The Pittsburgh Public Schools board this week renewed the five-year charters for the Hill House Passport Academy and Propel Hazelwood.

The vote was unanimous for both, an unusual move for a board that isn’t particularly friendly to charter schools. But members said they voted to renew the charters despite questions about student performance because of the unique circumstances of each school.

The Hill House Passport Academy — which also amended its name to Passport Academy Charter School following the dissolution of the Hill House Association earlier this year — allows students between the ages of 17 and 21 who have dropped out of school to return and earn a diploma. Propel Hazelwood, one of 13 Propel charter schools in Allegheny County, enrolls students in kindergarten through eighth grade and is the only school in the Hazelwood neighborhood.

“This particular situation in Hazelwood is unique,” said board member Sala Udin. “Schools in Hazelwood have been closed and now the community ends up with no schools other than this charter school. A school represents a whole lot more to a community than just a place of education. It is an important institution and an important component of the social fabric of that community.

Advertise with us

“To expect the Hazelwood community to recover economically with absolutely no public school is not fair and so I will be voting in favor of the Propel charter school renewal for Hazelwood because of its unique situation. But I do not expect that as a general rule I will be a charter school champion.”

Others said they voted in favor of the renewal Wednesday night for the same reason.

“I am aware that that community is really trying to build itself back up and there's a lot of organizations that are supporting it,” said board member Cynthia Falls. “I honestly believe that this community deserves the opportunity to continue on. Hazelwood deserves this second chance, all of us helping this community to grow again.”

“The community has really, really embraced Propel, Propel has really embraced the community,” said board member Terry Kennedy. “They understand it’s not the perfect school but it has a new principal this past school year... let's work with them and work with the law office to come up with agreeable standards (for improvement).”

Mr. Udin said he voted to renew the Passport Academy Charter School because of its ability to serve a specific population of students, although he reiterated that his vote to renew that particular charter should not suggest how he will vote on future charter applications.

Advertise with us

“The Hill House Passport school is a very special jewel and I'm glad we have it,” he said. “It is taking in people who may be at their very last option, this could be their very last shot at success for their lives. But I'm also aware that to have a successful school for people who have dropped out or who have been pushed out of public schools requires a special approach and talent and technique. It is not clear to me that the school has described what that special talent and technique is. At some appropriate point, I would like to hear a presentation of how their approach to educating dropouts and getting them back into the system, how that works, what their needs are and how we might be able to support them.”

Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1590 or @Ebehrman on Twitter.