Students from McKeesport Area High School have filed a civil rights lawsuit against the McKeesport Area School District and its superintendent, saying it has denied them permission to form a club they dubbed the Black Student Union, the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania announced Wednesday.
According to the ACLU's release, school administrators "diverted the students by requiring new conditions and eventually by refusing to approve the club," because they objected to its name. The administrators had proposed instead an alternative club, the McKeesport Student Union, the ACLU wrote, citing a press report.
The students, through the ACLU, said in the statement that they had "concerns about the way students of color are treated at McKeesport. ... We feel that the club, which would be open to all students, will be a space for us to discuss our concerns and then plan to constructively address those concerns in the broader school community, including with adult leaders. Unfortunately, administrators keep shutting us down.”
The ACLU claims that state data show that in McKeesport schools, students of color are more likely to be disciplined than white students.
District Superintendent Mark Holtzman declined to comment on Wednesday, but in an interview last week, he said said Fawn Walker-Montgomery, who is a candidate for mayor of McKeesport, is behind the push for the black student union. He also has denied that minority students are unfairly treated.
The school district later on Wednesday issued a statement from school board President Joseph Lopretto and Vice President Mary Jane Keller.
Read More
“It is disheartening that the political aspirations of one individual has set in motion a case that can turn back time on decades of progression, not only in our schools, but in our country,” the statement read.
“As President and Vice President of the McKeesport Area School District Board of Directors, we strongly support Dr. Mark Holtzman, [Assistant Superintendent] Dr. Tia Wanzo, and their administrative team, that have continued to try and resolve this, without cooperation from the ACLU.
“Following the initial conversation with their representative, the suggestion to form an unbiased group of students to lead a discussion, was completed. Students, without any adult interference from Dr. Holtzman, or other staff members, met on this issue and determined that the need for a McKeesport Student Union was valid, but not one that would cause division amongst their peers.”
The statement went on to say, “Those invited to attend these discussions included a majority of African American students, including the three founding students in support of the BSU creation, at the board meeting in February. Since that time, information surrounding this process has been twisted and released onto social media to create anger and frustration that isn’t warranted,” the statement said.
According to the ACLU, the district's denial violates the First Amendment and the federal Equal Access Act, "which requires public schools to grant students the ability to form non-curricular clubs outside of instruction time without administrative interference and without discrimination based on the message or purpose of the club."
Witold Walczak, legal director of the ACLU of Pennsylvania, called it “unfortunate that the superintendent has blocked these wonderful, energetic young activists from organizing a Black Student Union.” He added that “it’s also flatly illegal.”
The students have sought to create the club since February, and the ACLU warned in March that it would sue the school district if it blocked them.
The ACLU is seeking a preliminary injunction to allow the students to form the Black Student Union.
Deana Carpenter contributed.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.