Dharmesh Vyas has missed at least 19 Fox Chapel Area school board meetings over the past 2½ years as a member.

Keystone Oaks board member David Hommrich has missed at least 23 meetings during that span. His colleague Robert Brownlee: 21.

When Christine Matsko was a member of the Duquesne school board, she missed at least 24 meetings — in a row. She was listed as a member as recently as March 27, but the board has replaced her since then.

These officials have some of the worst attendance records among local school board members, but they’re not alone.

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reviewed more than 2,000 attendance records for Allegheny County school boards between January 2016 and last month.

During that period, 11 current local school board members have missed at least a third of the meetings — and four others have missed at least a quarter of them, according to available minutes. Some boards don’t take formal attendance at all meetings. The analysis does not include committee meetings.

The Duquesne school board, which lacks many of the powers other boards hold because its struggling district is in receivership, appears to have the worst combined attendance. Four members have missed at least a quarter of the meetings, including Cedric Robertson, who has missed half the meetings, records show. He did not respond to a request for comment.

Duquesne board member Laura Elmore missed 38 percent of the meetings the Post-Gazette reviewed.

“I was in the hospital for five or six weeks. I was sick,” she said. “I’m not in there [on the board] for a joke. That’s the only time I’ve missed in eight years, when I was in the hospital.”

Advertise with us

Board president DeWayne Tucker, who has served on the board for more than three decades, said he tries to attend every meeting to watch out for the community’s interests. But some of his colleagues have struggled with health and transportation issues, he said.

Only two members attended the Aug. 9, 2016, business meeting, records show.

The importance of being at meetings is “pretty straightforward,” David Thornburgh, head of the Philadelphia-based good-government group Committee of 70, said in an email.

“Remember the old line that ‘80 percent of success is showing up?' " he said. “It’s hard to figure how you can have the impact you pledged the voters to achieve if you aren’t present when the work is being done.”

Stuart Knade, senior director of legal services for the Pennsylvania School Board Association, said school boards have big responsibilities, balancing educational needs and community interests with available resources. Pennsylvania school boards typically consist of nine unpaid members.

Advertise with us

“It’s fair to say that with any board in any organization, you need as many people around the table as possible,” he said.

Jeff Hanchett, a Woodland Hills school board member, missed a third of the meetings the Post-Gazette reviewed. His absences often are related to his children’s sporting events, where he said he interacts with other parents, who inform his perspective as a board member.

“My daughter graduates this year, and those are games you don’t get back,” he said.

Mr. Hanchett, who said he likely will not run for re-election after his children are no longer in the school district, said he keeps track of board activity when he skips meetings.

The Gateway School Board appears to have the strongest overall attendance. The board had only six absences between all current and former board members since January 2016, records show.

Advertise with us

Vice president Mary Beth Circucci, who has perfect attendance since 2016, said members typically call in if they are unable to attend a meeting. She wondered if her colleagues also might be motivated in part by a rarely invoked state law that says a board may remove a member if they skip consecutive regular meetings.

“You can get kicked off the board if you don’t go to meetings,” she said. “Maybe that’s something some of the other school boards need to look at.”

Bruce Dice, whose firm represents several local districts, including Gateway, said it’s “very, very difficult” to remove an elected official from office — but said it shouldn’t come to that.

“I don’t think there’s any magic to it,” he said. “It’s two meetings a month. If you run, you know that you’re expected to be there.”

In some cases, local board members have racked up absences in the months before their terms end. On the Sto-Rox school board, Gary Drexler was absent 11 of his last 12 meetings in 2017; his colleague William Lenhart missed roll call for 15 of his last 16 meetings. Elliot Rambo, a former Baldwin-Whitehall school board member, missed at least nine meetings in 2017, his last on the board, records show.

Advertise with us

Clairton’s school board president, Richard Livingston, has been at every board meeting the past 2½ years, and has missed only two meetings in 16 years on the board — a surgically repaired broken ankle sidelined him several years back, he said.

“When you run for election and re-election, you represent your area,” he said. “You need to be there to understand what’s going on.”

As for Mr. Vyas, the Fox Chapel Area board member absent nearly half the time, he’s the Pittsburgh Penguins team doctor. He did not return a call requesting comment.

Matt McKinney: mmckinney@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944, or on Twitter @mmckinne17.