Just after lunch on Tuesday, Eric Graf got an email from a teacher asking for help — she said a 10th-grader had thrown a phone charger in a fit of frustration.
Heated and inappropriate, sure. But Mr. Graf, an assistant principal in his first year at Woodland Hills High School, knew the infraction also clocked in fairly low on a misbehavior spectrum that includes fights and controlled substances.
And at that point, he had only one side of the story.
Mr. Graf gathered more details. The student, who “went wandering around” after the teacher took the charger, was not a member of the class. So who was she? Was she deliberately trying to hit the teacher?
In the hallway, two voices echoed from a bathroom nearby. Swearing.
She opened the door … I’m gonna walk in … I just want to get my charger.
Read More
“Ladies, let’s go,” Mr. Graf called into the bathroom. “I need to speak to you.”
The voices stopped. Mr. Graf buzzed into his walkie-talkie and asked for a female security guard.
His work had just begun.
* * *
Each day, Mr. Graf arbitrates between five and 10 discipline cases, with some carrying over into the next day. Teachers or staff complete a form that includes the student’s name, infraction type — such as class-cutting, insubordination and unacceptable language — and comments about the incident. Non-criminal discipline referrals run through Mr. Graf, who oversees the 12th grade, and other administrators.
Before students get to his office, teachers may use one of at least nine different interventions such as detention, meeting with the student or calling home to their parent or guardian. Sometimes those fall short, which leads students to Mr. Graf.
But the work demands more than marking a box and handing down a predetermined consequence. Many cases hint at underlying hardships that students may face outside of school, and that may have provoked their actions.
With that in mind, Mr. Graf’s interactions with students take on a delicate but vital balance: holding students accountable while working to earn their trust. If Mr. Graf can build a rapport, he believes, it could discourage future misbehavior and foster healthier learning environments throughout the school.
“For me, school safety and order are important,” he said. “But obviously, as educators, our goal should be to help a child be successful here. So, it’s not necessarily that punitive steps are what’s best for that particular kid.”
Woodland Hills’ discipline practices have been widely scrutinized in recent years after a string of physical altercations between students and now-former school authority figures in the district. Last month, five current and former students reached a $530,000 settlement with the district after they sued in federal court alleging that officials sustained a culture of abuse.

Both in their first year with Woodland Hills, Superintendent James Harris and Woodland Hills High Principal Phillip Woods have each promoted reforms. Part of that effort includes measures outlined in an agreement the school board approved in August with a program that aims to cut down on racially disproportionate referrals of students to the criminal justice system. The model encourages counseling or other measures instead of arrests or expulsions for students who misbehave or commit minor crimes.
The data shows dramatic changes. Through the week of Nov. 12, detentions at Woodland Hills Jr./Sr. High School are down 82 percent from the same point last year, from 1,013 to 187, according to the superintendent’s weekly report. Each of those cases involve a series of choices.
* * *
When Mr. Graf receives a write-up, he begins by pulling up a student’s profile on the district’s online system, focusing on attendance, grades and disciplinary history. He wants to get a sense of where students stand at that specific moment and talk with them about possible troubles outside of school — if they’re ready — and their plans for the future.
From there, he can choose a range of responses, including out-of-school-suspension, community service or after-school yoga (he has led a few classes so far) instead of detention.
“It gives you a lot of flexibility to be creative in deciding what you think is best for the particular situation,” he said. “What’s best for the child and their education, what’s best for the teacher that they’re working with, and you can take all of those things into account and individualize it to help kids.”
Mr. Graf looks for behaviors that may indicate a cry for help, such as a “bizarre” recent incident in which a student was caught taking a drag from an E-cigarette at the start of class. But cases like that, which is a summary offense in Pennsylvania, give him less discretion: it typically results in an automatic suspension with a recommendation of counseling with parental approval.

