The Fox Chapel Area school board voted 6-1 during a special meeting Monday to hire independent counsel to determine whether Superintendent Gene Freeman ordered district personnel to destroy right-to-know documents.
The only board member to vote against the move was Edith Cook, who notified district officials in June that she had been alerted by others that some documents had been removed for shredding, including some that may have been destroyed to avoid disclosure under Pennsylvania’s Right to Know law.
After those allegations were reported, the district hired Thomas Breth of the Dillon McCandless King Coulter & Graham law firm to investigate. Mr. Breth reported at a school board meeting Sept. 9 that he had found no wrongdoing. At the same meeting, Dr. Freeman, who plans to retire at the end of this school year, angrily demanded an investigation to clear his name.
Mrs. Cook called the second investigation unnecessary.
In response, Nancy Foster, the board vice president, said Mrs. Cook instigated the second investigation by her FaceBook post the day before the Sept. 9 meeting, claiming that Mr. Freeman forced district office staff to shred certain RTK documents.
“That was an allegation that had never been made before,” Ms. Foster said. “If you would issue a public apology to Dr. Freeman, we would not need to pursue litigation.”
“I’m obligated to report RTK document shredding,” Mrs. Cook said. “I didn’t know to what extent it involved district personnel.” She said that was why she called the state auditor general’s office for advice and was told to call the district’s solicitor, Paul Guiffre.
By involving him and posting her suspicions, Mr. Guiffre said, Mrs. Cook created a conflict of interest and the need for the first legal investigation, which cost the district $15,000. “Do you not understand what’s a closed, private investigation,” Mr. Guiffre said.
“I’m very troubled and distressed how it was conducted,” Mrs. Cook said. She claimed Terry Wirginis, the board president, hired Mr. Breth on his own.
Mrs. Cook made a motion asking that board review its procedures for handling investigations. “I think our public needs to know we’ve behaved appropriately,” she said as she made the motion. The motion failed when no one on the board offered a second.
The board then agreed to retain independent counsel to review Mrs. Cook’s latest allegations and what, if any, action to take.
“You specifically called Gene out on Facebook. . . ,” Mrs. Foster said. “You wouldn’t talk to him or the investigator but you told everybody else about it,” she said of Mrs. Cook’s post, which has since been taken down.
Mrs. Cook then asked whether the action meant the board was responding to a personnel matter. And board member Somer Obernauer asked for verification that the vote was not on a personnel matter.
Mrs. Foster said the motion was to deal with Mrs. Cook’s allegation against Mr. Freeman, not a personnel issue. Mr. Wirginis agreed, saying if an independent counsel found that Mr. Freeman required district staff to shred RTK documents, then the outgoing superintendent would have to be dealt with appropriately.
“We are just determining whether we should go ahead and hire counsel,” Mr. Wirginis said. “We’ll take this first things first. We will rely on advice of counsel.”
“I am very, very distressed by the way this matter has been handled,” Mrs. Cook said.
Mr. Wirginis said he’s looking forward to hearing the findings, adding, “Counsel can review the documents to determine how we should proceed.”
Earlier, the school board unanimously accepted the resignation of long-time school board member Robert Mauro.
In a letter of resignation, Mr. Mauro said he’d served on the Fox Chapel Area School Board since 2008 and was proud of his accomplishments during the first decade. But he said he became discouraged by party politics and board members’ FaceBook posts since June.
“It now seems to me [that] social media comments have become more important than serving our community,” he said.
Because Mr. Mauro was board treasurer, members then voted Lisa Rutkowski to the office. It was a unanimous vote, with Mrs. Rutkowski abstaining.
The board will interview candidates Oct. 3 to serve out Mr. Mauro’s term through 2021.
Mrs. Foster said she was sorry to see Mr. Mauro leave. “He took his job very seriously. He wanted what was best for the kids. He had no agenda.”
CORRECTION, posted Sept. 17, 2019. This article has been updated to note that allegations about documents being shredded were made to board member Edith Cook, who passed them on to school district officials.
Rita Michel, freelance writer, suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.