Peters Township school directors reached a consensus at an April 8 buildings and grounds committee meeting to convert the present high school building into a middle school after the new high school opens in the 2021-22 school year.

Superintendent Jeannine French presented eight options to the board, all of which include closing the current middle school and utilizing the current high school as a sixth- through eighth- grade middle school. The middle school now houses seventh- and eighth-grade students

Ms. French said the administration analyzed the district’s current and historical enrollment and projected enrollment out to the 2022-23 school year. Additionally, building condition and utility costs were factored in to the eight options.

“We’re not just planning for the next few years,” Ms. French said, stressing that “enrollment is cyclical” and she added 317 developable lots have been approved by township council in 2018-19.

Advertise with us

“That means there are 317 opportunities for families,” she said, adding she realized that not all of the lots will attract families with school-age children.

Ms. French said as recently as 10 years ago, the district had enrollments as high as 350 students per grade level, but that figure has declined over the years.

“There may be a time in the district where we get back to the enrollment we had 10 years ago,” she said.

The options presented took into consideration room for growth up to 14 classrooms per grade level at 25 students per class, or about 350 students per grade level.

Of the eight options Ms. French presented, one that would entail the least impact on the other elementary schools. In that option, McMurray Elementary would house fourth- and fifth-grade students, rather than its current fourth-, fifth- and sixth-grade configuration. There would be no change at Pleasant Valley and Bower Hill, which would remain kindergarten through third-grade buildings.

Advertise with us

In that scenario, the current high school would act as a middle school and also house the district’s administrative offices.

Board member Daniel Taylor asked the administration to look at the cost of adding on to Bower Hill elementary and possibly closing Pleasant Valley elementary school. He pointed out that perhaps 10 classrooms could be added to Bower Hill Elementary for around the cost of upgrading Pleasant Valley. The cost to repair and replace items that are “high priority” at Pleasant Valley would be around $860,000 according to the district’s 2016 facilities assessment. To fully upgrade the building, it would cost about $2.9 million.

The administration also looked at staffing efficiencies if the current middle school was reconfigured and moved to the high school. Ms. French said about 17 sixth-grade teachers would move from McMurray Elementary to the middle school in that scenario.

“The (current) high school has a lot more instructional support,” Ms. French said, including larger lab facilities and a larger gymnasium.

The cost to repair and replace “high priority” items at the high school, including windows and the heating, air conditioning and ventilation systems and other items, would be about $9.1 million, according to the 2016 facilities assessment. The cost to fully upgrade the high school exceeds $13 million.

Advertise with us

Board member Ronald Dunleavy said that it would make sense to keep the current high school because it has the most classrooms and athletic facilities and because Pleasant Valley sits right beside it.

The board directed the administration to look into how much it would cost to add classrooms to Bower Hill. The board also asked that the numbers on how much it would cost to upgrade the district’s buildings be updated because the facilities study that was done in 2016 is outdated.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.