McKeesport High School students won lawsuit against school
McKeesport Area School District and ACLU officials have agreed to a settlement that would allow for the creation of a black student union after a previous dispute over its leadership structure.
The American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania filed a civil rights lawsuit this month on behalf of students who claimed that the district had denied them permission to create the club. District officials said they objected to the club’s proposed structure, not its stated mission.
Under the group’s original charter, it would have had on its executive committee two non-student advisers who would have voted on all decisions. But attorneys for the district argued that such a structure would have breached federal law and district policy.
According to a preliminary copy of the settlement, students may form the club within 10 days of submitting an application to the district, as long as “non-school persons” do not participate in meetings.
District officials had previously dismissed initial efforts to form the group as political maneuvering by McKeesport mayoral candidate Fawn Walker-Montgomery, whose ninth grade daughter is one of the students listed in the lawsuit. Ms. Walker-Montgomery has ties to one of the groups that would have had voting power under the group’s initial charter.
This “was never about a black student union,” Superintendent Mark Holtzman said at a news conference last week. “This was about outside control of a student group that we knew from the beginning was not appropriate or legal to do in our school system.”
Read More
Students wanted to create the club as a platform to discuss and address what they described as examples of racial bias within the district, including “racially insensitive” comments by teachers, according to the lawsuit. The complaint cited several examples, such as the district’s alleged failure to discipline a middle school teacher who told students that “black people benefited from being property during slavery.”
On Monday, district officials again said that they support the students’ push for a black student union under the terms of the settlement.
“It is unfortunate that we were forced to waste valuable educational resources that should have been allocated for our students’ continued success,” district spokeswoman Kristen James said in a news release. “Our district never opposed the formation of the black student union and is eager to move forward.”
In a separate news release, Pennsylvania ACLU legal director Vic Walczak said that they “could not be prouder” of the students.
“These brave students refused to accept no to their request for a black student union club and took their battle to court,” he said. “Now, after months of stalling by the district, the students are excited to move forward with their club.”
Matt McKinney: mmckinney@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944, or on Twitter @mmckinne17.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.