David Brown had planned all along to return to work on Monday after spending several weeks on leave to care for his newborn daughter, Avery Elizabeth, named for his late grandmother, a Holocaust survivor.

But his first day back Monday took on added significance for the Woodland Hills High School teacher, who leads classes on world cultures and the Holocaust, after the mass shooting Saturday at the Tree of Life synagogue, the same building where his parents worship in a separate congregation.

He and his family live in Squirrel Hill. He grew up there. He returned, in large part, because of its cultural identity.

And so on Monday, Mr. Brown embraced the doleful task of explaining to his students that anti-semitism festers beyond their history books and that people in their own community have been gunned down in 2018 – in a neighborhood many of them recognized for its diversity – apparently because of their faith.

Advertise with us

“There was a lot of shock and sadness,” he said. “They wanted to know who the victims were, if I knew the victims, and about the idea of terrorism and being afraid, how sometimes people want that, how the purpose sometimes is to make people feel afraid.”

Similar conversations played out Monday in classrooms throughout the region and country, as teachers did what they could to address the massacre and provide assurances while processing their own shock and grief. The question that seemed to arise again and again: When will it stop?

“In a way, it was cathartic,” Mr. Brown said. “I almost teared up in the process of talking about it during the day. I’m still developing more ideas about what I want to say.”

Extra counselors and social workers greeted most Pittsburgh-area students and educators on Monday.

The Orthodox Jewish Yeshiva Schools, which operates four schools not far from Tree of Life, prepared to help its students process their grief and their trauma, said Rabbi Chezky Rosenfeld, director of development.

Advertise with us

He wasn't aware of any students or teachers who were in Tree of Life at the time of the attack, but many of them were attending services in other synagogues that were placed on lock-down as a result.

Mental health professionals were close by, and teachers were watching carefully for signs of distress and encouraged to answer questions or address misinformation, Rabbi Rosenfeld said. Trauma centers from across the region and across the globe offered advice to the Yeshiva Schools about how to help the students cope.

"They've been guiding us on how to speak to children about this," he said. "I think the underlining message was it's definitely not something that can be ignored."

At Community Day School, a Jewish school that serves students in pre-school through eighth grade, the oldest students honored and recited the names of the shooting victims during their morning prayers, said Jennifer Bails, the school's director of marketing and communications.

"The staff was answering questions where we could and making them feel safe and secure and loved and keeping a really careful eye just to see where extra supports might be needed," she said.

Advertise with us

The school also made space available for parents to discuss and grieve with each other, Ms. Bails said.

Adam Forgie, a seventh- and eighth-grade history teacher at Woodland Hills Academy, said he often begins class with a short CNN video on current events geared toward students. They have talked about mass shootings before, but his students on Monday were reminded of their proximity to the attack when a classmate appeared in the video showing a vigil from over the weekend.

"The most shocking thing to them was that it happened in Squirrel Hill, in Pittsburgh," he said.

Classrooms Without Borders, an affiliate of the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh that provides resources and professional development for teachers to instruct on the lessons of the Holocaust, got requests from hundreds of teachers from Western Pennsylvania and beyond about the best way to talk about their students about the tragedy.

Melissa Haviv, the group's assistant director, said Classrooms Without Borders has encouraged educators to have open discussions about what happened and provide students with an "action step" – writing a letter to one of the victims' families, for instance – so they take a stance on the issue rather than just talking about it.

Advertise with us

"The ideal would be to be able to have a lesson about 'What is anti-Semitism and what is the basis of this kind of violent act? Where do things like this come from?'" she said.

In the North Hills School District, eighth-grade English students had been studying “The Diary of Anne Frank” in recent weeks. On Monday, the three teachers instructed their students to define and describe hatred. They each created posters, completing the sentence “I can overcome hate by…”

Responses widely centered on kindness, respect and inclusiveness, said teacher Vicki Truchan, who suggested the lesson plan to her colleagues in light of the shooting rampage. “The tone was serious and respectful,” she said. “They really wanted to solve the problem.”

The attack personally impacted one of the district’s own. Dr. Peg Durachko, the North Hills School District dentist, was the wife of Richard Gottfried, one of the victims.

Administrators of Pittsburgh Public Schools, which participated in a Classrooms Without Borders trip to visit Holocaust sites in Poland this past summer, reached out to the group for resources on Sunday.

Advertise with us

"Most of the schools have been right on top of this," Ms. Haviv said.

Schools throughout the district began with a moment of silence to honor the 11 lives lost, and school faculty were ready to assist students at any of the district's 54 schools, not just the ones with students from the East End, said school board member Lynda Wrenn.

"There are so many students affected by this," said Ms. Wrenn, who represents the Squirrel Hill area and is a member of Temple Sinai.

College and university campuses across Pennsylvania faced similar challenges on Monday.

Students in Michael Balmert's freshman class at Carlow University had last met on Wednesday, and since then, one of the deadliest attacks against Jews in U.S. history had occurred -- literally, just up the road from where they sat.

Advertise with us

So, what would Mr. Balmert -- a communication professor who for decades has probed human interaction in the class -- say to his students Monday about the carnage?

Should he broach the subject in any real way once he entered the fourth-floor classroom in Antonian Hall?

"I didn't know where it was going to go, but I did know the silence would be deafening," he said.

The question of when and what to say in the aftermath of Saturday's shooting hung over faculty Monday, not only at Carlow, but on campuses across the city, still reeling from the deadly rampage.

Campuses scheduled gatherings, and students and employees received offers of counseling. Faculty suddenly found themselves looking anew at the day's lesson plan.

Advertise with us

In his case, Mr. Balmert decided that it was important to give the 16 students in his "Communication: Personal to Professional" course an opportunity to share their feelings, to understand that it might affect them in varied ways and to take advantage of resources that can help.

To that end, he shared with them the number for resolve Crisis Services, a UPMC-affiliated service.

"I want to at least give you an opportunity to say something if you want to say something," he told them.

After about 10 seconds of silence, a young man who has worked for the Jewish Community Center spoke up. "He was upset because he knew some of the people from the Tree of Life. You could see it in his eyes and on his face and the tenor of his voice."

The student said he knew one of the victims, but referred to him only by his age, a 71-year-old man.

Advertise with us

''I think he was trying to keep his composure," Mr. Balmert said.

Duquesne University made plans for an interfaith service on its campus Tuesday evening “to focus on remembrance, unity and healing” in the wake of Saturday’s mass shooting.

The announcement came in a statement to campus by Duquesne president Ken Gormley. He said the event will be at 7 p.m. in the Student Union Ballroom on the Uptown campus.

“All members of the Duquesne community are welcome to attend, as are members of the broader community,” said Mr. Gormley. “We will make specific outreach to the Jewish community in Squirrel Hill, with whom we have been partners on many interfaith initiatives over the years.”

At Chatham University, less than half a mile from the synagogue shooting, an array of counseling and other outreach was offered to students in need. Efforts to cope also included a meeting between Chatham's vice president for academic affairs, Jenna Templeton, and faculty so they could share information and express their feelings.

Advertise with us

"Shock, sorrow, pain and anger are just some of the emotions that, like many of you, I’m feeling today," Chatham President Daniel Finegold said in a message to campus.

Officials at the University of Pittsburgh created a web page with resources available to those in its community who need them. Leaders there and at Carnegie Mellon University shared messages of condolence with their campuses.

Matt McKinney: mmckinney@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944, or on Twitter @mmckinne17. Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1590 or @Ebehrman on Twitter. Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.