It’s no secret that students of color are not proportionally represented in the number of Pittsburgh students who are tested and classified as “gifted.”

It’s something that educational advocates have called out for years, and a fact that was highlighted early in 2017 in a comprehensive review of the district by the Council of Great City Schools that found that black students in Pittsburgh were only half as likely as white students to be enrolled in gifted and talented programs.

But Pittsburgh Public Schools administrators want to do something about it, as they plan a roll-out of a pilot program that would screen all second-grade students at six schools to identify candidates for formal gifted testing.

If successful, the program would be expanded to the roughly 2,000 second-grade students enrolled in the district, making Pittsburgh Public one of a growing number of school districts across the country to implement universal gifted screening.

Advertise with us

“My hope is to gather information and see if this is a tool we can use for best practices in our district,” said Kashif Henderson, the district coordinator for K-12 gifted and talented students. “Before we commit to something we must learn through information gathered first. We've been at this for a while. It has been a really extensive process on our end with a lot of voices at the table.”

Pending approval by the school board later this month, the pilot would screen all second-grade students at Arlington PreK-8, Banksville K-5, Mifflin PreK-8, Langley K-8, Arsenal PreK-5 and Brookline PreK-8.

Beginning in October and continuing throughout the rest of the school year, the students participating in the pilot will be given one of two computer-based assessments that test their cognitive and reasoning abilities. Students who are identified as potentially gifted would then undergo the district’s existing identification process, which includes an IQ test.

Currently, Pittsburgh students are only tested to determine whether they are gifted if they are recommended for assessment by a parent or a teacher, at any grade level. Parents and teachers will still be able to refer students for testing, but the second-grade screening would help ensure that no students — particularly those in “underserved populations” — are overlooked.

“It’s another way to catch kids that might be getting missed,” said district spokeswoman Ebony Pugh, particularly students of color, low-income students, students with learning disabilities and English-language learners who are traditionally underrepresented in gifted testing and programs.

Advertise with us

Research shows that, nationally, low-income or minority children are 2.5 times less likely to be identified as or placed in gifted classes even though they qualify, said M. Rene Islas, executive director of the Washington, D.C.-based National Association for Gifted Children.

“There's a growing recognition that we need to do something different when it comes to identification and support of gifted students from all backgrounds,” Mr. Islas said. “So there are more and more efforts across the country to mitigate the biases that exist and rectify them.”

Of the 493 students in kindergarten through fifth grade who were tested last year, 142 were black and 273 were white, PPS data show. More than 100 students were tested at Pittsburgh Colfax K-8 in Squirrel Hill in 2017-18. Only one student was tested from each Pittsburgh Langley in Sheraden and Pittsburgh Spring Hill K-5 on the North Side. Black students make up 53 percent of the overall student population, but only 20 percent of the district’s gifted student population.

“Part of the reason why all of us are working to find solutions, including Pittsburgh, is that we know now and it's confirmed by federally funded research that we are systematically leaving children out of our programs,” Mr. Islas said. “That is not just.”

And one of the ways to eliminate that inequity is to screen all children, as early as possible, experts said. Mr. Islas said his organization even recommends screening students more than once.

Advertise with us

“It is a huge first step that (the district) should be commended for taking and for listening to parents and former students who had real clear stories about how the inequities impacted their education or the education of their children,” said James Fogarty, executive director of local education watchdog group A+ Schools.

Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1590 or @Ebehrman on Twitter. 

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.