Roaming the halls between classes, Mr. Graf is a stickler for students wearing hooded sweatshirts over their heads, in large part, because it makes it more difficult to identify them on surveillance.
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette is not identifying students involved in discipline cases to protect their privacy.
The key, generally speaking, is to build honest relationships. During phone calls home after referral meetings to notify parents of their teen’s misbehavior, Mr. Graf often tries to hedge bad news by emphasizing a positive interaction, if he feels there was progress in righting whatever wrong landed the student in his office. No burnt bridges.
During the lunch period he supervises, he greets students, many of them familiar faces. While observing a multimedia class last month, Mr. Graf, 48 — a retired indie-rocker who founded a recording studio in Lawrenceville just over a decade ago — met an aspiring rapper. He asked for a link to the student’s SoundCloud account and offered to share leftover beats he amassed in his years in the studio.
The student’s eyes widened at the prospect of a school administrator encouraging his fledgling rap career rather than ordering him to put his phone away.
But some relationships take more work. Mr. Graf’s most memorable dealing this year involved a 12th-grader who had received several referrals for “petulant, defiant behavior.” Mr. Graf remembered once stopping the student in the hallway and telling him to remove his hat. The student ignored him, refused to identify himself and kept walking. They met in his office later. Still no progress.
“After that meeting, I remember thinking, ‘I'm done with you, just get out. I'm done with you. I'm not talking to you anymore,’ ” Mr. Graf said.
Soon after, the student landed in Mr. Graf’s office a third time after misbehaving in class, this time “mean-mugging” the administrator who had by then become a familiar foe. Why?
“‘I don't even think you’re aware of it, to be honest with you.’ ” Mr. Graf told him. “‘Do you realize how you look?’ I said, ‘Is there something the matter that is making you so angry?’ And I don’t know what exactly it was that I said to him, but the next thing I know, he let his guard down.”
The student confided that he was close friends with Antwon Rose II, the 17-year-old fatally shot by an East Pittsburgh police officer in June, 11 days after the school year ended. He told Mr. Graf that hurt from the summer still absorbed him. The trauma. The anger.
But now he had an ally, someone who understood.
“I see that kid now,” Mr. Graf said, “and it’s like I’ve got him.”
* * *
Mr. Woods, the principal, recently had a similar reminder of the tragic circumstances that can sometimes fuel misbehavior.
Earlier this year, he met with a student who had been accused of an infraction that could have led to expulsion (Mr. Woods did not provide details on the incident.)
The student, who had transferred from another district, had poor attendance, couldn’t focus and was underperforming in class and on the football team.
In the meeting, Mr. Woods shared a story about overcoming adversity, describing the tribulations of a former student who had been shot.
The transfer student then spoke up. He, too, had been shot — three bullets remain lodged in his body. That was why he had left his former school district.
“The parent wanted to get him away from the environment where he got shot,” Mr. Woods said. “So now he’s over here, and I’m like, ‘Wow, it was that bad where he was at that they pulled him out of there and moved him here where everybody’s got these types of issues.’”
Rather than expelling the student, school officials set him up in an after-school mentorship program and provided extra supports — a second chance.
“Those are the kids you love to see when you walk down the hallway because you can smile and say, ‘Hey, we helped that guy,’” Mr. Woods said. “And sadly, there are cases where we’ve done that and they didn’t respond. But the ones where they do are very rewarding.”
The response falls under what Mr. Woods describes as a “learning model” for discipline, a method he prefers when possible, emphasizing teaching rather than punishment alone.
Frustrated by the negative, Mr. Woods recently instituted a biweekly positive referral day in which he only accepts positive “referrals” and names the students and their good deeds over the intercom. He believes the order he hopes comes with discipline reforms will soon drive academic improvements, as well.
But a troubling trend he has noticed in many of the discipline cases stemming from fights and outbursts this year: They often start from a place of deep-seated hurt.
“It’s about something that they’ve been holding in for weeks, months, years,” he said. “And then this is just the opportunity for them to explode.”
* * *

Near the end of the day, the student who flung the phone charger returned to Mr. Graf’s second-floor office, a sun-swept room with a yoga mat, Woody Guthrie poster and acoustic guitar propped in a corner.
During their meeting earlier, Mr. Graf learned that she had just served an in-school suspension for another incident. This time, he decided to take another approach, asking her to instead write an apology to the teacher she had wronged in lieu of another day of punishment.
The student held up her phone to show him the note she penned with the help of another teacher. “I didn’t want to just say, like, I’m sorry,” the student said. “That’s dry. I wanted to say more than that.”
Here’s what she said instead: She wanted to lend her charger to a friend and inadvertently hit the teacher with it. She apologized and acknowledged that excuses won’t make it right, but she meant no harm. She asked for forgiveness and that the teacher still consider her a “respectable young woman.”
“I appreciate you showing me this,” Mr. Graf said. “I think it’s well-worded and well-written.”
He knows the apology may be short-lived, that another incident will likely crop up, based on past experience. If they want to be punitive again, they can do it then.
Until that happens, he showed a student that he cared and gave her a chance to grow.
Chronic problems generally indicate a problem somewhere else in a student’s life, Mr. Graf said.
“It’s our job to deal with it,” he said, “and not just expect that it’s going to go away.”
Matt McKinney: mmckinney@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944, or on Twitter @mmckinne17.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.