If the Board approves implementation plans at its July meeting, the first cohort of students at an integrated institution would be August 2022.”
State System leaders, including Chancellor Daniel Greenstein, have said it is imperative the board acts in July, warning that finances at the schools are severely strained and growing weaker given sharp enrollment losses and cost pressures in the Commonwealth, 47th out of 50 states in its per capita support for higher education. Delaying for a year could cost $50 million, he said.
But others, who have warned the system is moving ahead with an unfinished plan too quickly, had a sharply different take Friday.
“This is just another in a long list of examples of why forcing a vote on consolidation on such an accelerated timeline makes absolutely no sense,” said Susan Spicka, executive director of Education Voters of Pennsylvania. “Moving forward without answers to questions from the NCAA would be beyond irresponsible and would demonstrate complete disregard for current and future student athletes at these schools.”
The State System, meanwhile, has announced a special meeting on June 30 to elect student members to its board of governors. No votes are planned, but afterward, the board of governors will hold a public workshop regarding the campus merger plans.
Critics argue that rushing ahead with an unfinished plan risks a disaster for students in a system created to boost access to a college education. The plan does not make clear what share of students’ courses will be pushed online and has not secured the level of support from the state Legislature needed to be more than a temporary Band-Aid, they contend.
“I had not heard the NCAA was waiting for additional information. I knew the System had provided answers back in late March to a series of NCAA questions. I guess those responses created more questions, said John Gump, head of the system’s coaches bargaining unit within the Association of Pennsylvania State College and University Faculties. “I do not know what additional information it is looking for, and it certainly doesn't sound like a resolution will be forthcoming in the next few weeks.”
“I am concerned this process is moving too quickly, and there are far too many unknowns for an informed decision to be made by the BOG next month,” he said.
The State System enrolls about 94,000 students, down from nearly 120,000 in 2010. The mergers would create a pair of enhanced institutions that collectively enroll 29,000 students and could leverage their course programs to boost opportunities, proponents say
Lyndsay Kensinger, spokeswoman for Gov. Tom Wolf, said he “supports individual campuses within the proposed integrated universities maintaining their current athletics structure and is hopeful that NCAA will provide information ahead of the July 14-15 vote.” She referred questions beyond that to system officials and the NCAA.
Some in the Legislature have sought a delay. Earlier Friday, Jamie Martin, president of the 5,000-member APSCUF faculty union, said, “We would at least like to see a delay until students are back on campus in the fall and go to Town Halls [to] find out from them what they know and what questions they have.”
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.