During the middle of a school day morning last week at the Woodland Hills Promise program, the second-floor hallways were hushed enough to hear the buzz of fluorescent lights above.

Inside classrooms, students ranging from early elementary to high school worked in groups of three to four per room, with at least two teachers in each class.

Behind the scenes, staff members often hand out necessities such as deodorant and socks, items that can be hard to come by for students who come from low-income homes.

But assignments to the program, which the district created in 2009 to devote extra attention to students with behavioral issues, are often met with resistance over concerns about issues such as isolation and stigma.

Advertise with us

“I've recommended kids to come here, and parents will tell them, 'You're not going to that jail school,'” Superintendent James Harris said. “But then you give people tours, and they're like, 'Oh, this is it?’”

He hopes that changes to the program will soon erase the stigma and put students on a more productive track.

Taimere Meggett, 9, listens to his teacher during class at the Woodland Hills Promise Program on Friday, Jan. 18, 2019. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Beginning next school year, Woodland Hills Promise will split into three sections housed across the district: kindergarten through third-grade will be at Edgewood Elementary; grades 4 to 6 will head to Woodland Hills Intermediate; and grades 7 to 12 will be at the junior/senior high school.

Each section will have separate space set aside in the buildings and behavioral experts will be available to help elsewhere in the schools. Officials believe the shift will help students return to their regular classrooms faster and, ideally, allay misgivings about the program.

“Most of our students that come to this building don't know what it's like. They just know the kid who got into trouble is sent there,” Mr. Harris said of the current Woodland Hills Promise home, a former Rankin elementary school in the shadows of the Carrie Furnaces. “So to them, it's prison, that's jail, that's the reform school,” he said. “But if you can remove the stigma from the building, you're good.”

Advertise with us

The Woodland Hills Promise, which has also been called the Rankin Promise or the Wolverine Promise, was originally housed in the high school before it moved to the former elementary school building.

The students enrolled in the Promise demonstrate “at-risk” behaviors, according to the district, and are placed there at the recommendation of their school administration, a counselor or school psychologist after a meeting with the student's parents.

Those students are supposed to be there for 45 days or one academic semester before being transitioned back to their regular school, but historically, some students have ended up in the separate school for much longer than that. At its peak, more than 200 students in grades one through 12 were attending classes at the Promise.

Critics of the Promise and alternative education programs like it have long raised questions about the length of time students spend there, the number of students of color or students with disabilities who receive referrals and the effects of separating those students from their peers in main school buildings.

And the Promise has been the subject of even more scrutiny in recent years as the district has received intense backlash over its disciplinary practices. In 2017, a former behavioral specialist at the Promise faced criminal charges over charges that he grabbed a 13-year-old student by the throat and dragged him down the hallway. Last April, a jury acquitted Joseph Golden III of endangering the welfare of children and simple assault.

Advertise with us

So news about Mr. Harris' plans to change to the Promise was welcomed by many in the district, especially those who work with young people and have long called for reform.

"Even though the kids may have some disruptive behaviors, even though the kids may have some learning disabilities, we still don't want to separate them," said Sam Timbers, assistant pastor at Rankin's Emmanuel Baptist Church and a Woodland Hills parent. “We still want them to be a part of the school district that they're in.”

Leonard Hammonds, a Woodland Hills alumnus and leader of Hammonds Initiative, a youth mentoring program, said eliminating the Promise as a separate school will eliminate the damaging stigma its students carry with them.

"The stigma that comes along with that is that you don't belong in your home school, for whatever reason, you're different from everybody else or you don't belong," said Mr. Hammonds, who works with a number of current and former Promise students. “Once you have that stigma and you go somewhere else, you don't want to be there because you feel less than.”

Emily Cullen, a behavior coach from Glade Run, works with Devontae McClinton, 7, during a class at the Woodland Hills Promise program on Friday, Jan. 18, 2019, in Rankin. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In 2013, the Education Law Center filed a federal civil rights complaint against the Pennsylvania Department of Education, arguing that it provided insufficient oversight for its Alternative Education programs for Disruptive Youth, or AEDYs. A review of those programs is still ongoing by the U.S. Department of Justice, said Cheryl Kleiman, a Pittsburgh-based staff attorney for the ELC.

Advertise with us

The number of students enrolled in those formal alternative education programs have dropped over the years, she said, but the ELC worries that those students are being moved into other informal alternative programs, such as the Promise.

"At the end of the day, whatever you’re calling these programs, however students get in there, separate is not equal," she said. "The separation of students of color and students with disabilities into inferior segregated programs is discrimination."

The changes to the Promise program could be a positive step, Ms. Kleiman said, but keeping those students in separate classrooms within their schools could still be just as exclusionary.

"The closing of Rankin Promise could be an opportunity to ensure that students get the supports and services that they need in the inclusive, regular education classroom," Ms. Kleiman said. "But we remain concerned, and we'll be watching it closely."

Woodland Hills plans to use the current building in Rankin for storage as the district undergoes construction. Mr. Harris hopes to then to the use building to house a new neighborhood school for students in pre-kindergarten to sixth-grade, sometime within the next three to five years.

Advertise with us

One of the challenges associated with the move, district officials say, will to be to manage the triggers that have previously aggravated students who have a track record of disruptive behavior. Examples include encountering an old foe or getting caught up in the chaos in the hallway, Mr. Harris said.

Students who may have been sent to the Promise for fighting may find common ground with their rivals in the more intimate setting away from their school, he said. The test will be how they react when they return to a setting with the peer pressure that prompted the fight in the first place, he said.

“They can get lost in the crowd at the other schools, so we try to individualize things here,” said Pedro Valles, a school resource officer at Woodland Promise who is running for mayor in Braddock. “For a lot of them, that's what they need. They need to be called by their names.”

Next year, officials say they plan to continue providing extra support, but will likely allow students who have shown progress to spend part of the day in regular classrooms, eventually phasing them back there full time when they are ready.

“Some kids don't need to be assigned to a building like this, but they may need some pull-out time,” Mr. Harris said. “So hopefully the program becomes fluid, with people coming in and out for supports, and not just being isolated.”

Matt McKinney: mmckinney@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944, or on Twitter @mmckinne17. Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590.