In a matter of weeks and in some cases days, America’s colleges and universities were forced last year to change the way they operate.
As the pandemic introduced new conditions and new patterns of behavior, postsecondary institutions across the country transitioned to online learning, testing the theory that higher education requires a student’s physical presence.
Research universities, moreover, proved themselves invaluable in the mitigation of the virus by helping to develop vaccines, create forecasting tools and provide the public with easily accessible sources of data.
It was a watershed moment for an industry already facing massive change.
From 1985 to 2012, America experienced what some are calling peak education — a golden age of learning. There was a broadly shared consensus that as many people as possible should go to college, and enrollment rates reflected that. Huge investments were made in ultramodern student centers and dorms with elaborate amenities. The value of the experience was organized around face-to-face classroom instruction and on-campus living.
Since 2012, however, the total number of students in America's colleges and universities has declined each year. The shift to online learning presents these institutions with a massive challenge but also an enormous opportunity to reverse the trend of declining enrollment and extend the realm of knowledge by educating more people.
Read More
What does this all this mean for the future of higher education?
We talked to Bryan Alexander, author of three books, including his latest, “Academia Next: The Futures of Higher Education.” A futurist, researcher and senior scholar at Georgetown University, the professor took time out to do some future gazing.
Q. Will the pandemic reflect a turning point in attitudes toward online learning?
A: During the course of the pandemic, colleges and universities learned a great deal about how to teach and otherwise work online. It’s possible that after the pandemic, we’ll see some students prefer the online experience, either for convenience or because they are accustomed to it. Some campuses will try to expand their online offerings. The challenge here is doing so without compromising quality.
Q. Can you talk about the experience of online learning? What are some aspects of education that students may be missing while studying remotely?
A. Online learning experiences are enormously diverse due to the wide range of American institutions, as well as the variety of instructors and their backgrounds. Students may miss parts of the residential or otherwise physically co-located experience, from parties to meeting people and exploring a campus with its local area.
Q. How will demographics alter the future of higher education?
A. We should expect smaller numbers of traditional-age students (18-22 years old, roughly). This will increase competition among institutions teaching that population. It may open opportunities for those colleges and universities to expand offerings for adults and seniors, as the latter population grows.
Q. The total number of students in American’s colleges and universities has declined every year for almost a decade. What explains this trend?
Several things. First, the massive collapse of enrollment in the for-profit education sector. Second, rising anxiety about student debt and the cost of college. Third, a recent decline in international students. Coming up, a demographic crunch reducing the number of teenagers.
Q. Women continue to outnumber men on campus, comprising nearly 60% of enrollment in universities and colleges. Rates for men, just over 40%, are at their lowest levels ever recorded. What do you think explains this trend, and do you see it continuing?
A: It seems that more men than women see careers available that don’t require postsecondary degrees. This could continue for some time, especially if numbers of men view higher education as unwelcoming.
Q. Are there ways that universities can remedy some of the inegalitarian consequences of higher education?
A: One way is to target resources toward marginalized populations, including advising and mental health support. Another is to address the digital divide by sending students hardware support or tailoring online content to better suit low bandwidth capacity.
Q. The total number of international students worldwide has more than doubled over the last 20 years. How has the recent drop in international travel affected the business model of universities?
A. One impact is financial, as international students represent a significant revenue stream for many campuses. The pandemic accelerates that decline, as fewer learners are able to travel. Indian students are likely to continue coming to the United States, as that nation’s enormous population (about to become the world’s largest) ramps up demand for postsecondary education beyond local capacity. China has already followed this path. It is an open question if U.S.-China geopolitical tensions will reduce the flow of Chinese students.
Q. Do you foresee a future in which brick-and-mortar universities simply go out of business?
A. Some, yes. America seems to have overbuilt higher education capacity, which means some programs and entire campuses will be consolidated, merged or shuttered.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.