With every student loan refund check that a Carlow University student receives for money borrowed beyond tuition, the school includes a bright orange flyer.

“If this refund results from a student loan, please consider the amount you will ultimately repay before you cash this check,” it reads, going on to note that at current rates, paying back a $10,000 loan will eventually involve an additional $2,000 in interest payments.

“We’re trying to do what we can to get the word out to our students about the dangers of overborrowing,” said Natalie Wilson, director of financial aid at Carlow. “We’re always excited when a student brings their refund check back and says, ‘I changed my mind. I don’t want it.’”

At Carlow, undergraduates carried an average debt load of $22,862 for the graduating class of 2016, the most recent year for which the university has data. Statewide, that figure is $35,759, with Pennsylvania second in the nation in average debt load, behind only New Hampshire, according to the Institute for College Access & Success.

Advertise with us

For the majority of college students, degrees come with a future price tag in the form of student loans. In Pennsylvania, 68 percent of four-year college students graduate with at least some debt, the fourth-highest proportion in the country. West Virginia is first, at 77 percent.

“One thing we’re hearing a lot is, ‘I don’t want my kid to have any loans,’” said Ms. Wilson. “That’s great if you can do it, but with the cost of education these days, the reality is that’s a really difficult thing to do.”

The key for most students, then, is not avoiding debt, but being smart about the debt they have.

At Carlow, and across the country, education about loans starts before students see a dime of the money. The federal government requires students with federal loans to complete entrance counseling before the school can disburse the loan, in the form of a video that they watch on studentloans.gov. Ms. Wilson cautions parents to make sure their child is involved in the process. “One thing we tell parents is do not do the entrance counseling for them,” she said. “Sit down with them if you need to, but do not do it for them.”

Mark Kantrowitz, a student loan expert who was previously based in Cranberry but has since moved to Illinois, believes families should start crunching loan numbers before choosing a school. His advice: estimate a student’s starting salary upon graduation. The total amount of student debt should not exceed that first-year starting salary. “If you’re borrowing more than you can afford to pay off in 10 years, you’re going to struggle to make the payments,” he said.

Advertise with us

Limiting borrowing to money available through Federal Stafford Loans — a maximum of $27,000 over four years for most undergraduates -— is a good rule of thumb, he said. Where students often get into trouble, he said, is not with federal student loans but with private loans, which typically have higher interest rates and higher borrowing limits.

He also provided a guideline for parents taking out their own loans, noting that the total debt to cover all children should be less than the parents’ annual income.

At Carlow, newsletters provide tips for current students, and direct them to additional resources, such as the websites youcandealwithit.com and saltmoney.org.

And while students are still in school, Ms. Wilson also tries to hammer home the importance of keeping current on their loans after graduation— warning them of the lengthy and expensive consequences that result from defaulting on student loans. “The most important thing we tell students is that if they are having trouble making their payments, do not ignore it,” she said. “It will not go away.”

Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1308.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.