The questions were direct, and on the surface they centered on a consultant’s call for a sweeping reorganization of Pennsylvania’s 14 state-owned universities.

But Monday’s hearing on a new report from Rand Corp. also highlighted sharply different views within the Legislature about why the State System of Higher Education is ailing, what role inadequate state funding plays in that, and even who should decide — management or the faculty union — what is taught on the state’s public university campuses.

Rand’s 79-page report, released last week, is the Legislature’s $250,000 answer to an earlier consultant’s study done last year for the State System. This latest effort includes recommendations that the system’s 14 member universities be merged or brought under management of a state-related university, such as the University of Pittsburgh or Penn State University.

Shortly after opening a joint hearing of the Senate and House Education committees, Senate Chair John Eichelberger Jr., R-Blair, called the earlier State System report that cost nearly $400,000 “money that was not well-spent, that didn’t really get us anything we can work with.”

Advertise with us

In testimony that followed, Rand Senior economist Charles Goldman reiterated Rand’s belief that, even if student costs rise and campus access erodes, a major restructuring is the system’s best hope to survive double-digit enrollment losses and financial strains now threatening it.

Questioners immediately took issue with the methodology that was used to study the system of 102,000 students and make proposals to ensure its viability.

State Sen. Andrew Dinniman, D-Chester, minority chair, said most state-related branch campuses have had enrollment losses similar to those at State System schools. But by including Pitt and Penn State’s highly competitive main campuses, Rand skewed that data, as well as graduation rate disparities, making them seem system-only problems.

“I am trying to understand why you would do that?” he asked.

State Sen. Robert Tomlinson, R-Montgomery, raised a more fundamental question. He wondered why Pennsylvania provides $564 million to Pitt, Penn State, Temple and Lincoln universities, schools it does not own, but gave $453 million to the State System schools.

Advertise with us

He said system campuses are the state’s own and have a mission to provide maximum access to students, including many first-generation and minority students.

The state, in essence, is giving money to higher-priced state-related schools and their branches to compete with the State System, even though the system predates those branches, he said.

“It’s kind of like Sheetz giving out money to Wawa to open a store across the street,” he said. “We’re taking those kids who would normally go to our schools and helping them go to another.”

State Rep.Gerald Mullery, D-Luzerne, wanted to know if the system would be in such dire financial straits if not for state appropriation cuts, including a 20 percent reduction nearly a decade ago. Pennsylvania is near the bottom among the 50 states in supporting its campuses and is ranked 47th per-capita by the Grapevine report from Illinois State University.

But Mr. Eichelberger said the answer isn’t to “just keep throwing money at things.” He, like Mr. Goldman, suggested there are other system issues at play, from declining population to an inadequate oversight.

Advertise with us

“I think we've had a system that's mismanaged,” Mr. Eichelberger said. “Competition is good for a lot of things; it certainly is in education.”

He said collective bargaining agreements with the Association of Pennsylvania State College and University Faculties make it difficult to react to declining enrollment or to enable certified high school instructors to teach courses for system credit.

Reacting to Rand’s finding that system enrollment is down by 13 percent since 2010, but instructional faculty have been pared by 2 percent, Mr. Eichelberger said, “They don’t get rid of people because they aren’t allowed to.”

Some questions involved the complexity of combining a state- and non-state-owned university system. Asked by state Rep. Kristin Phillips-Hill, R-York, if the state-related schools told Rand how receptive they are to mergers, Mr. Goldman said they did but that the response and some others in the report were given with the expectation that they not be made public.

Not all the recommendations from Rand are sweeping. One calls for keeping the system largely as is, but exempting it from procurement and construction regulations that add time and cost to projects.

Advertise with us

However, most of the attention has been focused on four recommendations, since Rand calls them changes more likely to have long-term success.

They involve merging the 14 universities regionally, reducing their ranks to as few as five to eight; converting the universities to state-related status, like the University of Pittsburgh or Penn State; putting the State System universities under management of a state-related school for a period of time, perhaps 10 years; or the outright mergers of State System schools.

The earlier State System study was from the Boulder, Colo.-based National Center for Higher Education Management Systems. It proposed no mergers but did call for a governance overhaul, administrative and academic program consolidations and giving campuses greater autonomy.

It also proposed replacing a uniform tuition set by the system’s board of governors with a range, within which schools could set prices to better compete in their regional markets.

The State System includes Bloomsburg, California, Cheyney, Clarion, East Stroudsburg, Edinboro, Indiana, Kutztown, Lock Haven, Mansfield, Millersville, and Shippensburg, Slippery Rock and West Chester universities of Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

Correction, posted April 30, 2018: In an earlier version of this story, the first name of Rand Senior economist Charles Goldman was incorrect.

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner