Since enrolling at Edinboro University, music performance major Dylan Hollingsworth has channeled his passion by playing drums in the school's marching band, singing for the chorale ensemble and performing with other campus groups.
But the 20-year-old junior from Girard, Erie County, is hitting a different note this fall.
He is out to convince Edinboro to rethink what he considers the unthinkable: its decision to eliminate the music major.
An online petition he and several campus peers have posted is at best a long-shot, he admits. The odds of saving the decades-old major are “slim to none,” he says.
Edinboro, after all, like many regional public universities, has decided that to survive it must adapt its classroom offerings to the new realities of fewer high school graduates, less state funding and a rapidly evolving job market.
Just the same, he's not giving up.
He said Edinboro was a low-cost option near his hometown that helped him grow as a musician. He worries that others pursuing music in northwestern Pennsylvania will end up on a pricier campus, if they can afford it, or miss out altogether on what he has enjoyed.
“I’m passionate about this. I want to show my support for the (music) department,” he said. “It's been like a home to me for the last three years.”
Edinboro, one of 14 universities belonging to the State System of Higher Education, is doing more than simply cut programs in the face of a 35 percent enrollment loss since 2010.
It plans to roll out new offerings in high demand areas, some by next fall, though officials are not identifying specific programs until approvals are in hand. The university also is re-configuring existing degrees in hopes they will be more attractive.
As an example, officials point to the Bachelor of Arts in Biology, which is being reorganized into a Bachelor of Science in Health Sciences.
The Bachelor of Arts in Communications Studies and Bachelor of Arts in Journalism and PR, are transitioning to a new Bachelor of Arts in Strategic Communication.
Still, some programs did not survive the campus-wide review this year that looked at factors including enrollment trends, completion rates and job demand.
With enrollment down 40 percent between 2012 and 2016 in the Bachelor of Arts in Music/Music Education and in the Bachelor of Arts in Music, officials said Edinboro could no longer justify those degree offerings. The 36 remaining majors were notified last month that no new students would be accepted and that efforts would be made to ensure students already on campus could get the courses they need to finish their degrees.
Edinboro’s Music and Theater Department is housed in the William P. Alexander Music Center, named for a professor emeritus, former department chair and published composer who transformed its offerings starting in the 1960s and became a financial supporter.
Stroll the halls or rehearsal rooms day or night, and students can be heard and seen making music. It’s a close-knit and unique community on campus, said Tony Peyronel, interim chair of the department.
He said it’s not as if his department is going away. Music will still be taught, both in the minor and as general studies courses, and various groups from the "Spirit of the Scots" marching band to the Pipes Band and other ensembles will continue to make music.
He said what happened to the music major at Edinboro is tied to factors both on campus and off, including a decline in emphasis on music at some area high schools.
"I understand the students' disappointment in losing the major, but my role has been trying to focus more on ways to keep the department vital in other areas, by maintaining the ensembles and by maintaining and perhaps redoing the minor to make it more attractive,'' he said. "Also, we're looking at the possibility of developing some new programs, including interdisciplinary ones."
Most of the system's 14 state universities face enrollment losses and budgetary woes, especially in parts of the state with declining population. The system's chancellor Frank Brogan, retired this summer, just after receiving recommendations for overhauling the system. Some of those ideas are now being implemented under interim leadership.
Enrollment at Edinboro reached 8,642 in 2010. By this fall, it was down to 5,575 students, and faculty and administrators say do not expect to get fully back to that peak.
Reconciling a smaller campus with program spending has been less acrimonious at Edinboro than on other State System campuses.
Edinboro's president H. Fred Walker promised a data-driven review, and to drive home the notion of transparency, he posted on the school's web site program-specific information, overall goals and streamed campus town halls live. He also pulled no punches in saying Edinboro's future was on the line.
Marc Sylvester, assistant chair of math and computer science who heads the campus chapter of the Association of Pennsylvania State College and University Faculties, said the process for reviewing programs "was generally good."
The changes to date were accomplished without tenured faculty layoffs, in part because Edinboro already had 73 faculty departures through natural attrition in the last five years.
Of the program review, he said, "Most things were maintained, some things were added and a few things were taken away."
No one wants to see academic programs go away, he said. But he also said there is enthusiasm among faculty working to develop new programs, and job postings for teaching positions give him optimism that "the university is finding its way back to being even healthier than it was."
But Mr. Hollingsworth said the school should have notified students earlier about the decision to end the music major. He said other students in the major and alumni are unhappy, too.
So far, the petition bearing his name on change.org has garnered about 4,000 signatures.
Mr. Hollingsworth said he worries that as the major winds down, certain courses might not be readily available, and making them up could require applying to, and auditioning for, another university's music program.
Mr. Hollingsworth said he believes music graduates are getting jobs in sufficient numbers to warrant keeping the degree. He said Edinboro is wrongly closing a door on a part of its future and that of students who enroll.
"I feel this is taking away a career opportunity for many young musicians who do not have a choice outside this university," he said.
In addition to Edinboro, the 14 system schools also include Bloomsburg, California, Cheyney, Clarion, East Stroudsburg, Indiana, Kutztown, Lock Haven, Mansfield, Millersville, Shippensburg, Slippery Rock and West Chester universities of Pennsylvania.
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @BschacknerPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.