With all four public hearings now in the books, upward of 100 individuals have weighed in on controversial plans to merge six public universities belonging to the State System of Higher Education. Of them, one speaker endorsed the idea and the rest unleashed a torrent of criticism.

As with hearings on Wednesday, which were held on Zoom, commenters Thursday warned that the plan due for a final vote in mid-July is not finished and also “muddled” and “rushed.” They said students in rural parts of Pennsylvania who already have fewer educational options would be among the hardest hit, as state campuses intended to make higher education accessible merge programs and departments.

It will push students to take a greater share of their courses remotely, they said, creating what one professor called “second-class students” — unable to join peers in classes that are split between those face to face and others participating online from up to 150 miles away.

Issues with the plans aside, multiple speakers asked why State System leaders, including Chancellor Daniel Greenstein, board chairwoman Cynthia Shapira and others, are not fighting the Legislature more aggressively for better funding. The Pennsylvania General Assembly provides colleges with less aid per capita than all but three other states, its near-bottom ranking barely half the national funding average.

Advertise with us

“My first point is, why are you letting them off the hook?” asked Kutztown University professor Daniel Spiegel. “Before any reorganization occurs it is up to the Legislature of this commonwealth to decide if they are willing to fund higher education at an appropriate and responsible level.”

He said erosion of robust offerings would undermine campuses, devastate communities whose economies rely on the campuses, and potentially set many of the six schools up for eventual closure.

“These schools will be gutted academically,” he said.

In all, about eight hours of testimony were offered, including Thursday afternoon’s session that stretched nearly double the planned 90 minutes allotted. Some waited in the queue as long as two hours to speak.

The plans call for California, Clarion and Edinboro universities in the west and Bloomsburg, Lock Haven and Mansfield in the northeast to be merged into two enhanced institutions, with California and Bloomsburg as the main campuses. The institutions that collectively enroll 29,000 students — nearly a of third of students attending the 14 State System schools — would share faculty, staff and a course array still being decided.

Advertise with us

If approved by the system board of governors when they meet in July, the first students in the combined campuses would enroll in fall 2022.

Gayatri Devi, who teachers English at Lock Haven, asked the board to vote against the mergers.

The proposed consolidation “strikes at the heart of the teacher-student relationship,” she said. “It breaks up their degree plans into online and face-to face courses, potentially to be taken at three different campuses.

“The past year of pandemic-enforced Zoom modality has categorically shown that students do not like online learning.” she added.

“Students from our rural communities deserve a chance at making their lives successful with affordable tuition and a university education that is fulsome and substantial, and not piecemeal, fragmented, diluted and badly stitched together.”

Advertise with us

She noted her role in shaping former students who went on to be lawyers, professors, editors and writers and said the system should not deprive others of that benefit.

“I know my students,” she said. “They know me.”

There was a heavy representation of faculty both days, but also speaking were students, alumni and some members of the affected communities. There was the medical student and West Chester University graduate who urged the system to rethink, and a recent Lock Haven alumnus and student athlete who did the same.

The tone of remarks varied widely.

Jason Worzbyt, a music professor at Indiana University of Pennsylvania, emphatically asked how system leaders could stand by as universities are deprived of reasonable support, leaving students looking to educational opportunities in other states that are more affordable.

Advertise with us

“Rather than making a full-throated defense of the importance of higher education,” he said, “there has been deafening silence. Where is your outrage?”

Another speaker told leaders who watched in silence that he did not envy their impending decision, likening them to drivers of a bus who see flashing lights warning of a disaster ahead. “Please pull over,” he said.

Ms. Shapira has said at each session that the State System is listening and that the mergers are intended to boost student opportunities in the face of a 22% enrollment loss systemwide since 2010 and other budget pressures. However, system officials did not respond to requests for comment about the tone of and level of opposition over both days.

But Save Our State Schools, a Harrisburg group opposed to the mergers, issued a statement Thursday night immediately afterward.

"The public has spoken, and they are clearly not in favor of this rushed, shoddy consolidation plan,” spokeswoman Danielle Gross said. “The fundamental question for the PASSHE Board of Governors members ahead of their July meeting where they will vote on the plan: will they listen?"

Advertise with us

Several speakers, among them Holiday Adair, a Cal U faculty member, appeared at multiple sessions. She told system leaders Thursday that it is shameful and disgusting to see university leaders each year essentially beg the Legislature for support it needs.

Todd Newcomer, a State System alumnus living in the Allentown area, said he and his wife are parents of four children likely to one day attend one of the 14 system schools.

"Please vote no on a plan that calls for consolidation of universities in regions of the state with the lowest higher education access already," he said. "Please vote no on a plan that takes an incredibly smart public investment that gets a 10-to-1 return and guts it, leaving rural communities with higher unemployment and vague promises about online learning.”

He added, “We already have a system we can be proud of. Please don't gut it.”

The Association of Pennsylvania State College and University Faculties has scheduled listening sessions of its own through mid-June.

Advertise with us

In addition, the State System is accepting written comments on both plans. A form to submit them is here.

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter @Bschackner.