The class is called "Self, Sin and Salvation."

Students in this special topics course in religious studies at Indiana University of Pennsylvania are expected to understand a range of Christian perspectives. They also are supposed to participate in class.

But on Feb. 28 — as discussion turned to transgender issues, sexism and white male privilege — a dispute erupted pitting a student's right to express himself against a professor's authority to lead her class as she sees fit, without disruption.

The student, Lake Ingle, stands accused of an academic integrity violation. Documents he shared with the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette say he is barred from returning to the class — one he says he needs in order to graduate in May — until he apologizes to the professor and other students.

Advertise with us

This is a description of the alleged violation Lake Ingle received and what he was told he needed to do:

Lake Ingle Violation Explanation (PDF)

Lake Ingle Violation Explanation (Text)

This is the letter that Mr. Ingle said he received from IUP Provost Timothy Moerland barring him from class. Mr. Ingle redacted names while the letter was on his Facebook page:

Lake Ingle Provost Letter (PDF)

Advertise with us

Lake Ingle Provost Letter (Text)

This text was briefly posted to Mr. Ingle’s Facebook page, but taken down:

Lake Ingle Facebook Post (PDF)

Lake Ingle Facebook Post (Text)

A hearing on the matter was held before a panel of four faculty and two students last Friday, Mr. Ingle said. A decision is expected after students return next week from spring break.

Advertise with us

Is this, as Mr. Ingle contends, a case of free speech denied? Or, as the complaint against him states, was it his "refusal to stop talking out of turn" that got him in trouble?

Was Mr. Ingle resistant to hearing opinions of a transgender speaker, or did he simply object to the professor's portrayal of those opinions about discrimination “as hard evidence.”

Officials at IUP declined to comment, citing privacy rules regarding a student’s academic record.

The professor, identified by the syllabus and by Mr. Ingle as Alison Downie, could not be reached for comment.

Mr. Ingle, 23, a senior religious studies major from Tyrone, in Blair County, said the class that day was required to watch a TED Talk presentation by Paula Stone Williams, a transgender woman who raised such topics as "white male privilege," sexism and gender pay disparities.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ingle said that after the video, the professor opened the floor to discussion, but said women were to be allowed to speak first.

After 30 seconds passed and no one spoke, said Mr. Ingle, he took the floor, questioning statements made by the transgender woman and the way the professor had employed the video to introduce discussion.

"I objected to the use of one person’s anecdotal accounts ... as fact," he said in a Facebook post. "I also took this opportunity to point out the official view of biologists who claim there are only two biological genders ... "

He said the professor had maintained during the course that there are 72 genders.

Mr. Ingle said he also complained in the class about what he called a “misuse of intellectual power” by both the instructor and other faculty in IUP's Religious Studies Department over the past few semesters.

Advertise with us

The next day, during a previously scheduled meeting with the professor, Mr. Ingle said she handed him an Academic Integrity Board referral form and a summary of the accusation against him — including “disrespectful objection to the professor's class discussion structure,” a “refusal to stop talking out of turn” and "angry outbursts in response to being required to listen to a trans speaker.”

He contends the issue was instead about the way the professor reacted to a view about gender that was sharply different than hers.

“[I]t is my firmest belief that every human being has the freedom and right to identify, dress, and represent oneself as they see fit,” he said. “This is not transgender, women’s rights, or wage issue. This is about free speech and the constant misuse of intellectual power in universities.”

Mr. Ingle provided a March 2 letter to him from IUP Provost Timothy Moerland saying he was “restricted from any contact, in person, via electronic mail and/or by third party with this class or the professor until this issue is resolved.”

Ms. Downie is identified in the religious studies department web site as having a doctoral degree in Systematic Theology from Duquesne University with a concentration in Christian Feminist Theology. It lists as her academic interests ecofeminist theologies, disability theologies, religious understandings of self and memoir, religious themes in literature and film, and interfaith dialogues.

Advertise with us

The syllabus, provided by Mr. Ingle, said that as an upper level special topics class, preparation is required.

“Learning is an active, sometimes downright uncomfortable and difficult process, which requires committed involvement in a supportive (and, I hope fun) respectful atmosphere,” it reads.

In the Facebook message, which he has since removed, Mr. Ingle said it's not the first time he and a professor have disagreed over course material, and that he has been insulted in the past by professors as “racist" or “sexist.”

"I am someone who has built the reputation of openly voicing my opinion, often in opposition to my Religious Studies instructors,” he wrote.

But he said he believes the accusation against him at hand “is an attempt to bully me into redacting my views.”

Advertise with us

CORRECTION: A previous version of this article misidentified the IUP's Religious Studies Department. The correct name of the department is reflected in this story.

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @ Bschackner