A decade after the city school district promised to create a premier college preparatory school in the Hill District, Pittsburgh Public Schools says it is poised to finally deliver.
But the proposal requires a significant change to Pittsburgh Milliones 6-12, University Preparatory School, known to many as U Prep, that includes splitting the school and sending all its students in grades six to eight to Pittsburgh Arsenal 6-8 in Lawrenceville next school year.
The plan and its timing have raised some concerns in a community already weary of shuffling its students and of “happy talk” from the school district, as one board member put it. Yet administrators believe the move will not only help U Prep’s middle school students — whose achievement the district has called “persistently stubborn” — by moving them to a school with a track record of helping students improve, it will also enable them to focus U Prep’s resources on its high school-age students and college preparatory magnet program.
The school board will vote on the reconfiguration at its meeting Wednesday night.
“I want to emphasize that it’s not abandoning U Prep,” Deputy Superintendent Anthony Anderson said. “We still want to make sure we put the resources in U Prep to make sure that high school is successful also. What that does is now we can we can focus on that nine-to-12 band and do what’s right to make that early college program more successful, and we can work on the students that are feeding into U Prep from Arsenal and give them the foundation needed by providing some of the resources necessary.”
The plan is to move an estimated 99 students in grades six through eight from U Prep to Arsenal, a feeder school to U Prep that has been among the top 15% in the state for the past five years in terms of student improvement. At the same time, PPS administrators want to strengthen the district’s relationship with the Community College of Allegheny County, allowing more U Prep high school students to take its college-level courses and earn entry-level college credit while they are PPS students.
Read More
District leaders outlined a plan that calls for, among other things, realigning the resources provided by the Heinz Fellows, who provide additional support for Hill District schools via a partnership with the Heinz Endowments and the University of Pittsburgh; eventually adding more career and technical education programs at the school; and working with all of the school’s ninth graders via mentoring and counseling to ensure that they have the necessary skills to be successful in college-level courses, such as note-taking, studying and time management.
Locations of Arsenal and Milliones schools
Multiple school board members said they had concerns about the timeline of the change and questioned administrators as to why the proposal was presented in May rather than months earlier.
“I don’t have any doubts that Arsenal is a great opportunity for the middle school students,” board President Lynda Wrenn said. “I do feel it’s rushed and there wasn’t sufficient time for community buy-in.”
Mr. Anderson said the administration has been considering the reconfiguration plan for several months and listening to parents’ calls for change at the school since before U Prep’s new principal was hired last summer. He said the district felt it would be more effective to move the middle school students from U Prep to Arsenal, a program that is already having success, rather than delaying and taking several more years to rebuild the program at U Prep. Currently, only about 18% of the middle school-age children in the U Prep feeder pattern actually attend the school, he said. Most of them attend other PPS schools or charter schools.
“We felt that this was the time and we have to do what’s best for the students immediately,” Mr. Anderson said.
School board member Sala Udin, who represents the Hill District, asked the board last week to consider waiting until next year to vote. The district held three community meetings — including one each at U Prep and Arsenal — to discuss the plan in the past month, and only a handful of parents were in attendance at all of them combined, Mr. Udin said.
He said the proposal is reminiscent of the so-called “rightsizing plan” led by then-Superintendent Mark Roosevelt more than a decade ago, which resulted in the district closing 22 schools.
“We need the time to plan,” Mr. Udin said during a committee meeting last week. “We need a planning year.”
“We need time to engage the parents and the community in this conversation about Hill District education instead of coming again with a new rightsizing plan. We don’t need another rightsizing plan, it has done enough damage to the Hill District. We need a planning process that involves the parents, that involves the students, that involves community leaders.
“I propose that we do not pass this proposal yet,” he continued. “Maybe we will, after we’ve had some time to get some community engagement, some parent engagement, after we’ve had some time to hear an educationally sound rationale for the decision.”
Mr. Udin added that he has spoken with Arsenal Principal Patti Camper, and was impressed by the “great work” happening at that school. He raised concerns about the neighborhood relationships between Lawrenceville and the Hill District, and argued that the Westinghouse Academy partnership with Wilkinsburg schools that began in 2016 was successful because the district took a year to work out the details.
“My real point is that unless we take the time to plan well, then we plan quickly, but it has consequences down the road,” he said.
Board member Kevin Carter, whose district also includes part of the Hill District, requested more detailed information about the goals of the plan and the student performance data at each school. He echoed concerns that the plan is rushed.
“I for one am not too keen on busing Hill District students out of the Hill District, which has been sort of a historical recurrence with Pittsburgh Public Schools, particularly as it relates to black neighborhoods,” Mr. Carter said. “I have concerns of that nature, not because of anything related to the educators or the administration [at Arsenal].”
U Prep in its current form is a “patchwork” of what it was promised to be, he said. The only way to fix it is to shift the culture grade-level by grade-level, he said, adding that the district needs to be strategic about how it reforms the school.
Board member Sylvia Wilson said the proposal will strengthen the early college programming already in place at U Prep, and hopefully draw back students from the Hill District and across the district to U Prep.
“This is unfortunate and regrettable, the timing,” she said. “Absolutely, absolutely regrettable. But it’s an opportunity to do something for the children from the Hill District, the children from Lawrenceville and students from anywhere in the city of Pittsburgh to take advantage of that early college program.”
But Mr. Udin said the initial details about the proposed changes at U Prep are reminiscent of the original promises that were made and not delivered.
“It’s just a lot of happy talk if it’s not implemented, if it’s not executed, with integrity and good planning,” he said. “We’ve got to get the parents involved. That’s what our commitment to community engagement is supposed to be about.”
Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1590 or @Ebehrman on Twitter.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.