At the latest in a series of Act 1080 hearings, suspended West Mifflin Area School District Superintendent Daniel Castagna denied he improperly used district procurement cards to purchase meals and hotel stays with district funds.
The Nov. 14 meeting was held under Section 1080 of the Pennsylvania School Code, which allows it to eventually vote to remove him from office — and void any buyout requirements. Mr. Castagna faces a number of accusations — including neglect of duties, incompetency and immorality under the Public School Code. The 1080 hearings began in late August.
The district’s attorneys showed several 2014 receipts from dinners Mr. Castagna allegedly paid with his procurement card issued by the school district. The restaurant receipts shown at the hearing included $78 to Lone Star Steakhouse, $63 to Ciccanti Ristorante and $73 to Vochelli’s.
Mr. Castagna’s attorney, Colleen Ramage Johnston, said after the hearing that the dinners could have included board members or administrators.
Krisha DiMascio, attorney representing the school district, said a review found that eight West Mifflin administrators spent $25,000 total on their procurement cards in a 12-month period.
Ms. DiMascio asked Mr. Castagna if it was safe to say that he used his procurement card for meal purchases.
Read More
“That is pretty much all I used my ‘P card’ for,” he said, adding if he stayed at the district for a board meeting after regular business hours and did not go home for the break in between, administrators were entitled to a meal in lieu of being reimbursed for mileage.
Mr. Castagna said because he lives too from the district to go home before board meetings, he chose to stay and have a meal.
“As a practice, we would stick to $25 for a dinner,” he said.
There was no written policy on allowing administrators to use procurement cards for meals, according to a recent audit by the state auditor general’s office. State auditors said they found no wrongdoing by the district, but said a policy should be put in place specifically stating the cards could be used for meals instead of mileage reimbursement.
“The auditor general never told us it was improper,” Mr. Castagna said of the practice of administrators using their cards for meals.
Also admitted into evidence was a $199 hotel stay from the Holiday Inn Express in West Mifflin in March 2014.
“That was our community night event,” Mr. Castagna said, adding it was not over until late in the evening.
“I was going to stay here regardless because I live 42 miles from the district,” he said, adding several board members at the time told him to expense the room.
Ms. DiMascio asked Mr. Castagna if on that night in March 2014 he was drinking at West Wood Country Club, and that if the reason he stayed at the hotel because he was too intoxicated to drive home.
“I believe I checked in prior to community night,” Mr. Castagna said.
“Were you so intoxicated at West Wood that you had to have Mr. DiCenzo (board member Anthony DiCenzo) drive you to the Holiday Inn?” asked Ms. DiMascio.
Mr. Castagna replied, “I don’t ever in my 11 years here recall Mr. DiCenzo driving me anywhere,” he said.
“Were you too intoxicated to drive home?” Ms. DiMascio asked.
“No,” Mr Castagna said.
Earlier this year the board voted to put Mr. Castagna on paid administrative leave. In July, the board voted 6-3 to place him on unpaid leave.
Mr. Castagna has filed a federal lawsuit against the district and the six board members who voted to suspend him, saying he had been targeted because he reported wrongdoings by several district employees. Last month, a U.S. District magistrate judge dismissed a motion by the school district to have the lawsuit dismissed.
After the conclusion of the hearing, both the district and attorneys for Mr. Castagna will have 30 days to submit “findings of facts and conclusions of law,” to the hearing officer. The hearing officer will then make a recommendation to the school board, which the board can either accept, reject or modify. The board would then deliberate in executive session and finally cast a vote at a public school board meeting.
The hearing will continue at 6:30 p.m. Nov. 29 at West Mifflin Area Middle School.
Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.