The North Allegheny School District will not change the start time for high school for the next school year, a decision that did not sit well with several school board members.

Superintendent Robert Scherrer cited “significant costs” and a nationwide shortage of bus drivers for the decision.

Mr. Scherrer noted that they plan to redistrict students for the 2020-21 school year, after the addition to Franklin Elementary is complete. There may be some efficiencies in bus routes that will allow them to change the high school start time then, he added.

North Allegheny began a study to determine if the start time for high school – now 7:25 a.m., one of the earliest in the region – would help combat student stress. Surveys taken by teachers, parents and students endorsed the idea of starting both middle and high school at 8 a.m.

Advertise with us

But a study by the district and the company that provides its scheduling software showed that shifting to two instead of three tiers of bus runs would cost between $1.8 million and $2.8 million a year and require hiring between 29 and 46 bus drivers.

For next year, the district added three buses, which may cut the time that some students in the far reaches of the large district spend on the bus, Mr. Scherrer said.

Roger Sechler, director of operations, said there is a nationwide shortage of drivers who hold commercial driver’s licenses. And school bus drivers are even harder to attract, he said, because a five-hour shift is split between morning and afternoon. Most of their drivers, he added, are retirees.

Mr. Scherrer said the administration will also work to develop guidelines for homework and analyze practice and meeting schedules for extracurricular activities and athletics to make sure “we are maximizing that time.”

Board member Michael Meyer said homework is a key cause of both stress and students not getting enough sleep. He cited a letter that he received from a student who, the week before Christmas, had four tests, a 12-page paper, a three-page paper and two projects due at the same time. Only the 12-page paper was announced before that week, and the student had to skip his extracurricular activities to get it all done, he said.

Advertise with us

“That’s punitive. That’s not enjoyment. A week before Christmas? Can’t we as a district and as a board say, 'Can we stagger that?’” he said. “We have to tackle this homework issue and this issue of how much work these kids have.”

Other board members criticized the decision to wait a year.

“It is now crystal clear that start times impact student sleep – and that later start times yield immeasurable benefits,” said board member Kevin Mahler.

He noted that Pine-Richland recently voted to start high school at 7:45 a.m. Mt. Lebanon starts at 8 a.m. Seneca Valley starts at 8:09 a.m. and State College is moving its high school start time to 8:40 a.m.

Board member Scott Russell said that students at the intermediate high school, who are not allowed to drive to school, “beat the system today by getting their parents to drive them to school,” and senior high students can get an extra half-hour of sleep by driving instead of taking the bus.

Advertise with us

“We’ve been looking at this for a good 18 months, and I am disappointed as well that we didn’t reach a solution,” he said.

Allyson Minton said that State College “got very creative” with their school days by slightly lengthening the elementary school day. “We are not going to solve this problem by just moving buses around,” she said. “We need to take a programmatic look at this in addition to examining our transportation model.”

Wills Kraus, the senior high representative to the board, said he sees students “falling asleep in class all time,” even those who get extra sleep by driving to school.

Board President Rick McClure said annual cost of combining the start times for high school and middle school would pay the debt service for the planned renovations to Franklin and McKnight elementary schools.

“While a start time change is a really neat idea, …it becomes a dollars and cents issue. Do we do the renovations to Franklin or do we do a start time. It becomes that kind of dynamic,” he said.

Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.