A months-long investigation into who signed a school board member’s name to a document in Pittsburgh’s bid for Amazon’s second headquarters was “inconclusive,” Pittsburgh Public Schools officials announced Friday.

The review was commissioned by district Solicitor Ira Weiss in November, after school board member Kevin Carter denied that he signed his name on a support letter representing the school district in the city's failed pitch for Amazon's HQ2. At the time, Mr. Carter said he'd like for whoever forged his signature to lose his or her job.

He could not immediately be reached for comment Friday.

The region's failed Amazon HQ2 bid included up to $4.6 billion in state incentives and some $4.2 billion in local subsidies generated largely through taxes on Amazon employees. Had HQ2 come to southwestern Pennsylvania, some of the proposed sweeteners -- such as tax-increment financing -- would have faced a school board vote.

Advertise with us

According to the investigation report, it could not be determined who signed Mr. Carter’s name to the letter.

“We are satisfied that a thorough investigation was conducted based on the information available,” Board President Lynda Wrenn said in a statement Friday. “Although we did not get the definitive answer we had hoped, the situation did result in valuable lessons learned. We must implement tighter internal documentation to ensure that this kind of confusion never happens again.”

The alleged signature from Mr. Carter, who at the time was chair of the school board's business and finance committee, appeared on the letter next to the signature of Superintendent Anthony Hamlet. The document was included in the regional big package, which included similar letters signed by Allegheny County Rich Fitzgerald and Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto.

Monaca-based Corporate Security and Investigations, a private firm, was paid about $4,200 to conduct an independent investigation, Mr. Weiss said.

As part of the review process, investigators with CSI interviewed Mr. Carter, Mr. Weiss and Mr. Hamlet, as well as Kevin Acklin and Dan Gilman, Mr. Peduto's former and current chief of staff, respectively; Mr. Gilman's administrative assistant; and Jack Pawlak, government affairs officer for the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority.

Advertise with us

The signature also was reviewed by a document examiner.

"Even though all potential relevant interviews have been conducted and investigative leads exhausted thus far, at this juncture the results are inconclusive," the nine-page investigation report reads. No one recalled who delivered the letter to the mayor's office, or when Mr. Carter's alleged signature appeared on the document.

As a result of allegations, PPS has implemented “tighter documentation controls,” according to the news release. Any board member who is asked to sign official letters or documents will now record that they did so in a separate ledger.

“To provide accountability, I recommended, and the board president agreed, that letters of support receive the same level of review by the board as contracts, even though letters of support are not binding,” Mr. Weiss said in a statement. “This means a vote would be taken and the results recorded in the board’s meeting minutes. Furthermore, as per school code, this means only the board president would have the authority to sign letters of support. This practice will start immediately.”

Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1590 or @Ebehrman on Twitter.